Essay on Analysis Of Colm Toibin 's ' Brooklyn '

Essay on Analysis Of Colm Toibin 's ' Brooklyn '

Length: 1054 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In Colm Toibin’s novel “Brooklyn”, Rose’s connection to her home is through her role and obligations to her family. Her commitment to her mother and sister limits her opportunities for marriage and a family of her own. However, she manages to create a life for herself that is separate from her family, one that she is happy with. Despite her personal satisfaction with her own life, she sends Eilis away to live in Brooklyn because she wants a better life for her. Rose is therefore not totally defined by her connection to home, but it appears that she wished to spare her sister the hindrances she experienced.

In the novel, Rose is somewhat defined by her role in the family. She is the family’s provider, her mother’s carer and a role model for her sister. When her father died, “Rose had taken care of everything”. Because her mother’s pension is small, rose assumes the role of provider, and we are told that “her wages paid for most of their needs”. In addition to paying for the household, Rose also provides her sister Eilis with financial and emotional support. She tries to find her an office job in Enniscorthy, and pays for her books for her bookkeeping and rudimentary accountancy course. Instead of chastising Eilis for accepting the job with Miss Kelly, Rose acts supportively, giving her a new cardigan and some lipstick. While in Brooklyn, Rose continues to provide Eilis with financial and emotional support, giving Eilis “money to live on”until she is “settled in her job”, and suggesting in a postscript that Eilis “might like sometimes to write to her separately about private matters or things that might worry their mother too much”


The responsibilities she has assumed toward her family hinder her in important wa...


... middle of paper ...


...on’t know when she learned of her illness. Eilis wonders “if she had known before Eilis had left”. Because the story is told in the third person but limited to Eilis’ perspective, we don’t get much insight into Rose’s inner world. It is left for the reader to speculate that perhaps Rose did know beforehand, and wanted to save Eilis from being obligated to taking Rose’s place in the family after she passed away. Perhaps Rose wanted to spare Eilis the restrictions she experienced due to her responsibilities.




In conclusion, Rose is both defined and hindered in ways by her connection to her family, but she manages to create a life for herself outside of the home. Rose expresses satisfaction in her life. However, it seems that she wants a different life for her sister, and we presume that Rose did not want her sister to be hindered in the same way she had.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Representation of Home in Brooklyn: A Novel

- In Brooklyn: A Novel, Colm Toibin narrates the experience of a young woman named Eilis Lacey, who leaves behind Enniscorthy, Ireland to start a new life in Brooklyn, New York. Like many other novels about migrants, Eilis’s relationship to “home” and Brooklyn is represented through her experiences and feelings. Eve Walsh Stoddard states that “Home points at rather than determines its referent. Thus we may say that ‘home is where the heart is’ or home is where one’s family is,”’ in her essay “Home and Belonging among Irish Migrants: Transnational versus Placed Identities in The Light of Evening and Brooklyn: A Novel,” (156)....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Book Review]

Better Essays
1387 words (4 pages)

Essay about Analysis of Colm Tóibin's Short Story, A Journey

- Life is a journey, a cycle. We start somewhere and end somewhere, we are on a round trip. We experience different seasons and grow both physically and mentally. But some point in life all of us realize that we want last, live forever. From a very early age on we are being told that we all one day will pass away and be buried in the ground. The short story:”A Journey”, written by Colm Tóibin, takes us on a journey together with a young boy called David and his mother Mary. The short story, A Journey, starts off in a dialogue, in medias res, between the son and his mother, where we also are introduced to a 3 rd person narrator....   [tags: literary analysis]

Better Essays
915 words (2.6 pages)

Essay about Analysis Of The Poem ' Crossing Brooklyn Ferry '

- It has been said many a times how New York is a magical, wondrous, fantastical land of dreams. Many believe this statement and it is one of the main reasons why New York City is one of the most visited places in America. Countless events have happened in New York that aided its reputation as a great place to be. And New York is a great place to be, come and visit the sights and feel the pullulating streets, however, it does not seem to be a great place to stay. According to Walt Whitman’s “Crossing Brooklyn Ferry,” New York is a wonderful place to be, and according to Joan Didion’s “Goodbye To All That” New York is a bad place to stay....   [tags: New York City, New Jersey, Brooklyn, Walt Whitman]

Better Essays
1086 words (3.1 pages)

