Analysis : ' Can I Tell A Dying Friend 's Secret On His Children ' Essay

Analysis : ' Can I Tell A Dying Friend 's Secret On His Children ' Essay

Length: 1086 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Ethical Conundrum Essay
I selected the article, “Can I Tell a Dying Friend’s Secret to His Children?” I selected this article
from the New York Times Ethicist Column. The ethical conundrum in question in this article is from the
perspective of the dying man’s friend. In a sense he is asking is he obligated to keep his friend’s secret
or can he reveal it now or upon his death. His friend’s secret is a rather big one that can have many
potential consequences - He has a child approximately 30 years old that he has nothing to do with since
birth, and has kept this secret from his wife and other children. The friend has a terminal cancer that
has metastasized and it is estimated that he has less than a year to live at best. This man had previously
asked his friend to let his wife and children know that there is another child out there, but the friend
decided not to tell them. He clearly thinks that the man’s children have a right to know that they have a
sibling, and he is battling with the idea of keeping the secret. It isn’t clear whether his decision was
because he did not want his family to think less of him, or if it was for other reasons he did not disclose.
According to Kwame Anthony Appiah, the Ethicist responding in this article, the man should first
understand the gravity of the situation. He needs to take into consideration that his friend told him this
secret in confidence, and that if the man can still understand him perhaps he should talk to the man and
try to understand why he does not want his family to know. I agree with the ethicist on this point - he
should talk to his friend to try to understand his logic for keeping this secret from his family. Trust,
loyalty, and privacy are qualities that we expect from a friend ...


... middle of paper ...


...half-sibling. Therefore it is morally right to
tell the truth that there is another sibling.
I decided to break this scenario into two parts the first part being the duty to the friend while he
is living, the second part being the duty to the family upon his death. From my interpretation of the
ethicist’s point of view it most fits Kant’s Theory. I agree with the application of Kant’s Theory to the
scenario while the man is living. There is a duty of trust and confidence with his friend that he should
not break. However, once the man passes away, the obligation to his friend is gone - therefore the
friend’s duty moves to the man’s children. When the duty moves to the man’s children, I think that act-
utilitarianism is the most applicable theory. I think the telling the truth is the most morally right action
to take at this point, and will produce the most overall good

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Ways of Dying by Zakes Mda Essay

- ... One feels that Zakes Mda was trying to convey to the reader the seriousness of the conditions in which the character lived under. Mda wanted to bring to light the unnecessary death of children. He wanted to show the reader that mothers and fathers gave birth to children who were only destined to die. “Death lives with us everyday. Indeed our ways of dying are our ways of livening. Or should I say our ways of living are our ways of dying.” (Kayla Van der Merwe) Ways of dying covers only a few days, but these few days mark a considerable change in the life of the central character, Toloki, He meets up and moves in with his childhood friend from his hometown, Noria, they both come to term...   [tags: story analysis]

Better Essays
1082 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on The Issue Of Confronting My Own Dying

- In this paper, the issue of confronting my own dying will be presented. I will present how being hooked to machines or other gadgets will not be a way that I would like to end my last days on earth. I will provide specific reasons why I would not like to be hooked to machines the last days of my life along with some vivid example I had with people who were dying. Just to think about the process of dying is something that makes people uncomfortable, never-the-less to think about how we will be living the last days of our lives....   [tags: Death, Family, Pain, Suffering]

Better Essays
925 words (2.6 pages)

a lesson before dying Essay

- Lesson Before Dying The Right to Be Free In the novel A Lesson Before Dying, although Grant is an educated black man in the era of a racist society he has struggles greater than most men of his decent. I feel sorry for him because of his limitations, even though I view him as a coward. He cannot break free of his background and family. The three main female characters in the novel, Tante Lou, Miss Emma, and Vivian, restrict and limit Grant's choices. Grant realizes that freedom means leaving his small town and creating a new life, yet each woman holds a chain that keeps him from his destiny and the right to be free....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
650 words (1.9 pages)

