Essay Analysis Of Angela Garcia 's The Pastoral Clinic

Essay Analysis Of Angela Garcia 's The Pastoral Clinic

Length: 1034 words (3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Angela Garcia’s The Pastoral Clinic is a riveting collection of illness narratives depicting the lives of heroin addicts, specifically in the underserved area of Espanola Valley, New Mexico. She genuinely provides her audience the reality behind a marginalized population that suffers from an addiction crisis as well as the presence of institutional structures that criminalize addicts for their illness. This paper will focus on care and chronicity as two central ideas of Garcia’s work from two lenses of understanding. The first lens is the Foucauldian approach to bio-power and bio-bureaucracies, a mode of analysis that the author utilizes quite sufficiently to support her argument of “restoring the embodied, economic and moral dynamics of addiction” (Garcia 2010, 10 ). This approach illustrates care as a product of chronicity and vice versa. The second lens is Gramsci’s theory of hegemony and resistance, a mode of analysis that Garcia does not incorporate in her work but will expand her argument to include heroin addiction as a social justice issue. Chronicity will be examined as a product of a medical hegemony, while care will be understood as an element of resistance; the two themes will now be regarded as opposing forces that constitute the never-ending victories of hegemonic ideals due to the presence of resistance.
The Lens of Biopower and Bio-Bureaucracies: Care and Chronicity

Angela Garcia explicitly draws upon Foucauldian theory to expand her argument on care and chronicity as well as its impact on the lives of heroin addicts. Bio-power and bio-bureaucracies represent institutional structures that contribute to the formation of addiction as well as the quality of care that an addict will receive for their condition. More...


... middle of paper ...


...’s fault in the eyes of the law, thus blame is placed upon the individual who fails to uphold the expectations of the judicial system (Garcia 2010, 18). The influence of bio-power and bio-bureaucracies does not stop here; it plays a prominent role in the mindset of heroin addicts.
The chronology of addiction alters the mentality of the afflicted, which inherently dismantles any sense of hope for full recovery. In the medical realm, heroin addiction is described to be a chronic illness and patients embody this term as they are persuaded to accept the permanence of their condition (Garcia 2010, 16). Alma, one of Garcia’s informants, affirms that “her relapse and readmission were simply part of the order of things, simple cause and effect” (2010, 79). This one of the many examples of how a biomedical framework shapes the experiences of a patient in a despairing light.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Mayo Clinic: A Performance Management Assessment Essays

- At its most fundamental core, quality improvement of healthcare services and resources requires disciplined attention to the measurement, monitoring, and reporting of system performance (Drake, Harris, Watson, & Pohlner, 2011; Jones, 2010; Kennedy, Caselli, & Berry, 2011). Research points to performance measurement as a significant factor in enabling strategic planning processes and achievement of performance goals (Tapinos, Dyson & Meadows, 2005). Thus, without a system of measurement that accounts for the performance behaviors of healthcare professionals, managers and administrative employees, quality improvement remains a visionary abstraction (de Waal, 2004)....   [tags: Mayo Clinic Case Study]

Better Essays
2102 words (6 pages)

Analysis of Angela's Ashes Narrated by Frank McCourt Essay

- Analysis of Angela's Ashes Narrated by Frank McCourt Angela's Ashes: A Memoir is Frank McCourt's acclaimed memoir. It charts the author's childhood from his infant years in Brooklyn, through his impoverished adolescence in Limerick, Ireland, to his return to America at the age of nineteen. First published in 1996, McCourt's memoir won the 1997 Pulitzer Prize in the category of best Biography/Autobiography, and has gone on to become a worldwide bestseller. McCourt, who for many years taught writing in a New York public high school, waited for over forty years to write about his troubled youth....   [tags: Angela's Ashes Memoirs Frank McCourt Essays]

Better Essays
4634 words (13.2 pages)

Swot Analysis For The Satellite Clinic Essay

- SWOT Analysis The objective of a SWOT analysis is to help leaders develop an awareness of the factors involved in the decision. It helps leaders to identify both internal and external influences that will affect the sustainability of the satellite clinic. Perhaps most importantly, a SWOT analysis allows leaders to determine if the project’s strengths and opportunities outweigh its inherited weaknesses and threats (Taylor, 2016). Appendix B provides a summary of the SWOT analysis. Strengths PMH has an extraordinary amount of local support....   [tags: Health care, Health care provider, Medicine]

Better Essays
703 words (2 pages)

