An Experiment On Animal Acts Essay

An Experiment On Animal Acts Essay

Length: 1533 words (4.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Friederike Range, the principle author of this study, and three other scientists from the University of Vienna, conducted an experiment in which they paired together domesticated dogs with an experimenter. All of the dogs that engaged in the study were asked to place their paws in the experimenter’s hand. After doing so, the dogs would be rewarded with a treat. When the experimenter did not reward one dog with a treat when he obeyed, but the other got rewarded, the dog who was not given a treat refused to obey and would not respond to the commands given by the experimenter. The scientists then proceeded to measured by recording the non obeying dog 's’ responses and interpreted the data.
The experiment performed by the scientists and experimenters caused the dogs, who were unrewarded for their actions, to feel what is called, inequity aversion. According to Paul Morris, inequity aversion is “...when an animal acts to stop perceived inequalities within its social group and it is a defining characteristic of social, or cooperative, species”. In other words, the dogs wanted similar rewards for performing the exact same actions as each other. Morris also stated that although dogs experience “jealousy” or “envy”, the feelings are not precisely how humans feel those feelings. Instead, Morris says the dogs most likely experienced a “primitive” feeling of envy.
Feeling certain emotions are considered to be a result of evolution. They are considered the end result of evolution for the main fact that these feelings cause animals to act in distinct ways that help increase their survival. In this case, the feeling of jealousy, enhances the animal’s chances of survival by “motivating” it to protect it’s nearby mates and for safety purposes. ...

... middle of paper ...

... popular article. Not enough information about the main facts of the experiment were referenced to in the popular source, as they should have so the reader could follow along easily. The main points are extremely essential to include in the popular article in order to get the reader to maintain a full understanding of what is being said throughout the entire article.
Overall, the popular article is a poor representation of the scholarly source. Most of the conclusions and findings reported in the scholarly article were not even mentioned or referenced to in the popular article, as they should have been for the reader to get a full grasp of the topic and what is being discussed. Ultimately, most of the information presented in the popular source is inaccurate and misleading, while not enough evidence was provided in the popular source to support the thesis as well.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Experiment On Non Human Animal Essay

- Experiment On non-Human Animal Laboratory experimentation of animals has been a hot topic of debate for decades. Advocates of animal’s rights think that it can never be justified because it brings sufferings to animals. They equate animal experimentation to torture. On the other hand there are those who think that humanity should have no qualms about using nature for their own ends. There are more shades of opinion in between and they are frequently reflected in debates over this emotionally and ethically charged topic....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights]

Better Essays
1152 words (3.3 pages)

Animal Testing And The Field Essay

- The animal testing has great contribution to the development of biomedical field, and discovery of essential medical devices, medicines and treatment. The biomedical field would not be in today’s advance form if animals testing and studies were not performed. Therefore animal testing should be continued to save the human kind and to advance the biomedical field. Response to the counterargument There is no any doubt that animal testing and animal experimentations has great contribution to the development of biomedical to today’s advance form, but do we still need to continue the animal testing if many new advance techniques and alternatives to animal testing are already discovered....   [tags: Animal testing, Medical research, Experiment]

Better Essays
734 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about The True Cost Of Animal Experimentation

- The True Cost of Animal Experimentation “More than 100 million animals are poisoned, burned, crippled, and abused in other ways in U.S. labs each year” (PETA). Vile experiments regularly take place in some bloodcurdling lab, inconspicuous to a vast majority of society. Insufferable agony and demise is looming, slowly creeping upon for those involuntary guinea pigs. The victims who lamentably survive are maimed beyond healing and / or are left for the buzzards, metaphorically speaking, forever distorted beyond recognition....   [tags: Animal testing, Experiment, Psychology]

Better Essays
1092 words (3.1 pages)

Osmosis Experiment Essay

- Background Knowledge: Osmosis definition: Diffusion of water molecules through a semi permeable membrane from a higher concentration to a lower concentration until the concentration on both sides is equal. Osmosis in animal cells: The cell membrane is the partially permeable membrane in animal cells. If the cells were placed in distilled water they gain water, swell and burst. This is known as haemolysis. Osmosis in plant cells: The cellulose cell wall of plant cells is fully permeable. Therefore it’s the cell membrane of a plant cell which acts as the semi-permeable membrane, deciding what gets into and out of the cell....   [tags: Science Experiment]

Better Essays
582 words (1.7 pages)

Animal Testing And Changing The Animal Welfare Act Essay

- Did you know, different pharmaceutical and medical companies can avoid animal rights laws if they use rats or mice in their studies and experiments. The Animal Welfare Act is an act that has been around since 1966 and has been molded and changed throughout the years as research has surfaced about different species of animals. Though, even with all these changes, it still fails to protect the rights of some types of rats, mice, and birds. One of the main things that has to be understood to fully ponder this issue of animal rights is a concept called the 3Rs....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights, In vivo]

Better Essays
2002 words (5.7 pages)

Animal Testing Should Be Banned Essay

- The Humane Society has stated that many animals undergo immensely painful tests, such as: the deprivation of necessities, forced feeding, the infliction of burns and chemicals, physical restraint, neck breaking, and decapitation (Animal Testing). Animal experiments have been used for centuries to test personal products, cleaning tools, food, chemicals, and drugs (Animal Experimentation Driscoll and Finley). Contrary to popular belief, many of today’s experiments are unsupervised, leaving the animals subjected to torturous, cruel, and useless studies (Animal Testing)....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights]

Better Essays
1741 words (5 pages)

Should Animal Testing Be Banned? Essay

- Cosmetics is a very powerful promising industry. People buy different sorts of product for the sake of beauty which is a result of massive profits for this beauty global business. Hidden in this production is the unfortunate situation that animals are getting inhumanely treated. Over 100 million animals are burned, crippled, poisoned, and abused in US labs every year ( are rabbits, guinea pigs, hamsters, rats and mice that are being experimented and tested for the sake of cosmetics....   [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights]

Better Essays
1178 words (3.4 pages)

Animal Rights And Human Health Essay

- I will argue that it is a better option for humans to not accept the doctrine of Animal Rights, and I will offer three reasons to support this claim. Firstly, Animal Rights can be limiting to the advancement of human health. Secondly, there are alternatives to accepting the Animal Rights. Finally, Animal Rights does not support animal control, which is important for sustaining the ecosystem. The second point will be discussed as an extension of the first point. In support of my first claim, I will offer two reasons....   [tags: Animal rights]

Better Essays
947 words (2.7 pages)

The Effects Of Animal Testing On Human Tissue Essay

- Biomedical research has lead to innumerable medical breakthroughs throughout history. Without animal testing, there would not be chemotherapy, insulin for diabetics, pacemakers for individuals with heart problems, or blood transfusions. Discoveries made with the help of animal testing have already saved countless lives, and will undoubtedly continue to be essential to the development of treatments for other diseases. Therefore, individuals who fight against animal testing are impacting social views on the benefits of medical advances....   [tags: Animal rights, Animal Liberation Front]

Better Essays
733 words (2.1 pages)

Animal Experimentation Essay

- I have always had a great admiration for animals. Being an animal owner of two dogs, I believe that they are a friend of the human and both benefit from each other in the sense of company and joy. They are also great contributors to the balance of the eco system. These are some of the various reasons why I chose this topic. In this research paper I will inform you, the reader of the horrible experiences that innocent animals have to endure due to the fact that supporters believe that animal experimenting is a humane method of bettering our lives....   [tags: Animal Rights ]

Better Essays
1831 words (5.2 pages)