The ideas presented in Tanner’s book deserve recognition on the basis that the author’s thesis is addressing a hypothetical supposition. However, the thesis here is unconventional, as Tanner doesn’t introduce any innovative ideas, rather Tanner asserts how other historians’ bases are false. Countless historians, Tanner included, propose a central problem exists as a result of the Civil War: how did the Confederate States of America lose the war, and, if so, how could victory have been achieved? Tanner submits that something known as a Fabian strategy cannot be attributed to how the Confederacy might have won the war because of how this strategy exhausted popular support for the war.
Before beginning, it might be prudent to explain what Fabian warfare is and to what benefit could it have done for the Confederacy. The origins of the stratagem known as Fabian range back to the Second Punic Wars, when the Roman commander Quintus Fabius Maximus Verrucosus instituted a policy of avoiding battle rather than be lured into a direct clash, utilizing guerilla tactics and scorched-earth warfare to defeat “the gre...
... middle of paper ...
... when he could have taken the approach addressing the root of the problems: the Confederate high command.
To conclude, Tanner’s book Retreat to Victory? looks at the hypothetical response to how the Confederacy could have won the Civil War. By looking at the geography of the southern half of the United States, the slaves and the generals of the Confederacy, Tanner is able to show through evidence and historical examples why a Fabian strategy could not have given the Confederacy the victory they so desired. Although Tanner’s thesis does seem unorthodox due to how the author doesn’t introduce any new, revolutionary ideas on how the Confederacy could have won the war, Tanner’s analysis is well done because the author allows the reader to suppose what could have changed United States history while at the same time showing the audience why the case presented cannot be.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- During the Civil War, a young nation was divided. Families were torn apart, brothers fighting brothers. There was no neutral ground. Everything was split, including the United States Military Academy. Previous classmates at West Point, bound together by principles and virtues would now face the inconceivable: fight each other in battle. The history of West Point leads back to the American Revolutionary War. West Point was a key fort on the west bank of the Hudson River. It was considered to be the most strategic location in America, but was sold away to the British by Benedict Arnold, a notorious traitor.... [tags: American Civil War, Robert E. Lee]
1740 words (5 pages)
- Nature was not the only thing at risk during the Industrial Revolution. The social structure was being challenged by social justice leaders around the country. The feminist and abolition movements swept the nation, and the art scene. Artists took to showing the injustice of slavery through various paintings. Robert Duncanson’s painting Uncle Tom and Little Eva, shows the flawed logic of white supremacy. The little girl in the painting is standing while the African American man is sitting under her.... [tags: American Civil War, African American]
1040 words (3 pages)
- Many historians have studied the way the Civil War unfolded and how the south could have possibly won if the southern generals executed Fabian warfare. This war technique has the offensive army retreating deeper and deeper into their territory, thus causing the defensive army to have longer supply lines and exhaustion sweep the soldiers. Although this is a major topic of discussion, Robert Tanner does not agree with the notion the Confederate nation could have won using this tactic. This is because the southern population did not have a unifying reason war was erupting, nor did the southern army have generals who took advantage of union troops when they showed weakness, and the confederate... [tags: Confederate States of America]
1013 words (2.9 pages)
- The War of Secession, or universally known as the Civil War, was a war unlike any other. The war began on April 12, 1861 after the Confederacy’s attack on Fort Sumter. According to the Civil War Trust, “ it was the largest and most destructive conflict in the Western world between the end of the Napoleonic Wars in 1815 and the onset of World War I in 1914.” It was also the first modern war because it used 20th century technology and strategies. The Civil War was severely catastrophic for both the Union and the Confederacy.... [tags: American Civil War, Robert E. Lee]
714 words (2 pages)
- The Civil War 154 year ago, in the early morning of April 12, 1861 the Civil War officially began. The next four years were the bloodiest four years in American history. Leading up to the Civil War in November of 1860 Abraham Lincoln was elected president, he wasn’t even on the souths ballet and still won with 40% of popular votes and 59% of electoral votes. On December 20 South Carolina succeeded from the union. On December 26 US Major-General R. Anderson moved his troops from Ft. Moutrie in Charleston, Carolina, to Fort Sumter.... [tags: American Civil War, Robert E. Lee]
1388 words (4 pages)
- According to History of America, the causes of the Civil War, and the Battle of Gettysburg, were the differences between two cultures. The Confederacy had a farming economy producing tobacco, corn, and cotton, with many large plantations owned by a few very rich white males. The owners lived off the labor of sharecroppers and slaves, charging high dues for use of their land (History, 76). The Civil War branch from multiple issues. The protection of the Union, the explanation of slavery to new grounds and the rights to citizenship only in a short time, which means to be an American.... [tags: American Civil War, Robert E. Lee]
1123 words (3.2 pages)
- Not realizing how much had actually gone in to the history of the civil war, especially with history not being my best subject it was surprising to read the differences from what I guess you could say the confederate and anti-confederate side. The men fighting for the north or as they say “Yankees” I feel like forcefully won only because they used “guerilla tactics” (Freehling, pg.16). Meaning that they basically terrorized the community to prove their point, this essentially made them leave large amounts of groups behind which made it even more slower pace to advance in the war.... [tags: American Civil War, Robert E. Lee]
1147 words (3.3 pages)
- In the American civil war, Gettysburg is perhaps the turning point of the war, and it is also the last invasion on North American soil. Gettysburg, at the time, was just a small-time town before and during the civil war any, yet forever changed after the battle. A lot of people may remember the battle of Gettysburg by Pickett’s charge or Abraham Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address, but anyone would not think about what actually happened during the battle. People may not realize that there were over 50,000 casualties over the three day battle, or how the North had the high ground, which would be a military advantage, most of the time.... [tags: gettysburg, civil war, robert lee]
1023 words (2.9 pages)
- There are always two sides to every story. What side you want to believe though, is up to you, what you think happened and who you trust more. During the civil war it was clean that there were two sides; the North and the South. What side you were on depended not on what you believed but by where you were from. For some people this was hard. They would believe that we could get rid of slaves and just wanted the war to end but since they were from Virginia they had to fight for the Confederacy. One of the men this happened to was Robert E.... [tags: confederate, civil war, differences]
801 words (2.3 pages)
- ... The Confederates emerged victorious after the Unions looked like they held a considerable lead. 18. During the opening of the Battle for Bull Run, the North was shattering the lines of the Confederates, except for those of Stonewall Jackson who held strong and provided hope for the surrounding men. He was known as one of the greatest leaders of the Civil War. 19. The Peninsula Campaign was the first large-scale campaign in the Civil War led by George McClellan with the Army of the Potomac. It ended with the battle at Seven Pines in which McClellan lost most of his men.... [tags: The Civil War Essays]
2342 words (6.7 pages)