Analysis of Alan Roger´s Evidence of Evolution Essay

Analysis of Alan Roger´s Evidence of Evolution Essay

Length: 1803 words (5.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Evolution has been a constantly debated topic with central importance in defining the origin of man. Creationism is still a common belief in modern society, somehow maintaining validity through assumed truth; this belief attained its popularity many years before the concept of evolution itself, yet is the main opponent of the theory of evolution. Alan Rogers, author of In Evidence for Evolution, provides thorough arguments against creationism, ranging from molecular to morphological data. He argues that many creationists use “arguments from personal incredulity,” meaning that a lack of a fathomable explanation to a question is proof of an answer. Creationists are strong proponents of these arguments; rather than acknowledging the overwhelming amount of scientific facts for evolution, the lack of explanation to compliment biblical record is used as proof against evolution. Rogers himself states: there is no active research into the occurrence of evolution; that issue was settled centuries ago and is no longer an interesting scientific question (p. 3). From an aspiring biologist’s perspective, evolution as fact has not been questioned for many years. Unfortunately, popular culture dictates its truth through social beliefs rather than concrete evidence. Another author, Steven Pinker, sees Rogers’ evidence as for the political controversy of evolution, rather than its occurrence. Roger’s interpretation of creationism not only sheds light on the importance of evolution, but also proves its correctness with minimal room for speculation.

The recognized theory of evolution, distinguished using the terminology “natural selection,” began with On the Origin of the Species, by Charles Darwin. Darwin noted that as he moved throughout the Ga...

... middle of paper ...

... Rogers’ addressing of skepticism and evidence against it shows his desire for truth. Rogers presents common questions from skeptics of evolution throughout the literature. Rogers does an extraordinary job at avoiding patronizing remarks, although a minor hint of bias appears every so often in his phrasing. One could argue that the entire book is biased; I refute this statement by referencing the extensive evidence behind Rogers’ theories. Rogers even states that his conclusions may be perfectly logical and still not true; he provides factual evidence to the reader and not biased opinions. He addresses skepticism with an open mind and recognizes the scientific advances that come from questioning theories. In order to properly prove a point, one must provide all evidence possible and address all known skepticisms: Rogers does an extraordinary job of doing just that.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Evidence for Evolution Essay

- Evolution and Diversity
 Evolution and Diversity The foundation for the theory of evolution was laid by Charles Darwin (Rose, n.d.). He developed hypotheses about natural selection which helped scientists develop the theory. Evolution is a theory and not a hypothesis because evolution has been proven by vast amounts of scientific data, research, and testing. The definition of a hypothesis is an educated explanation that needs to be researched and tested but has not yet been proven (Earman, 1984)....   [tags: Scientific Research ]

Better Essays
916 words (2.6 pages)

The Evidence of Evolution: On the Origin of Species Essay

- Evolution is defined as the process by which different kinds of living organisms are thought to have developed and diversified from earlier formed during the history of the Earth. Evolution is the reason we have so many different species. The basis of evolution comes from survival of the fittest. Those who do survive create an offspring even more fit for survival. The process of natural selection supports the idea of survival of the fittest and plays a key role in evolution. For species to evolve, there must be diversity present....   [tags: natural selection, on the tree of life, survival]

Better Essays
866 words (2.5 pages)

Critical Analysis of Evil as Evidence for Christianity by Gregory E. Ganssle

- Critical Analysis: Evil as evidence for Christianity Evil as Evidence for Christianity is Gregory E. Ganssle’s attempt to logically explain and disprove the claim that evil points toward there being no God. Ganssle claims exactly the opposite, that evil by definition points toward the existence of God with much more substantial evidence than the latter. Ganssle states that there are “three ways in which our thoughts about evil represent facts that point to God ”. Humans have moral objections of good and evil, evil distorts good reality away from its objective purpose or end, and the objective nature of evil rather than the concept of evil points to God....   [tags: Evidence, Creation]

Better Essays
712 words (2 pages)

Essay on The Evidence Against Evolution

- The theory of evolution was published by an evolutionist called Charles Darwin in 1838. He also proposed the theory of Natural Selection, sometimes known as survival of the fittest. Evolution is when a change occurs in the genetic source within your Deoxyribonucleic Acid, this is believed to happen over an extremely long period of time. Natural Selection is the process whereby organisms better adapted to the nature surrounding them tend to survive a longer period of time due to the fact that they are more suited to the environment in a stable manner....   [tags: genetics, complexity, fossils]

Better Essays
663 words (1.9 pages)

Essay about Proof of the Existence of Evolution

- Since the publishing of Charles Darwin’s Origin of Species, where the theory of evolution has arisen from, people have debated Creationism versus Evolution. Through supporting facts and statements the theory of evolution will be defended as being more than just a theory, and proven as fact. Evolution as a fact is reinforced through; scientific studies on DNA, genetics and its mutilation, the Fossil Record and the change in earlier species that has been found, and finally the distribution of related species of animals over a broad geographical range....   [tags: evolution]

Better Essays
625 words (1.8 pages)

Theory of Evolution Essay

- Man could not evolve to any other state, because he was made in the ultimate state. He was made in the image and likeness of the Father so there was no need for evolution; hence, there was no sign of evolution from the beginning. Since sin came into the world, man has been deceived into thinking there is evolution. We are not talking about the theory of evolution that says man started from an amoeba or as an ape and eventually began to walk upright; not that evolution, but evolution in the sense of development....   [tags: Evolution]

Better Essays
1355 words (3.9 pages)

Evidences of the Theory of Evolution Essay

- Evolution is not simply a matter of change over time. Lots of things change over time, but they aren't all examples of evolution because they don't involve descent through genetic inheritance. Evolution is the process by which different kinds of living organisms are thought to have developed and diversified from earlier forms during the history of the earth. In genetic terms it is a change in the occurrence of alleles in a population over time. There is so much evidence that supports the theory of evolution....   [tags: Biogeography, Creationists]

Better Essays
621 words (1.8 pages)

The Lack of Evidence for Creationism Essay

- On November 24th 1859 one of the most influential books ever written was published. I am of course referring to the Origin of Species. The origin of species was published by Charles Darwin, it outlined the theory of evolution and was immediately ridiculed by the religious community as it went against the story of creation in the bible and to this day it is not fully accepted as the truth of our existence. The book wasn’t published light heartedly, Darwin himself was as devout Christian as was his wife as such the publishing of the book was a big decision for him, he put in masses of work into collecting proof of evolution; he even undertook a 5 year ship journey around the world collecting e...   [tags: evolution, mutations, species]

Better Essays
692 words (2 pages)

Essay about The Benefits of Evidence Based Practice in Nursing

- Evidenced Based Practice (EBP) is essential to enable all nurses to provide the most current up to date practises for their patients. This process involves research, systematic review of current practises, critical thinking skills, evaluation and application to the clinical setting. In addition to this, the nurse must take into account the patients’ preferences. For nurses to have professional autonomy they must be able to justify their actions and demonstrate an understanding of why they perform the tasks they do....   [tags: Evidence Based Practice (EBP)]

Better Essays
2114 words (6 pages)

Creation vs. Evolution Essay

- The purpose of this essay is not to prove “Darwinian” evolution, as the writer would be performing a feat already done by others, but to examine a certain track of thought amongst Creation proponents. Specifically their noting certain improbabilities of evolution's ability to “design.” I'll evade defining the individual concepts because they've all been described before, and far better than I could manage, although I'll point out that micro/macro evolution distinction is largely Creationist lingo, as is the “kind” terminology....   [tags: Evolution]

Better Essays
1386 words (4 pages)