Essay on Alexander's Attempt To Integrate the Greek and Persian People

Essay on Alexander's Attempt To Integrate the Greek and Persian People

Length: 937 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The following gobbet is from Plutarch’s (C. 50 B.C.- C.120 A.D.) Alexander. It narrates Alexander’s journey to the Libyan Oracle of Siwah in 332 . The aim of this essay is to draw the possible reasons as to why Alexander went to this specific oracle its consequences and question the reliability of Plutarch’s account.

Plutarch describes the conversation between the priest of Ammon and Alexander. Alexander inquired if all the murderers of his father were punished to which the priest replied that Alexander was not the son of a mortal.
Plutarch also records the priest mispronouncing “O paidos “ (O son of Zeus) instead of “O paidon” (O my son).
Even if Diodorus and Justin relate the same event and agree that the priest speaking to Alexander referred to him as the son of Zeus, our most reliable source on Alexander, Arrian, whose account is generally well detailed, fails to mention this. Indeed, the only mention of what was said at Siwah was that Alexander ‘heard what was agreeable to his wishes’. So why then does Arrian fail to mention the account of Alexander’s speech with the priest? One possibility would be that this speech never happened.

The deification of Alexander was an important event in his lifetime, in the years before his death he was deified. Although speculation exists as to how Alexander was deified; meaning whether or not it was self-deification.
Roberts suggests that Alexander encouraged many Greek cities to ‘offer him divine cult’, for which they allowed. Plutarch being a biographer and moralist had a tendency to romanticise his subject and as a consequence being subjective. One of Arrian’s principal sources was Ptolemy, who was a key figure during Alexander’s campaign and Pharaoh of Egypt followin...


... middle of paper ...


...: Zeitschrift für Alte Geschichte, Vol.8, No 3, pp. 349-355 at http://www.jstor.org/stable/4434623 (Accessed on 22nd February 2010)
• Robert J. (2007), ‘ruler-cult’ in Oxford Dictionary of the Classical World, Ed. Robert, Oxford Reference Online:Oxford University Press.at http://www.oxfordreference.com/views/ENTRY.html?entry=t180.e1947&srn=1&ssid=1247856200#FIRSTHIT (Accessed on 22nd February 2010)
• Robison C. (1943), ‘Alexander’s Deification’ in The American Journal of Philology, Vol. 64, No. 3, pp.286-301 at http://www.jstor.org/stable/291013 (Accessed on 22nd February 2010)
• Russel D. (2010), ‘Plutarch’ in The Oxford Companion to Classical Civilization, Ed. Hornblower and Spawforth. Oxford Reference Online:Oxford University Press.at http://www.oxfordreference.com/views/ENTRY.html?entry=t133.e497&srn=1&ssid=1128506243#FIRSTHIT (Accessed on 22nd February 2010)

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Taking a Look at Alexander the Great

- Alexander the Great was a renowned leader and military strategist of the ancient Macedonia Empire who conquered most of the ancient known world. His conquest has led about many changes across his empire, which fuses the cultures of East and West, of Asia and Greece. This fusion is known as Hellenization, a period when Greek culture spread in the non-Greek world after Alexander’s conquest. What resulted was a new attitude toward life and its expectations – a new world view, which saw the shift from the Greek ideal of the city-state to universal empires....   [tags: ancient leaders and military strategists]

Better Essays
964 words (2.8 pages)

Alexander The Great Episode Essay

- Alexander The Great Episode The film begins in Iran where we are told of how he was the devil and how he had two horns . They made their hate for him obvious. Th intro also tells us of how he was led to the speaking tree in India that told him that he would die young. That was the end of the introduction. Alexander was born in Macedonia , at a young age he believed that he was the son of god . There was no doubt about his extraordinary parents . His father had seven wives , he was an alcoholic yet a great man who controlled the country well ....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
2842 words (8.1 pages)

The Impact of Greek Philosophy on American Education Essays

- The modern world is becoming more complex day by day, and it seems that most of what surrounds us is actually the result of various ancient practices of philosophy. From the structure and foundation of Government to the fine arts we have today, it is all because of philosophy, and especially the philosophy of the ancient Greeks. Records of history show Greece as the birthplace of philosophic thought, it is said that Philosophy is the child of the wise men of Greece. The philosophers of ancient Greece made many contributions to the modern world, they have a very profound impact on the way people live nowadays, their wisdom affected our fine arts, various fields of science, ment...   [tags: Importance of Education Essays]

