Compare And Contrast Traditional Education And Public Education

1287 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: John Dewey's effects on education today

America’s public education is in the process of being changed because groups wish to insert their lifestyle, their wants, and their ideas into the public education system. Public education was created as a systematic method of teaching and training to acquire knowledge with the ability to use knowledge wisely. To quote Benjamin Franklin from Education and Public Health: Natural Partners in Learning for Life; “Nothing can more effectively contribute to the cultivation and improvement of a country with wisdom, riches, strength, virtue, welfare, and happiness of a people than a proper education of the youth.” (qtd. in Smith 1) Education is not just getting prepared for life; it is life itself. John Dewey said that “intelligence plus character …show more content…

Which was free the pupil from regulations and authority in the schoolroom. By doing this the dread of failure was eliminated; the curriculum was adjusted to match the mental thought power of the average student. Classes were grouped by age, social status rather than by mental preparedness and also allowing classes to advance at their own rate of progress. Traditional education states school is a preparation for life, whereas Progressive Education says school is only a part of life. Teachers have different roles to perform in each type of educating. Progressive Education declares teachers are leaders that guide the students to do their own thinking of a situation through play and social interaction. Traditional Education implies teaching consists of lectures, worksheets to be informative with strict discipline. Students are required to sit and listen while the teacher discusses the text. Progressive Education is driven by inquiry generated by the student and assessed mainly by benchmarks. The contrast is the traditional way that is straight-forward; based solely on correct answers and is grade oriented. The results of both types of education produced controversial dispute. Both approaches produced some failure. However, new and better ideas were tried. The country has gone mainly with Progressive Education with the idea of producing free and original productive citizens contributing to the good of the country. This thought pattern removed all restrictions from the lives of public school students. It gave the teachers the responsibility of developing the curriculum. Teachers are split on which way of educating is the best. According to William Owen, a lifetime teacher, “Under Progressive Education, authoritative sources and control were lost.” He also said “Original thinking came first over textbooks which became second and discipline became a problem.”(14-15, 53-55)

Show More
Related

  • To what Extent the Progressive Movement was Successful

    1284 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many progressives thought that the greatest way to reform society was through its schools. Public education had grown rapidly since the Civil War. Progressives had new ideas about the purpose of education. Progressive educators believed that children should learn best by contributing in activities where they can work on projects and learn at their own rate. I thought this idea was a better way of learning because memorizing methods were really stressful and many people have diverse ways of learning: visual, hearing, hands on, and etc.

    Read More

  • Essay On Native American Education

    1388 Words  | 3 Pages

    All over the world, people have always sought for power, they have struggled to defend their culture; they have worked beyond imaginable to obtain economic prosperity and political freedom. A matter of fact equality is something that nowadays we are still fighting to obtain. Education has always been the key to power. In the twenty-first century education means a way to obtain the American dream, in other words, to achieve success. However, schools were never intended to empower people to think for themselves or to help them succeed. At the beginning of the American school, different groups of people wanted different things to come out of schooling, one of those things was to facilitate reading the bible in the text it states that “Schooling became important as a means of sustaining a well- ordered religious commonwealth” (Spring 22).

    Read More

  • John Taylor Gatto The Weapons Of The Curriculum Analysis

    2033 Words  | 5 Pages

    Personal Thoughts- Education is a life-long endeavor. Education isn’t restricted to a classroom or confided by the time restraints of the bell. Education can, and does happen anytime and anywhere. Students who attend public schools are certainly becoming well-schooled, but are they becoming well-educated? For example, take politics. There have been numerous presidential administrations packed with people that have college degrees make foolish mistakes. Were they well-schooled or

    Read More

  • America's To-Do-List: #1-Fix Education

    1088 Words  | 3 Pages

    Education is a fundamental aspect of any civilized nation. The goal of public education in America is to turn uninformed children into knowledgeable citizens who are fully capable of participating in a society driven by democracy and economics. Students drop out every year by the hundreds of thousands, and those who remain receive a less than satisfactory educational experience due to lack of funding, inadequate teachers, and flawed educational strategies. Americans must improve school funding and increase teacher pay to ensure all students receive quality primary and secondary education as well as reduce remediation and drop out rates through improved learning standards, effective assessment tools, and early-college initiatives that prepare students for college and the workforce.

    Read More

  • Away with the Canon -- Onward with Street-Smarts

    1961 Words  | 4 Pages

    When you think of education, the thing that probably comes to mind first, is the institution of formal education, i.e., primary, secondary and then higher education. We have this closed perception that education has to be formal, and nothing else. Often times we, as human beings, tend to weigh things too heavily on formal education. We frown upon the fact that if a person doesnt choose to go and become educated in the traditional way, they wont be able to make something of themselves in their lives. Personally, I strongly disagree. As Jon Spayed, Learning in the Key of Life, put it, there are many ways to become an educated American, as there are Americans (Spayde 63).

