Judith Thomson’s essay “A Defense of Abortion”, argues about the right to life a fetus and a mother have and how abortion can be morally permissible in certain scenarios. She begins her essay by clarifying that her arguments discuss that abortion is occasionally permissible in certain situations and that it is immoral during others. Also, she addresses the fact that the debate over abortion leans on the argument of whether or not a fetus is a person. Throughout Thomson’s essay, she separates the essay into six arguments and uses her famous violinist example to relate each argument to.
Before Thomson begins her first argument, she elaborates on her very famous violinist example. The violinist metaphor explains that you have just woken up and you are lying in bed next to a famous violinist. The violinist has a fatal kidney condition and the Society of Music Lovers have searched all medical records and have determined that your blood type can save their violinist, so they have kidnapped you. When you wake up you notice your circulatory system is hooked up to his and you will remai...
... middle of paper ...
...is immoral. Thomson’s essay is widely regarded, read, and referenced in many abortion arguments. Acknowledging that the fetus is a person is really only the strongest part of her argument.
“A Defense of Abortion” uses lots of different metaphors and comparisons to argue whether abortion is immoral or moral. Thomson’s use of the violinist example is used throughout her entire essay and is referenced and changed multiple times to fit the different scenarios of her argument. Even though she uses the violinist a lot, that does not make it a strong example or her arguments any stronger. I believe that the argument of abortion will never be solved. There are way too many underlying issues that are extremely hard to find answers to. The divide of pro-life and pro-choice will always be there because it is simply way too hard to find an answer that will please both sides.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Morality of Texas Abortion Limitation It is hard to find an issue causing more division among the American public than abortion. Political, legal, religious and ethical implications come into play every time the question of abortions and reproductive rights is being raised. Looking at the amount of debate this problem provokes, we can easily put it next to such controversial issues as capital punishment and gay rights. (Geuras & Garofalo, 2011, p. 47) Given a strong public opinion on the matter, state legislatures all over the country are tirelessly passing abortion regulations which are being reviewed and implemented by various state agencies.... [tags: Abortion, Human rights, Abortion law, Ethics]
1182 words (3.4 pages)
- Abortion In “Unsafe abortion: The Preventable Pandemic,” Grimes states, “About 50% of unsafe abortion deaths occur in Asia and about 44% in Africa” (“Medical” 3). Basically, Grimes is saying that unsafe abortion can happen anywhere to anybody, and a majority of women are dying do to abortion. Some people are pro-life which people who support women’s rights to abort are. While the other side thinks abortion is murder; but everybody has their own opinion on abortion. Which is why the idea of abortion will always be a controversial issue in our world.... [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Fetus, Ethics]
1540 words (4.4 pages)
- The main problem in the world is inevitable abortion. Because it is about morality; which people tend pay more attention. Nowadays, Abortion is a controversial problem as people think of appropriateness. However, Abortion is necessary in many cases. Three main reasons why abortion should be banned are condition that women are not pregnancy, health problem in mother, and social problem. First, the pregnancy without readiness because the teenagers has sexual relation “premature” because nowadays it has communication is easy and comfortable.... [tags: Abortion Pro Choice Essays]
674 words (1.9 pages)
- An effective scholarly article usually catches people’s attention and enables the readers to come to understanding all the complexity of inquiry issues. Considering the two articles that one should definitely take a notice of, it is important to make an emphasis on “Developments in Laws on Induced Abortion: 1998-2007” and “Legal Abortion Worldwide in 2008: Levels and Recent Trends.” It is interesting to note that both scholarly articles focus on such a social problem as unintended pregnancy drawing a particular attention to an inappropriate bureaucrat-dominated policy-making.... [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Maternal death, Abortion law]
1184 words (3.4 pages)
- Affects of Abortion in America There are hundreds of social problems in the USA today and one of the most complicated is abortion. Abortion is so complicated owing to the fact that it affects a woman’s body, causing it to be a very personal and emotional issue, but at the same time since it is affecting a future American citizen, it becomes a problem that America as a society has to deal with. This causes America to be split into two sides, one side claiming that it should be the woman’s choice since they believe it affects the woman alone and the other side claiming that it affects society as a whole and can’t be left to the woman alone to decide.... [tags: Pregnancy, Birth control, Abortion, Fertility]
1015 words (2.9 pages)
- There are hundreds of social problems in the USA today and one of the most complicated is abortion. Abortion is so complicated owing to the fact that it affects a woman’s body, causing it to be a very personal and emotional issue, but at the same time since it is affecting a future American citizen, it becomes a problem that America as a society has to deal with. This causes America to be split into two sides, one side claiming that it should be the woman’s choice since they believe it affects the woman alone and the other side claiming that it affects society as a whole and can’t be left to the woman alone to decide.... [tags: Pregnancy, Birth control, Fertility, Abortion]
784 words (2.2 pages)
- Poverty in society: Major social issues Steven Soderbergh said after looking up into social issues, “There are three major social issues that this country is struggling with are education, poverty and drugs. Two of them we talk about, and one of them we don’t”. Poverty is a very dangerous factor that can destabilize an entire country. The character Rorschach from Watchmen who was also known as Walter Kovacs was raised in poverty. Poverty is a major foundation of social issues and threatens to divide the nation because of inequalities, in certain income inequality which happens when wealth in a country is poorly distributed among its citizens.... [tags: Poverty, Cycle of poverty, Economic inequality]
1104 words (3.2 pages)
- Philosophy of Abortion With about 1.3 million aborted pregnancies annually, abortion has become one of the most highly debated issues in our country and tends to leave both pro-life and pro-choice advocates furious (Operation Rescue). Many circumstances involved with this issue can make choosing a side tough, including the conditions the fetus will live in after birth and the rape of a women. When debating, people often focus on the personhood of the fetus, the rights the fetus obtains, and the morality of abortion.... [tags: pregnancy, zygote, fetus]
922 words (2.6 pages)
- Teen Pregnancy Teen pregnancy is a major issue in society today. In 2010, an estimated 614,400 U.S. teenagers became pregnant, approximately 89,300 had miscarriages, and 157,500 had legal abortions. Teens are having unprotected sex without knowing the consequences of the choices that the are making. Teens believe that sex is something new that they can try, so they can be popular like their peers. These accusations are wrong, having unprotected sex has major consequences, and by having unprotected sex these teens could be changing their lives forever.... [tags: Teenage pregnancy, Pregnancy, Abortion]
1506 words (4.3 pages)
- Abortion is defined as the premature expulsion of a fetus so that it does not live. Abortions can happen as a result of natural occurrences, but the interest of this paper is abortion that is induced. Abortion has been the topic of heated debates in many places. Nicole Miller went through an abortion at the age of 18, now 20 and is attempting to talk about the experance that it put her through. The government has had long difficult battles over the aspects of abortion. Legal cases have set benchmarks that are somewhat vulnerable.... [tags: essays research papers]
1969 words (5.6 pages)