The Supreme Court case to be closely followed and reviewed for class this semester is Madigan v. Levin. This is a case of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois. Lisa Madigan is the petitioner, with Harvey N. Levin being the respondent. On Monday, March 18, 2013, the case was granted and on Monday, October 7, 2013, it was argued. (OYEZ, Inc., 2013)
Facts of the Case:
This is a case of age discrimination. On September 5, 2000, Harvey N. Levin was hired as an Illinois Assistant District Attorney, but was then terminated a little under six years later on May 12, 2006. Being that Levin was over the age of sixty, Levin believed this firing was due to his gender and age. To support Levin’s point, a female attorney in her thirties was hired as his replacement. This led to Levin suing, under the Age Discrimination Employment Act (ADEA), the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment and the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the State of Illinois, Lisa Madigan the Illinois Attorney General, and four other Attorney General employees. (OYEZ, Inc., 2013)
The case was moved for dismissal by the respondent, but the district court had ruled originally that the ADEA granted the qualified immunity for the proceeding and the case was reassigned to a different district court judge. This district court held that Levin was not able to pursue these claims due to not being an employee for covered purposes. Some states are immune to damages from the ADEA, but due to discrimination, the Equal Protection Clause could be violated leading to states being held liable for damages. (OYEZ, Inc., 2013)
After following this case for the majority of the semester, it was difficult to think exactly what the Supr...
... middle of paper ...
... end, Justice Antonin Scalia stated what one could assume the entire Court was thinking, “We don’t like to dismiss a case as improvidently granted, and … only when the -- when the case is before us, counsel suddenly finds all sorts of reasons why we shouldn’t have taken it in the first place. You should have told us that before we took it.” (OYEZ, Inc., 2013), leading to the official dismissal of the Madigan v. Levin.
Before even bringing the case forth, the counsel should have done all research that could have been done. There was much information that could have been brought forward to support both sides, as the Justices stated, yet the counsel kept talking in circles and seemingly had no idea how to even argue the case.
OYEZ, Inc. (2013, September 12). Madigan v. Levin. OYEZ. Retrieved from http://www.oyez.org/cases/2010-2019/2013/2013_12_872#mla
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Our society is facing a serious problem that is the age discrimination between women and men. In 1939 to 1979 white women made less than 60 % as much as white men. The 40% gape difference decreased these days, but there is still a wage gap between men and women. There are many claims behind the reason of wage discrimination. George F. Will (2000)” Lies, Damned lies and …..” claims that the main cause of wage gap is omen’s decision to establish a family, so that force them to make comprise for raising their children and that leads them to work in flexible jobs with flexible ours that permit them to enter the fast track..... [tags: Age Discrimination, Discrimination, gender, ]
443 words (1.3 pages)
- The Issue of Age Discrimination in America The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) protects against age discrimination under Title VII. Specifically, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA), which was passed in 1967 by congress, covers discrimination against employees who are 40 or more years old. This topic should be a big concern for employers, since the number of elderly workers is increasing as the baby boomer population matures. It is estimated that as many as twenty-percent of the claims filed with the EEOC are for age discrimination.... [tags: Age Discrimination Discriminate Equality Essays]
875 words (2.5 pages)
- ... This is also a way for employers to skim away employees they feel would not fit the working environment they built. With third party interviewer services, most apply online. This makes it very easy for firms to single out who they want to hire. Age discrimination is not a new phenomenon. This has been an issue in the workplace for over a half century. The federal Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) was passed in 1967. “Initially, the ADEA solely protected individuals between 40 and 70; however, in 1986 the upper age cap was removed.... [tags: Employment, Discrimination]
1356 words (3.9 pages)
- Age Discrimination in the Workplace The American workforce is getting older. Fact, in between 1970 to 1991, the workforce number over the age of 40 in the U.S. has increased from 39,689,000 to 53,940,000. Because of that, the legislative and judicial developments in the age discrimination in employment have occurred (1). The baby-boomer generation - Americans born between 1946 and 1964 represent more than seventy million workers in the U.S. workplace, and that around 50 percent of the whole workforce.... [tags: Discrimination, Employment, Retirement]
1779 words (5.1 pages)
- ... At this phase, youth are no longer seen as childish, but as “almost-adults”. Throughout these years, teenagers steadily gain more experience and responsibility until they eventually develop into young adults. Young adulthood is usually characterized as a time of exploration and postponement of adult activities. It is socially acceptable to leave home, work temporary jobs, travel, and do anything in general for oneself before one settles down and marries. Usually, middle age adulthood happens directly after, following marriage or the achievement of a decent, steady career in which to support themselves, their partner, and potential children.... [tags: Old age, Middle age, Ageing, Gerontology]
1187 words (3.4 pages)
- Age Discrimination in the Public Sector My topic of discussion will consist of an analysis on the subject of Age discrimination. Age discrimination generally is discriminating on the basis of age, which is illegal under the Federal Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA), and the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). Age discrimination has some special aspects that make it different from other types of employment discrimination. My research will discuss this more in detail. Included will be several court decisions of great importance, the history of the Age Discrimination Statute, and other important data in regards to Age discrimination.... [tags: Discrimination Discriminating Essays]
3250 words (9.3 pages)
- ... For example in this video one of the clips was about Arthur from Kings of Queens a television show. Doug was playing a game with his father-in-law Arthur, during the game Arthur rolled the dice he said it was a 6 and he will buy it. Doug informed him he rolled a five not a six then Arthur became upset and tossed the game. This clip shows Arthur acting in a childish behavior since he wasn’t able to fool Doug and win the game. In the other clip Christmas Vacation, the while family was around the dinner table they ask someone to say grace but she didn’t hear what they said and another women repeat it and said grace and the older women said “she passed away 30 years ago” her husband informed... [tags: Old age, Ageism, Retirement, Gerontology]
1164 words (3.3 pages)
- Age Discrimination in the Workplace Harold had been with the company going on forty-five years. There was no doubt that his contributions over the past few decades helped the once intimate business flourish into an international corporation. As his sixty-fifth birthday rolled around, Harold was greeted with a staff party and a mandatory retirement notice that was effective two weeks from that date. Harold was stunned, inasmuch as he had no intentions whatsoever to leave his position with the company; indeed, he was still fully able to complete his duties better than any new hire ever could, not to mention the fact that his attendance record was spotless.... [tags: Work Ageism Discrimination]
1823 words (5.2 pages)
- Age Discrimination About 200 employees of General Dynamics in Ohio and Pennsylvania sued their company after the company said in 1997 it would discontinue retirement health benefits to union workers younger than 50. Among them was Dennis Cline, a materials driver at the company's Land Systems tank plant in Lima, Ohio. The age discrimination case springs from a dispute between defense contractor General Dynamics and the United Auto Workers eliminated the company's provision of health benefits to subsequently retired employees, except for current workers who were at least 50 years old at the time of the amendment of the agreement.... [tags: Business Ageism Discrimination]
894 words (2.6 pages)
- Ira Levin's A Kiss Before Dying Ira Levin was twenty-two when he wrote his first novel, the award-winning thriller “A Kiss Before Dying”. He was twenty-five when he, fresh from military service, wrote his first play; the smash-hit adaptation of Mac Hyman’s “No Time for Sergeants”.... [tags: Levin Kiss Before Dying Book Review]
1193 words (3.4 pages)