Alison Jaggar's Error Theory Essays

Alison Jaggar's Error Theory Essays

Length: 1649 words (4.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In Alison Jaggar’s Feminist Politics and Human Nature she discusses, among many topics, human nature and how it relates to capitalism and socialist feminism. Though Jaggar proposes a strong and valid argument for her position on why work is awful under capitalism and how using an error theory worker’s are not inherently lazy, I will be critiquing Jaggar’s error theory, and as a result, her views (as well as some of Marx’s views) on capitalism in a broad sense. I believe that Alison Jaggar does not have a sound argument in her error theory against Thomas Malthus, strictly due to her interpretation on why capitalism is awful due to Jaggar’s interpretation intrinsic value under capitalism.
An Overview of Jaggar’s View of Capitalism and How it Isolates Workers, Human Nature, and Response to Thomas Malthus
(quote summarized areas with actual quotes from text readings)
Jaggar supported Karl Marx in the sense that they both believed that the capitalist alienates the worker under capitalism and even exploits the worker. According to Marx, the worker should create a product freely in order to develop his or her capacities. But under capitalism, the worker who creates a product does not have control over how the product is made, over what product is made, or what is to be done with the with the product once it is finished. Marx argues that the strong connection that should exist between the worker and product is fragmented; therefore workers are alienated under capitalism. He also argues that workers are often enemies because they are competing for jobs that are offered by the capitalist (Lecture, 10/7).
Jaggar then goes onto describe human nature. To summarize, it is with in human nature to work purposefully transform our world to me...

... middle of paper ...

... could respond to Thomas Malthus in a more effective manner. Though the error theory is unsound, I am one to still accept her vision of an economic democracy, although capitalism is still a great alternative. Her arguments against mandatory motherhood, compulsory heterosexuality, and the structure of work would still remain valid and sound as well.
Ultimately, Jaggar’s error theory is unsound due to the fact of a fundamental misinterpretation of capitalism in which Jaggar believes that work is generally awful under the economic system, when in actuality it is not so awful. Work is not so awful under capitalism due to the nature of capitalism that promotes competition to encourage entrepreneurship, which benefits society as a whole in comparison to socialist feminism. Although Jaggar’s error theory is unsound, the rest of her theory remains unaffected.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Support for Alison Jaggar's Feminist Politics and Human Nature Essay examples

- Introduction In Alison Jaggar’s Feminist Politics and Human Nature she discusses, among many topics, the nature of work and how it relates to capitalism and compares it to her preferred economic system: economic democracy. Jaggar proposes a sound and valid argument for economic democracy. I believe that Alison Jaggar does have a sound argument for economic democracy and proponents of capitalism cannot justify their argument that capitalism is better than economic democracy because it does not promote greater innovation and creativity in general because that type of work only applies to a small portion of the population....   [tags: economic democracy vs capitalism]

Better Essays
1685 words (4.8 pages)

Inductive Risk Is The Risk Of Error Essay

- 5. Inductive risk is the risk of error. More specifically, it is the possibility of wrongly accepting a false hypothesis or falsely rejecting a correct hypothesis. For example, there is a new cancer drug on the market. There are two types of inductive risk in this scenario. The first, is that scientists presume that it is a safe, effective treatment when it is not, so it stays in the market. The second scenario is that scientists believe this treatment is ineffective and so it is pulled from the market, even though it is actually effective and could cure the cancer....   [tags: Scientific method, Science, Theory, Falsifiability]

Better Essays
946 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Computer Error : Computer Errors

- 1. Computer Errors 1a. What is an error. In the computer world, another word for an error is “corruption. These corruptions happen when data, going from one source to another, is changed. [1] To understand the importance of this change, a more in-depth understanding is needed. Computers speak in their very own language called machine code or binary. This language is a stream of “1’s” and “0’s” is what every operation on every computer in the world depends on to operate. Since nothing in this world is perfect, errors are an eventuality....   [tags: Computer, Computer security, Technology, Error]

Better Essays
1956 words (5.6 pages)

