Analysis Of ' A Rose For Emily ' Essay

Analysis Of ' A Rose For Emily ' Essay

Length: 1393 words (4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

More often than not, when analyzing the similarities and differences between a written story and its reimagined film version, the differences leave an altered impression on the audience. In the short story, A Rose for Emily, the outstanding differences take the viewer on a ride they didn’t experience when reading the story. The biggest alteration is how the story’s chronological order takes a twist as they place the events back into an order in which they happened. Even though it is easier to follow, the original version left the audience dazed and confused for a reason. It made it less predictable, and allowed the reader to guess why Emily did those things. The offbeat approach the film takes adds more romance, rearranges the original time set, and leaves the author in a state of boredom due to the predictability factor.
To make a movie more admirable, directors often tweak small things to draw the viewer in with suspense, drama, and action. Therefore, in an attempt to keep that perfect mix, some crucial elements get dropped off to the side similar to an outdated phone. In the case of A Rose for Emily, the director takes the liberty to redo the way the story is presented by putting the series of events in the correct chronological order. Although it does make the story easier to follow, people lose the sense of confusion they had obtained when reading the story. That sense of confusion is important to the experience and was done for a reason. In the book, people are more focused trying to keep up on what is going on and where they are on the time line that they miss the subtle clues about Emily’s true mental health.
Next, the film version seemed to put more emphasis on a romantic aspect than the original. The courtship seemed t...


... middle of paper ...


...ies Shutter Island and Halloween. One movie leaves more questions than answers while the other is foreseeable. While neither genre is bad, it brings example from each.
Although movies may not turn on exactly as one had imagined it to be, everyone’s creative effort should be noted. The film version and the story version of A Rose for Emily differs greatly because of each of the creative differences each person took. It is clear that they do not leave the same effect which is the same. Elements of the book were played around with and in the end didn’t produce as riveting of a piece as the original. It is often the reason people despise most movies based on books because they don’t leave the same impression. Even though there was great potential, the movies change in the original time line order left the viewer with predictability and with a feeling of disappointment.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Emily Character Analysis of A Rose for Emily Essay

- Miss Emily Up Close In the short story of A Rose for Emily, the main character illustrates a disturbed individual that doesn't want to separate herself from a deceased loved one. Everyone knows what its like to loose a loved one, but the town of Jefferson had no idea how hard Emily had taken death until they unraveled her deep, dark secret. People knew what it must have been like to be Emily. They knew the type of life she had lived and felt bad for the way her father had kept her all cooped up and sheltered away from any man....   [tags: A Rose For Emily, William Faulkner]

Better Essays
929 words (2.7 pages)

Analysis of A Rose For Emily by William Faulkner Essay

- Analysis of A Rose For Emily “A Rose for Emily”, by William Faulkner, begins and ends with the death of Miss Emily Grierson, the main character of the story. In the story William Faulkner uses characterization to reveal the character of Miss Emily. Faulkner divided the story “into five sections, the first and last section having to do with the present, and the now of the narration, with the three middle sections detailing the past” (Davis 35). Faulkner expresses the content of Miss Emily’s character through physical description, through her actions, words, and feelings, through the narrator’s direct comments about her, and through the actions, words, and feelings of other characters....   [tags: A Rose for Emily, William Faulkner]

Better Essays
1295 words (3.7 pages)

A Rose For Emily Novel Analysis Essay

- “A Rose for Emily” written by William Faulkner focuses on the sorrowful life of Miss Emily Grierson in the town of Jefferson. Emily has lived a life of solitude in her once white house. She tried to live the most fulfilling life possible but was held down. She tried to keep her life and land private, but always had those passersby watching her life as if it was a television show. Miss Grierson was a woman who was seen as somewhat of a problem to the town of Jefferson. She was also seen as somewhat of a pity....   [tags: william faulkner, emily grierson]

Better Essays
553 words (1.6 pages)

