The American Family Structure By Stephanie Coontz 's Talk At Dickinson College

The American Family Structure By Stephanie Coontz 's Talk At Dickinson College

Length: 1134 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In society today there tends to exist a nostalgia for the utopian family life of the past.
When envisioning the American family structure, one may usually picture the nuclear families
one sees portrayed so happily in 1950s shows: the husband is the breadwinner, the wife is the
homemaker, and the children are mischievous, yet lovable. While this ideal of the American
family structure is pervasive through the media, it does not represent most families throughout
history. Families with single parents and step families and divorced spouses have not been
uncommon at all, yet they seem to have been excluded from the narrative of American families
in the 20th century. In Stephanie Coontz’s talk at Dickinson College, she addresses the evolution
of marriage in American society and the extent to which it affects women.
While many believe that single parent families and step families are a convention of
modern society, they have in fact been in existence for centuries. The reason for them today is
not always the same as it was historically, as Stephanie Coontz explains that “one parent families
were the norm throughout most of history because of high death rates” (Coontz). Without
modern forms of medicine or care, many parents died of health issues or childbirth, leaving the
other parent behind often with children and the need for a new spouse in order to care for the
home and provide for the children. This leads to families whose children are a mix of different
marriages and parents, and in fact “many step families of the past had many more problems than
the ones that we think of today” (Coontz) because marriage was oriented around property and
power. It may have been likely that children in these older step families fought over money and

...


... middle of paper ...


...een so consequential to American life because they
have allowed women to be vocal about marriage rape and the desire to divorce, to move away
from home without being married, and to be independent of men with their own finances without
needing marriage at all. Stephanie Coontz believes that these changes in the concept of marriage
have revolutionized lives to the extent that the industrial revolution changed the ways in which
people worked at the beginning of the 20th century. Since marriage is now socially separated
from sex and there is no longer a need for a full time caretaker in the home, women can find their
places sexually, in the work force, and economically without marriage as a necessity. While
divorce can be painful to children and adults alike, they deliver people from difficult and
sometimes abusive situations, and should be a right to both men and women.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Lecture At Dickinson College, The Way We Never Were : American Families And The Nostalgia Trap

- In Stephanie Coontz’s lecture at Dickinson College, The Way We Never Were: American Families and the Nostalgia Trap, she discusses the myths of family life and the way marriage has changed over time. She talks about her basic philosophy about the positive aspects of these changes and how these changes have “reshaped” the idea of family and marriage today. The first aspect of family Coontz talks about is single parent families, which she explains is a concept we think of as new but is actually quite traditional....   [tags: Marriage, Divorce, Love, Alimony]

Better Essays
1079 words (3.1 pages)

A History Of Marriage By Stephanie Coontz Essay

- A History of Marriage by Stephanie Coontz speaks of the recent idealization of marriage based solely on love. Coontz doesn’t defame love, but touches on the many profound aspects that have created and bonded marriages through time. While love is still a large aspect Coontz wants us to see that a marriage needs more solid and less fickle aspects than just love. The first chapter begins with an exploration of love and marriage in many ancient and current cultures. Surprisingly many cultures either avoid the discussion of love in marriage or spit on the idea completely....   [tags: Marriage, Love, Arranged marriage, Husband]

Better Essays
1031 words (2.9 pages)

The American Family By Stephanie Coontz Essays

- Today 's generation have changed many ways since the beginning of the century. In “The American Family”, Stephanie Coontz discusses many situations that has occurred during the beginning of the 21st century and suggested solutions to solve those issues in the future. For instance, she argued that women are being treated unfairly, family are not discussing their problems openly, and institutions need to change to fit the families’ requirement. In “Complexity of Family Life among the Low-Income and Working Poor” Patricia Hyjer Dyk, argued that women still doesn’t have enough choices, low income families doesn’t have enough jobs, and Government are not helping many families....   [tags: Poverty, 21st century, Family, Marriage]

Better Essays
1138 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on The American Family By Stephanie Coontz