Objective Moral Norms and Values According to Error Theory Essay

- Almost everyone seems to believe that we live in a world with objective norms; norms about what we should and shouldn’t do; norms about what is good and what is bad, what is right and what is wrong. We are always interested in discussing what is morally right or objectively valued but do we ask whether anything is anyhow valued. The error theory already asked whether norms exist at all and what we may mistake as an objective value. Error theory rejects the idea that there are objective moral norms and values that are independent of us....   [tags: norm, objective, moral]

Better Essays
717 words (2 pages)

Healthcare Error Assessment : Healthcare Errors Essay example

- ... The purpose of this paper is to 1) discuss a real-world sentinel event, the affected individuals and how the event was handled by healthcare leaders, internal and external stakeholders, 2) how it influenced quality service delivery, and 3) recommendations for performance improvement to prevent this event from reoccurring. Real-World Sentinel Event Rhode Island Hospital in Providence had several real-world sentinel events of wrong side/site surgeries: three brain surgeries in 2007, cleft palate in 2009, and finger in 2009....   [tags: Surgery, Hospital, Physician, Medical error]

Better Essays
714 words (2 pages)

The Facility Will Provide Medical Error Insurance For Staff Members Essay

- The facility will provide medical error insurance for staff members, The facility will ban electronic devices for personal use in the work place The staff members if they would be allowed to join the union, the benefit would another layer of oversight for the staff members. The facility will notify staff members that non-licensed staff members administer the medication. Each area may need to be evaluated and address in the future with respect to the changes that do occur. Base on several of the interventions presented, it will impact the welfare of the residents in a positive way....   [tags: Health care, Medicine, Medical error]

Better Essays
1608 words (4.6 pages)

The Success Of Taylor Alison Swift Essay

- Taylor Alison Swift was born on December 13, 1989. She is an American singer-songwriter, and actress. She signed with the independent label Big Machine Records and became the youngest songwriter ever hired by the Sony/ATV Music publishing house. The release of Swift 's self-titled debut album in 2006 was the start of her career as a country music singer. Her third single, "Our Song," made her the youngest person who single-handedly write and perform a number-one song on the Hot Country Songs chart....   [tags: Sigmund Freud, Psychosexual development]

Better Essays
1420 words (4.1 pages)

Trial and Error Essay examples

- In life, we are often faced with tasks where we as individuals are called to make decisions, to choose what is right and what is wrong. Making decisions has the possibility of changing your atmosphere, educationally, spiritually, physically, and psychologically. The ability to make decisions is a humanistic quality that expresses, choice, desire, and confidence. The process in which decisions are made happens one of two ways: by theory and logic, or by trial and error. Both are proven to aid in success, but one is more inspiring than the other....   [tags: Literary Analysis]

Better Essays
1130 words (3.2 pages)

The Tides Have Turned By Alison Bechdel Essay

- The Tides Have Turned The circus acts known as Icarian Games have existed for hundreds of years, and the origin myth of Icarus and Daedalus even longer. This story of a father and son is very prevalent in Alison Bechdel’s graphic memoir, Fun Home. Bechdel’s relationship with her father has various parallels to this myth, but who plays which role. Bechdel distorts the Icarus-Daedalus myth to illuminate her views on the role reversal within her growing relationship with her father. In the first two pages of Fun Home, Bechdel associates her father most with Daedalus....   [tags: Daedalus, Minotaur, Icarus, Greek mythology]

Better Essays
1093 words (3.1 pages)

Eyewitness Error Essay

- Memory is a cognitive function of the brain that is often taken for granted. Memory may have many purposes, but most importantly it is essentially a record of an entire life span. From this perspective memory is the most important aspect of consciousness. Unfortunately, through formal experimentation it has been shown that memory is fairly inaccurate, inconsistent, and often influenced by our own experiences as well as the bias of others. Memory is not only affected during an observed event, but there are instances where memory can be influenced after an event as well....   [tags: Justice System ]

Better Essays
1175 words (3.4 pages)