A Rose for Emily Plot Analysis Essay

- Significant Quote: “Alive, Miss Emily had been a tradition, a duty, and a care.” Plot: The plot of “A Rose for Emily” shows the later years of the main character, Emily Grierson, with flashbacks to her life interspersed between. It begins with the reader learning of her passing, developing into a story that provides insight in to her reclusive nature and past dealings with family as well as the town of Jefferson. Due to her reclusive nature and high standing in society she is often gossiped about by her fellow townsfolk....   [tags: death, miss emily, william faulkner]

Better Essays
753 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of A Rose For Emily By William Faulkner

- Analysis of “A Rose for Emily” “A Rose for Emily” reveals several literary dynamics worth analyzing. Faulkner wrote this short story in a nonlinear fashion, with an untraditional plot structure. The author uses unique symbolism, foreshadowing and narration to create suspense and mystery to an otherwise mundane story. Faulkner uses an interesting method to tell a dark and disturbing story, about a woman’s struggle to find love, and her resort to necrophilia when that love is threatened. “A Rose for Emily” takes place right after the Civil War, and throughout the Industrialization Period....   [tags: Fiction, Short story, William Faulkner, Narrative]

Better Essays
1781 words (5.1 pages)

Analysis Of ' A Rose For Emily ' Essay

- More often than not, when analyzing the similarities and differences between a written story and its reimagined film version, the differences leave an altered impression on the audience. In the short story, A Rose for Emily, the outstanding differences take the viewer on a ride they didn’t experience when reading the story. The biggest alteration is how the story’s chronological order takes a twist as they place the events back into an order in which they happened. Even though it is easier to follow, the original version left the audience dazed and confused for a reason....   [tags: Short story, Fiction, Film, Chronology]

Better Essays
1393 words (4 pages)

Essay Factors That Impacted Miss Emily's Behavior

- William Faulkner’s short story “A Rose for Emily” is a famous example of what some critics call the “Southern gothic” genre, in which the close-knit qualities and antiquated customs of a Southern community lead to aberrant , sometimes grotesque behavior. There is a voyeuristic aspect to these stories, as though the reader is invited to observe the bizarre nature of aspects of life and belief in the South. Of course, the observation of ‘exotic’ customs is not enough to explain Emily’s beliefs and motivations for her bizarre and transgressive acts – murdering her lover and then living with his corpse for many years....   [tags: Literary Analysis, A Rose for Emily]

Better Essays
1765 words (5 pages)

Analysis Of `` A Rose For Emily `` By Emily Faulkner Essay

- Caesar’s Take on Homer’s Sexuality in “A Rose for Emily” In Emily Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily”, Homer Barron has been a questionable subject of homosexuality for “some fifteen years” (Caesar). Although most people assume that Homer is a homosexual, I would have to disagree. On the other hand, there is some evidence that Homer is gay. In my opinion, the critics are jumping to conclusions when it comes to assuming that Homer is a homosexual when basing it off the lines “he liked men, and it was known that he drank with younger men at the Elk’s Club—that he was not a marrying man.” (Faulkner 187)....   [tags: Homosexuality, LGBT, Sexual orientation, Gender]

Better Essays
1346 words (3.8 pages)

Character Analysis of Emily Grierson in A Rose for Emily by William Faulkner

- Emily Grierson, referred to as Miss Emily throughout the story, is the main character of 'A Rose for Emily,' written by William Faulkner. Emily is born to a proud, aristocratic family sometime during the Civil War; Miss Emily used to live with her father and servants, in a big decorated house. The Grierson Family considers themselves superior than other people of the town. According to Miss Emily's father none of the young boys were suitable for Miss Emily. Due to this attitude of Miss Emily's father, Miss Emily was not able to develop any real relationship with anyone else, but it was like her world revolved around her father....   [tags: A Rose Emily William Faulkner]

Better Essays
554 words (1.6 pages)

A Rose for Emily Setting Analysis Essay

- A Rose for Emily Setting Analysis In "A Rose for Emily", a woman (for whom the story is named) confines herself in her somewhat large house in a small town during the early half of the twentieth century. For the most part, in order to understand the entirety of the story, it is vital to understand the setting and how each character develops it, and,or, interacts with it. As far as the town is concerned, it is very isolated and the people seem to value this quality, as well as the lack of progression in social change, most....   [tags: essays papers]

Better Essays
578 words (1.7 pages)