Religion Should Not Be Imposed on Children of a Young Age Essay

- Regardless of what religious practice, you follow bringing your children into those religious practices is called indoctrination, and is always wrong because you are bringing out a concept that the child has no hope of understanding and developing an opinion at a young age. “My aunt told me that when you were saved you saw a light and something happened to you inside (Hughes 125).” In Christianity parents enter you into the religion just a couple of weeks after your born, usually after you are born a Christian parent will bring you into church to get a baptism (different denominations have different practices) and as you are growing up the core values of Christianity are ingrained in you by...   [tags: indoctrination, personal analysis and reflection]

Better Essays
585 words (1.7 pages)

The Death of My Best Friend Essay

- I remember an old saying my mother used to tell me, “Never say never”. Is this true. I would have never expected this to be true till something happened to me that changed my life till this very day. Growing up I was oddly very cold hearted. I guess I was never the gurly girl always crying after a finger nail broke or the kind of person that wore her heart on her sleeve. I would always keep things to myself and let it be the day someone saw me cry. Most people just thought I wasn’t human. Crying wasn’t something I was used to but I didn’t know one instance would make me shed oceans....   [tags: friendship essay, my best friend]

Better Essays
1638 words (4.7 pages)

Alienation in As I Lay Dying, William Faulkner Essay

- William Faulkner is an American novelist whose major work is As I Lay Dying. Faulkner gave each of his characters traits that are expressed throughout the story.  The reader is introduced to each character through their detailed and descriptive character traits.  We are able to delve into the character's mind and see their personal and distinct traits. He did not tell us anything about the characters, but he takes us into the mind of each character to analyze what we see there. Even though these characters lead parallel lives we can see the total alienation and breakdown of the relationships between each other.  Darl, Jewel, and Anse possess character traits that contribute to or cause the b...   [tags: As I Lay Dying Essays]

Better Essays
1733 words (5 pages)

The Literary Merit of A Lesson Before Dying Essay

- The Literary Merit of A Lesson Before Dying Ernest Gaines was born during the middle of the Great Depression on January 15, 1933. He was the oldest of twelve children. At the age of nine Gaines worked as an errand boy on the River Lake Plantation, the same plantation his book A Lesson Before Dying was set in. Gaines was raised by his Aunt Augusteen Jefferson, much like Grant, the protagonist in the novel, was raised by his Aunt Tante Lou. At the age of fifteen Gaines rejoined his immediate family in Vallejo, California because there were no high schools for him to attend in Louisiana....   [tags: Lesson Before Dying Essays]

Better Essays
1124 words (3.2 pages)

Marijuana: Friend to the Dying Essay

- Marijuana: Friend to the Dying Peter is an AIDS patient. The violent nausea caused by the handfuls of pills he must take every day prevents anything he eats from staying down. Even the pill to calm the vomiting won't stay in his stomach long enough to take effect. He has lost nearly forty pounds and is unrecognizable, even to himself. He has given up on life, and he dreads each day because of the pain and the sorrow it brings. Now imagine there's a drug that may help Peter, a drug that helps him keep food down or even makes him hungry, a drug that helps him gain weight, a drug that gives him the hope that he will live long enough to see a cure, a drug that helps him accept what's ha...   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Topics]

Free Essays
1153 words (3.3 pages)

Ernest J. Gaines's A Lesson Before Dying Essay

- Grant Wiggins has been teaching on a plantation outside Bayonne, Louisiana, for several years when a slow-witted man named Jefferson is convicted of murder and sentenced to death. Jefferson claims he is innocent of the crime. He says he was on his way to a bar, but changed his mind and decided to tag along with two men who were on their way to a liquor store. Upon arriving there, the two men began arguing with the storeowner, and a shootout ensued. The storeowner and the two men died, and Jefferson remained at the scene of the crime....   [tags: Lesson Before dying Review]

Free Essays
915 words (2.6 pages)

Tie-Dying Essay examples

- This essay will explain a dying technique that is called tie-dying. Tie-Dying is a technique that can be used on many different fabrics to create different effect and millions of designs that are all one of a kind; no two tie dyes are alike. I have come to be very fond of tie-dye, using it as a means of support, owning my own small tie dye business for years. To design a tie-dye you will make several handmade folds that are secured by string or rubber bands, and then saturated in dye for different periods of time to create different shades of colors....   [tags: Dying Techniques]

Better Essays
2024 words (5.8 pages)