Analysis Of The Poem ' Crossing Brooklyn Ferry ' Essay

- Walt Whitman’s poem “Crossing Brooklyn Ferry” gives a light euphonious feel and reveals all the passion Whitman receives from being in such a grand city overflowing with expectations. The third part of the poem talks about the unity of the people of New York, how they all experience the same experiences. The piece is filled with a lot of positive words that impact the view of the person reading the poem. The start of the excerpt from the poem, “It avails not, time nor place” speaks of how neither time nor place can aid in the separation of New Yorkers....   [tags: New York City, New Jersey, Brooklyn, United States]

Better Essays
811 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on Brooklyn and The Translator

- In the novels Brooklyn and The Translator we see the theme of the home prevalent in many different forms. The idea of home, leaving home, and returning home is a very proficient focus point for the paper. In addition, the concept of home means something very different to each character and how issues such as immigration/emigration, exile, and going back home play out in the narrative. From a rainy Ireland to a bustling New York City, or perhaps from the Western part of Sudan to Chad; the people demonstrate the idea of nationalism and a purpose of being....   [tags: Novel Analysis]

Better Essays
1004 words (2.9 pages)

Essay about Absolut Brooklyn Campaign’s Objective

- In the summer of 2011, Absolut Vodka launched a limited edition new flavor red apple and ginger of vodka and named it Absolut Brooklyn. They collaborated with Spike Lee, a filmmaker. He designed the style of the picture that was presented on the bottle. He drew a stoop because that is where he grew up in and the stoop was a place for entertaining. Before this campaign Absolut already produced three city themes which were New Orleans, Los Angeles, and Boston. Brooklyn was chosen for several reasons....   [tags: vodka, brooklyn, spike lee]

Better Essays
1299 words (3.7 pages)

Essay about Crossing Brooklyn Ferry by Walt Whitman

- Through the use of simple diction, Whitman is able to traverse both time and distance and connect with his readers as so few other poets can. His mastery of verbiage draws readers into the poem, as few other poets can. In “Crossing Brooklyn Ferry,” Whitman creates a vignette into the Brooklyn of the past, and he connects it to the present, though in surprising ways. The omnipresence of Whitman allows the reader to envision themselves into the settings he created- and to interpret them into modern language....   [tags: Crossing Brooklyn Ferry, Walt Whitman ]

Better Essays
868 words (2.5 pages)

Essay A Tree Grows in Brooklyn

-             A Tree Grows in Brooklyn is an appropriate name for the book. It’s about 7 years of Frances Nolan’s life. The book’s title is highly symbolical and took me several passes through it before I understood it completely. In the beginning of the book the author talks about the “Tree of Heaven”. “No matter where the seed fell, it made a tree which struggled to reach the sky”, is an excerpt from the first page of Book One. Until you finish the book or at least most of it you think the author is talking about a type of tree and the title makes absolutely positively no sense whatsoever because of that....   [tags: A Tree Grows in Brooklyn Essays]

Free Essays
471 words (1.3 pages)

Coming of Age in A Tree Grows in Brooklyn Essay

- Coming of Age in A Tree Grows in Brooklyn Betty Smith's A Tree Grows in Brooklyn presents the problems of a child growing up, the coming of age when one meets challenges and overcomes obstacles. The protagonist, Francie Nolan, undergoes a self-discovery as she strives to mature living in the Brooklyn slum despite its poverty and privation. Thus, Smith's thematic treatment of the struggle of maturity has become for the reader an exploration of loneliness, family relationships, the loss of innocence, and death and disease....   [tags: Tree Grows in Brooklyn Essays]

Free Essays
1256 words (3.6 pages)

"Crossing Brooklyn Ferry" by Walt Whitman Essay

- "Crossing Brooklyn Ferry" by Walt Whitman Recurring Images and Motifs in "Crossing Brooklyn Ferry" In the poem "Crossing Brooklyn Ferry" by Walt Whitman, there are many recurring images and motifs that can be seen. Whitman develops these images throughout the course of the poem. The most dominant of these are the linear notion of time, playing roles, and nature. By examining these motifs and tracing their development, ones understanding of the poem becomes highly deepened. Whitman challenges the linear notion of time by connecting past with future....   [tags: Poem Poet Whitman Brooklyn Ferry Essays]

Better Essays
937 words (2.7 pages)