Actions in Negligence: Case Study Essay

Actions in Negligence: Case Study Essay

Length: 828 words (2.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


Through the introduction of the Civil Liability Act the NSW government’s extensive Tort Law reform in 2002 saw changes to the degree at which the courts might apply certain principles to cases of negligence. The CLA has improved to make more predictable the finding of a duty of care with these statutory guidelines. The moral and equitable extent to which this new regime is an improvement however is arguable, as the general principles of the Duty of Care have become somewhat restrictive and difficult for plaintiffs to succeed.


The law of Torts began prior to the era of Industrialisation, where duty for action was minimal due to the majority of claims being for only “intentional” wrongs. Following the Industrialization tasks and jobs become more distinct and citizens began to depend and become more inter-reliant on one another. As articulated by Abel ‘as the focus of tort law has shifted from intentional wrongs among intimates to unintentional injuries among strangers, its moral tone has changed as well’

The CLA with its more rigid control mechanisms to determining a duty of care has no improved to enact a much more probable approach towards bringing about actions in negligence. The specific preconditioned measures listed the CLA include those rejected by the High Court previously in Tame/Annetts , two of which are that a person of ‘normal fortitude’ could have foreseeably suffered the psychiatric harm and that the plaintiff must have had ‘direct perception’ of the incident at the scene or been a ‘close member of the family of the victim’ . In Castel’s case, having successfully passed one of the preconditions for recovery, it was found rather efficiently and predictably that TopClub should owe him a duty of care.

T...


... middle of paper ...


... can further be seen in the case scenario where allowing Frankie’s appeal could potentially pose the risk of opening up the floodgates to mental harm claims by people that watched the incident on TV. Therefore irrespective of Frankie being Sophia’s brother, ruling against TopClub owing Frankie a duty of care proves the more economically efficient option.


As has been attempted by the CLA, the law evolves with respect to the progression of societal values and expectations. The restricting of litigiousness in society through the Civil Liabilities Act has worked to narrow the scope of claiming ‘nervous shock’ however on the contrary it also has the downside to lowering the incentive to prove a duty of care and receive compensation. Thus it remains debatable as to whether the CLA has improved to make more predictable and principled the finding a duty of care.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Action of Negligence Case: Millie vs Huck Essay

- Issue: Can Millie (plaintiff) bring an action of negligence against Huck (defendant) and prove he should be held liable for her loss and damages. Law: In the law of tort, negligence was established in Donoghue v Stevenson [1932] AC 562. It can be described as ‘an omission to do something that a reasonable person would do, or doing something that a prudent and reasonable person would not do. It is the failure to exercise reasonable care and skill’ (Gibson & Fraser 2013, p.166). Application: In a negligence claim, ‘a person is only liable for harm that is a foreseeable consequence of their actions’ (Gibson & Fraser 2013 p.166)....   [tags: Negligence Case Study]

Better Essays
590 words (1.7 pages)

Negligence Case Study Essay

- Review the scenario below. Consider the legal principles influencing the likelihood of any successful action against Steve in negligence. Daria and her lover, Tom, were crossing the road on a pedestrian crossing when Tom was hit and killed by a car being negligently driven by Steve. The car missed Daria by inches. Since the incident Daria has had frequent nightmares and has been unable to return to work. Harry, a policeman patrolling the area, witnessed the incident and went to try to help Tom, but quickly realised that Tom was already dead....   [tags: Law of Tort, Tort Law]

Better Essays
2378 words (6.8 pages)

Case Study of the 4 D's of Negligence Essay

- A dentist fits several children with braces. The children are regular patients of the dentist. The results for some of the patients turn out to be unacceptable and damaging. There are children who have developed gum infections due to improperly tightened braces. Some mistakenly had their permanent teeth removed, while others have misaligned bites. A local attorney becomes aware of these incidences, looks further into it, and realizes the dentist has not been properly trained and holds no legal license to practice dentistry or orthodontics....   [tags: duty, dereliction, cause, damage]