    Read More

  • Most Likely To Succeed Film Analysis

    1084 Words  | 3 Pages

    According to the documentary “Most Likely To Succeed,” the American education system was created to train America’s youth for jobs in factories during the industrial revolution. However, technological advances will soon make those jobs obsolete. With machines being able to be programmed to do manual labor, the only jobs that will remain are those that require higher level thinking skills. The majority of current high school curriculum does not allow students to exercise their creative thinking skills and does not leave much room for free thought. The current curriculum was developed to teach what employers deemed essential knowledge, such as geometry, biology, and geography. These subjects should still be taught to children because a fundamental understanding of these subjects helps them understand the world around them. The U.S. government realized this and made public schools not only virtually free but mandatory to help children succeed. In contrast, today a college degree is more than ever vital for the country’s youth and the government has done little to help them obtain a higher education. The days of factory workers and laborers are over and it is time the nation prepares children for the road ahead. If not they are on the road towards certain failure and a life of poverty. With an already shrinking middle class one would think the government would be doing everything in its power to assist children in getting a higher education to find a

    Read More

  • The Negetive Aspects of American Education System

    667 Words  | 2 Pages

    The American Education System has been a core component to the development of generations since it became a public system in the 1870s. Since then more rules, higher expectations for some, and even lower expectations for others have been added to the original structure. In recent years, many debates have surfaced over whether the American education system is failing. Too few they believe the American Education System is on the right track. Most researchers however have shown statistics that it is in fact slowly declining as new acts and regimens are added. It has been on a downward spiral for years and citizens have been watching it happen, the lack of government funding, acts like the No Child Left behind Act, focus in the wrong places, and the curriculum set up is acting as a deterrent for success.

    Read More

  • As American As Public School: 1900-1950

    873 Words  | 2 Pages

    Arthur Bestor had the ideal that progressive education was teaching students skills that did not need to be taught in school. He wrote educational wastelands, which talked about how schools need to return to basic academic

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On American Education

    903 Words  | 2 Pages

    Throughout the course of time, teaching, scores, and curriculum have changed to where education is mainly about “being okay” and never about actually improving; and abundant amount of people hold the theory that the government is well aware of this fact and has contributed to the continual downfall of American education in an effort to systematically decrease the competency and literacy of the American population, making them easier to manipulate and allowing the government to achieve increasingly greater power and control over the American population; as a result, Americans are being submerged in a culture that has encouraged them to become more complacent and less interested in bettering themselves which has allowed the government this power that continues to grow.

    Read More

  • Public School Reform in America

    619 Words  | 2 Pages

    Public Schools in America for a long time were regarded as the best public schools in the world, but with the development of Asian and European schools American schools are not ranked as highly. American Public schools in 1999 were ranked sixteenth and seventeenth in science and math right behind Bangladesh. Some students are graduating from high school with little more than an inadequate ability to read and a diploma that should mean the student knows at least the core subjects. Other students are dropping out and not graduating at all. Colleges are not trusting diplomas and grade point averages as a basis of admissions because they know that with the large variety of classes that high schools offer as credit that the student may not know as much as his or her GPA says. Colleges are recalculating GPA's deleting non-core classes and evaluating SAT and ACT scores for the purpose of admissions. Colleges also have to offer more remedial classes to teach students what they should have learned in high school. Something needs to be done to reform America's public schools especially at the high school level.

    Read More

  • Comparison Essay: Traditional Schools Vs. Public Schools

    406 Words  | 1 Pages

    Eighty-six percent of public schools in the United States operate on a traditional school calendar, according to the National Center for Education Statistics. Although you can receive the same education at a year round school that you can at a traditional school, traditional schools are better. They are better because traditional schools educate all students, have access to government funds, and have qualified teachers.

    Read More

  • The Texas Education System

    1595 Words  | 4 Pages

    Knowledge is power, yet wisdom is domination. This all begins with education, whether it be a shepherd boy learning about his sheep or a future idealist learning math to change the world, education is meant to prepare individuals for their upcoming future. Education is even mentioned in the Bible, because “wisdom is a shelter…that preserves those who have it” (New International Version, Eccl. 7:12). According to Nelson Mandela, “Education is the most powerful weapon which [one] can use to change the world” (Mandela, par.1). However, in the United States, there seems to be a massive orifice in the preparation of youth. Texas is receiving some of the most destructive and unnecessary blemishes of this problem, however, no one has accepted the

    Read More

  • The Essentialist View Of Education

    1356 Words  | 3 Pages

    Firstly, a pragmatic progressive educator believes that schooling should promote the future ability for students to learn, as well as the belief that children should learn how to problem solve in a way that connects to their personal

    Read More

  • Book Review: Teaching Social Studies That Matters

    750 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...ee myself embracing the concepts of a progressive education now more than ever. Thornton reminds us that the choices educators make on topics, methods, conceptual understandings, and skills are basically educational questions and that vehemently as importantly as content. That although there are many levels above us, teachers cannot assume their concepts and intentions are successful and we need to engage in our own way. Of all the things mentioned in this book, the most important aim of a teacher is to develop a child's potential to the fullest. Regardless of what happens to you twenty years down the line, a student will always remember which classes and teachers help spark what they have become to this day.

    Read More

  • Education Argumentative Essay

    1276 Words  | 3 Pages

    Growing up they said that education is the key to life. Without an education you won’t make it very far in life, at least that is what adults preaches. According to Capra "America must acknowledge that education is a public necessity and not a luxury for

    Read More

More about Compare And Contrast Traditional Education And Public Education

Open Document