- It’s not easy to build an ideal family. In the article “The American Family” by Stephanie Coontz, she argued that during this century families succeed more when they discuss problems openly, and when social institutions are flexible in meeting families’ needs. When women have more choices to make their own decisions. She also argued that to have an ideal family women can expect a lot from men especially when it comes to his involvement in the house. Raymond Carver, the author of “Where He Was: Memories of My Father”, argued how his upbringing and lack of social institutions prevented him from building an ideal family....   [tags: Marriage, Family, Mother, Father]

Better Essays
1511 words (4.3 pages)

The Ideal And Real Of Marriage By Stephanie Coontz Essay

- “The Ideal and Real of Marriage” by Stephanie Coontz discusses the evolution of marriage and how the social context is changing. The thesis of this article is marriage has changed in the past 30 years than 3,000 years because people marry for love. The next article “Why Your Marriage Sucks” by Amanda Fortini she gives a breakdown as to how much hard work and sacrifice it takes to sustain a marriage. The thesis is it’s easy to glean that we currently inhabit a vast and bleak landscape of marital discontent....   [tags: Marriage, Love, Human sexuality, Wife]

Better Essays
1468 words (4.2 pages)

The Differences Between Dorian Solot’s and Stephanie Coontz’s Essays

- Is marriage really important. There is a lot of controversy over marriage and whether it is eminent. Some people believe it is and some people believe it is not. These opposing opinions cause this controversy. “On Not Saying ‘I do’” by Dorian Solot explains that marriage is not needed to sustain a relationship or a necessity to keep it healthy and happy. Solot believes that when a couple gets married things change. In “For Better, For Worse”, Stephanie Coontz expresses that marriage is not what is traditional in society because it has changed and is no longer considered as a dictator for people’s lives....   [tags: Literary Analysis ]

Better Essays
1619 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on The Radical Idea Of Marrying For Love By Stephanie Coontz

- History of Marriage and Love Introduction In the article, “The Radical Idea of Marrying for Love” author Stephanie Coontz argues that love is not a good enough reason to get married. People shouldn’t marry just because they love one another, Coontz suggests that perhaps marriage should be based on how well a couple gets along and whether or not if the significant other is accepted by the family. One will notice in the article that Coontz makes it very clear that she is against marrying because of love....   [tags: Marriage, Love, Wife, Husband]

Better Essays
798 words (2.3 pages)

The Way We Never Were By Stephanie Coontz Essay

- Stephanie Coontz’s speech, “The Way We Never Were,” debunks many social constructs about marriage that our society assumes to be true today. These include ideas about single parent families, divorce, choice of partners, and distinct spheres for men and women. Many people believe that step families and single parent families has only emerged in recent history. However, this was the typical of many families in the early 19th century due to high death rates. For instance, many mothers would die while giving birth leaving the father to take care of the rest of the family....   [tags: Marriage, Family, Divorce, Family law]

Better Essays
944 words (2.7 pages)

The Way We Wish We Were Essay

- Coontz Précis The Way We Wish We Were, written by author Stephanie Coontz, converses about the ways the "traditional" American family has changed over time. Family's can be divided into two general categories: the extended family style, and the nuclear family style. Due to the changing of family styles, the "American traditional family" no longer survives. Coontz divides how extended families follow traditions in which they teach their children the way they were raised, "The way it's always been" claims Coontz....   [tags: Stephanie Coontz]

Free Essays
307 words (0.9 pages)

Stephanie Coontz's What We Really Miss about the 1950s Essay example

- Part 1: Summary Stephanie Coontz's essay `What we really miss about the 1950's' is an essay that talks about a poll taken in 1996 by the Knight-Ridder news agency that more Americans preferred 1950's as the best decade for children to grow up. Coontz doesn't believe that it is a decade for people to remember fondly about, except for financial reasons and better communication within families. Coontz doesn't believe in it as the best decade because of the votes, the 50's only won by nine percent, and especially not by African Americans....   [tags: I Love Lucy]

Free Essays
560 words (1.6 pages)