Better Essays
517 words (1.5 pages)

BUG, Inc. Case Study Essays

- BUG, Inc. designs, manufacturers, and sells recording devices that are used by law enforcement agencies to intercept and record sounds and voices. BUG employees write the software that supports BUG. BUG currently ha exclusive contracts with most state and federal law enforcement agencies within the United States. BUG is considering expanding its marketplace to an international level; the manufacturing plants are split between foreign countries and the United States. Intellectual Property Patents, copyrights, trademarks, trade secrets, and names are intellectual property rights....   [tags: Internet, Commerce, Case Study, solution]

Free Essays
1708 words (4.9 pages)

Tort, Negligence and Nuisance Claims Essay

- A number of aspects of liability rise from this case study and each one will be discussed. With regards to the headaches suffered by Karl, it is necessary to look at private nuisance. Negligence is disregarded as it is assumed from the details in the case study that the headaches suffered are not so serious as to cause personal injury, it is just described as ‘mere discomfort’. Such a claim under the law of nuisance requires three factors to be fulfilled. The first being a continuous interference....   [tags: Tort Law]

Free Essays
1310 words (3.7 pages)

Case Study : Company X Ethics Program Essay

- Marko Miskovic EST1- Task 2 2/15/2015 Company X Ethics Program As a new member of the Company X family, there are sets of rules and regulations that every employee must adhere to in order to be successful while performing daily duties, maintain safety within the working environment, and positively contribute to the progress of the company. Standards and procedures are set forth by the company’s leadership as an effort to ensure safety and productivity of employees. Each employee must: 1. Report to duty at the designated time....   [tags: Employment, Management, Negligence, Ethics]

Better Essays
1812 words (5.2 pages)

Legal Case Study Essay

- Introduction Tins must be advised with information that will enlighten her to her options but first we must understand facts and the issues in the case, then information about the legal issues will be presented and then the determination of whether Tina has suffered actual loss or damages and also depict other possible actions that she can take and then a summary describing all of her actions that she can take. Case In Tina’s case the relevant information is; • Tina is looking to buy a house and asks Simon about the safety of the garage, Simon says “don’t worry about that....   [tags: Law Legal Case]

Free Essays
1582 words (4.5 pages)

Case Study : An Owner Of An Investment Property And A Property Manager Who Rents Out Two Apartment Units

- s an owner of an investment property and a property manager who rents out two apartment units, experience has dictated that there are a lot of things that an owner needs to be mindful of when operating a business. It is very important the owners are knowledgeable of the laws that apply to their organization in order to be prepared and prevent possible lawsuits from the city and citizens. The illegal incident that took place at Springfield Arms Apartments, an apartment renting business used primarily for students, is a classic breaking and entering case which questions who should be legally responsible for the damages that occurred....   [tags: Tort, Tort law, Negligence, Common law]

Better Essays
1053 words (3 pages)

International Law Case Study Essay

- International Law Case Study A & B are two homosexuals who have lived together for a number of years. Also living with them is C, who, while aged 30 is mentally abnormal and has a mental age of 10. A and B have cared for C for 2 years since C’s remaining parent, an old friend of theirs, died. C cannot look after himself very well and occasionally goes through periods of deep depression. One day, A thinking that C might learn how to bake a cake, shows C how to mix ingredients and use the gas oven....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1196 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on Legal Case Study

- Legal Case Study The Facts Jenny had an argument with her boyfriend, David, which resulted in David throwing Jenny down some steps. Jenny suffered a very badly broken leg that needed surgery. She also suffered cuts and bruises to her other leg. Question (in 3 parts) (a) Briefly explain the legal requirement that actus reus and mens rea should be contemporaneous (occur together). (5 marks) Plan A brief explanation of actus reus - guilty act, omission, state of affairs, result crimes A brief explanation of mens rea - guilty mind, types of mens rea (intention, recklessness) The requirement that actus reus & mens rea must coincide A brief explanatio...   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
2902 words (8.3 pages)