Better Essays
1487 words (4.2 pages)

Investigation of the Effect of the Policies of Alexander II in Russia Essay examples

- Investigation of the Effect of the Policies of Alexander II in Russia Alexander 11 was the son of Nicholas 1. Alexander came to the thrown in 1856. Alexander’s reforms were unfair to many especially the peasants. However, they were a step forward for Russia as a whole. The emancipation of the serfs was introduced in 1860. This affected the serfs immensely. The serfs now became peasants and were each given land, which also gave some peasants opportunities to become Kulaks. However, it could be argued that the peasant’s lives were no better than before as the emancipation proved to be very unpopular....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
970 words (2.8 pages)

Lebanon and the Hellas Essay

- Why is it that many Greek artifacts were found in the soils of Lebanon . Why were there Lebanese citizens who were buried in tombs that had Greek carvings . Was Lebanon a Greek occupation or was it a Hellenic vacation spot ?. When Darius perceived the fierce attack of Alexander, he turned his chariot around and was the first to flee, abandoning all of his soldiers and his property to be taken by Alexander. After Darius' loss to Alexander at Gaugamela, the Persian Empire, which included Lebanon, Iran, Armenia, Syria, Israel, Turkey ......   [tags: ancient Greek artifacts]

Better Essays
925 words (2.6 pages)

Alexander The Great Of The Greek Kingdom Of Macedon Essays

- ... Arrian wrote about the Pharaoh Nectanebo visiting Olympius and having sex wither her, then foretelling of her future son: “Be calm, woman, in your womb you carry a male child who will avenge you and will become king and ruler of all the world” (Arrian I.7). Nectanebo uses astrology to predict Alexander’s future, “Woman, you have conceived a male child who will make you fruitful and will avenge the death of his father” (Arrian 1.8). When Alexander was young he visited the Oracle of Ammon at the oasis of Siwa in Egypt’s western desert, consulting her about his divine heritage....   [tags: Alexander the Great, Ancient Greece]

Better Essays
1085 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on Powerful Figures: The Dark Knight

- Since time immemorial, people have been generating images and stories of strong figures that they can look up to. These powerful figures are often referred to as heroes. While the presentation of these heroes and their traditional mythological stories are different from those of modern day fiction, the principles that guide these heroes and make up their stories are very much the same. This paper will examine attempt to show how this is the case, particularly with the hero known as the Dark Knight: Batman....   [tags: batman, greek mythology]

Better Essays
1387 words (4 pages)

Essay Theories, People, Places, And Events Surrounding The New Testament

- The New Testament, a compilation of ancient texts dating from the birth of Jesus Christ to an unknown Second Coming of Christ, is a very important document to the archaeological history of the world, as well as the history of man on Earth. However, one would wonder how and why it was written, what influenced it, who were the people involved in it, what events surround it, and so on. Essentially, what truly influence the New Testament to stand at its current status quo. The attempt is made here to expostulate on that and attempt to provide an answer or answers to those pressing questions....   [tags: Religion Religious ]

Free Essays
1546 words (4.4 pages)

Alexander The Great : A Leader Of The Greek Kingdom Of Macedonia Essay

- Alexandros III Philippou Makedonon, also known as Alexander the Great, is one of the most successful military commanders in history. He was the leader of the Corinthian league and during his years as king he build one of the biggest empires known to humans and conquered most of the known world before his death. During Alexander’s childhood he was tutored by Aristotle in science and political arts, along with his education by Aristotle he also received physical training by a man named Leonidas, a relative of Olympias....   [tags: Alexander the Great, Philip II of Macedon]

Better Essays
853 words (2.4 pages)

Essay on Alexander the Great

- Alexander the Great Alexander the Great, a patient and often devious man; had never struck without careful planning. The youthful, headstrong Alexander liked to settle problems by immediate action. Making decisions with great speed, he took extraordinary risks; his success was achieved by the amount of sheer force and drive to overcome these risks. Alexander was educated as a student by the Greek philosopher Aristotle. The philosopher imbued Alexander with a love of Greek art and poetry, and instilled in him a lasting interest in Philosophy and science....   [tags: Greek Greece Philosophy Science Essays]

Better Essays
2860 words (8.2 pages)