The Crowded Clinic : Critical Analysis Essay

- The Crowded Clinic: Critical Analysis The Crowded Clinic Case Study (Colorado State University - Global, n.d.) discusses the issues of practice management as they apply to access to care. Access to care may be as inconvenient as lengthy patient wait times to issues far more serious that may have a profound effect on the health and well-being of a single patient or an entire cohort. In order to properly address the issue and look for a remedy, it is necessary to understand the underlying conditions that create the problem before creating the means to manage the change required to correct the problem....   [tags: Health care, Health care provider, Culture]

Better Essays
1420 words (4.1 pages)

Essay about Angela Carter's Wise Children

- Angela Carter’s attitude towards her work has always been one with intrinsic feminism at its roots. Carter’s feminist attitude within her novel Wise Children has given the reader a much more realistic and intuitive approach to Shakespeare. Carter conveys ideas of feminism through matriarchy and the power of womanhood, or rather new family structures of an acceptance of an absentee father. In some aspects, her work is an invitation to criticisms towards Shakespeare’s lack of matriarchal concentration and sometimes all together absentation, and realistic approaches towards female characters....   [tags: Angela Carter, Feminism]

Better Essays
2737 words (7.8 pages)

Essay Analysis Of ' The Bloody Chamber ' By Angela Carter

- In my analysis of ‘The Bloody Chamber’ by Angela Carter, I have decided to analyze hw role-reversal plays a large part in this story. The POV is set in first person, with the Heroine as the narrator. The story is told through her eyes and she is believed to be a reliable source because she clearly outlines unfortunate events that happen to her, such as the mark of shame on her forehead of the blood-stained key. I believe for many that Carter may have wanted her story to defy the cultural norm of fairytales where the female character always needs to be saved from a situation- this typically places female characters in roles that make them seem fragile, weak, and helpless....   [tags: Marriage, Wife, Husband, The Chamber]

Better Essays
1497 words (4.3 pages)

Angela's Ashes by Frank McCourt Essay

- Angela's Ashes by Frank McCourt Life can be hard. A hard life though without hope can be devastating. The first 19 years of life for Frank McCourt, the author of the 364 page biography Angela's Ashes, were very difficult and full of change. Originally published in 1996, Angela's Ashes shows the reader the life of a poor Irish Catholic family through the eyes of a young boy. Frank McCourt was born in New York in the 1930's, but his family moved back to Ireland when he was an infant and most of his story is set in Limerick....   [tags: Frank McCourt Angela's Ashes]

Free Essays
1013 words (2.9 pages)

Angela's Ashes by Frank McCourt Essay

- Angela's Ashes by Frank McCourt "When I look back on my childhood I wonder how I survived at all. It was, of course, a miserable childhood: the happy childhood is hardly worth your while. Worse than the ordinary miserable childhood is the miserable Irish childhood, and worse yet is the miserable Irish Catholic childhood." Thus begins the highly celebrated memoir by the name of Angela's Ashes, written by Frank McCourt. In this book Frank McCourt writes about his childhood, how his parents meet in New York and then decide to return to Ireland....   [tags: Frank McCourt Angela's Ashes]

Free Essays
958 words (2.7 pages)

Economic Discrimination in Frank McCourt's Angela’s Ashes Essay

- Economic Discrimination in Frank McCourt's Angela’s Ashes As Jerome K. Jerome once said, “It is easy enough to say that poverty is no crime. No; if it were men wouldn’t be ashamed of it. It is a blunder, though, and is punished as such. A poor man is despised the whole world over.” This famous quote describes the way poor people are discriminated against and despised around the world by those who are better off. In the novel Angela’s Ashes, by Frank McCourt, the characters are greatly discriminated against by all different parts of society because of their poverty....   [tags: Angela Ashes Essays]

Better Essays
1414 words (4 pages)

Essay Gothic Conventions in The Bloody Chamber by Angela Carter

- Gothic Conventions in The Bloody Chamber by Angela Carter The Gothic is often distinguished by an atmosphere of terror, darkness, mystery, the unexplained and the transgression of boundaries. This essay will attempt to dissect how Angela Carter uses Gothic conventions in the passage taken out of her novel, 'The Bloody Chamber'. One of the most predominant conventions manipulated here is that of a dark and mysterious atmosphere. Throughout the passage the feeling of terror prevails. This is first started by the protagonist's taking of a "forbidden key"....   [tags: The Bloody Chamber Angela Carter]

Better Essays
1355 words (3.9 pages)