Marquis is pro-life when it comes to pregnancy, and aborting the fetus is what he wants to prove morally wrong in his argument. Marquis is arguing that fetuses, children, and adults are all human beings and have the right to life. Also, Marquis expresses that losing one’s life is one of the worst things that can happen to a human being. So he technically declares that it is horrible to die but not the worst thing to happen to someone. He starts out with the first premise about how the killing of a fetus deprives it of its potential future experiences. Which is a factual statement in that it states that if someone is dead they obviously cannot participate in future events. In Marquis’ second premise, he states that by not allowing a human being to have those future experiences your action is prima facie (accepted as correct until proven otherwise) morally wrong. Marquis argues about how it is wrong to ...
... middle of paper ...
...ts the validity of his argument. In the beginning, Marquis claims a fact in his first premise by using a moral of society in it not being socially correct to murder people. So, if a fetus is morally considered a person then it is morally wrong to have an abortion. In the second premise in how Marquis believes that it is the same to kill a potential fetus and a human being already born. I do not believe that it outweighs an actual human being already born. It overshadows the fetuses because the human being already born has experiences, relationships, and values in the past and future. Whereas, the fetus only potentially has a future like ours and is a parasite on the mother. The argument Marquis made is not correct because it is not complete with a faulty premise. Thus, if Marquis had a more solid second premise then he could potentially have a solid argument.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Abortion In this paper I will explain Judith Thomson’s argument that abortions are not morally wrong under the condition that the fetus is considered a person. By setting this condition, Thomson advances the argument on why abortions are morally permissible by getting past the triviality of whether the fetus is a person or not. I will explain three cases she presents in which she argues that an abortion is morally justified: (1) It is not wrong to abort a pregnancy that resulted from rape (2) It is not wrong to perform an abortion in order to save the mother’s life (3) In many cases, it is not wrong to abort if the pregnancy resulted from protected, consensual sex and does not threaten the m... [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Fetus, Birth control]
1829 words (5.2 pages)
- Women are prohibited from abortion in country X due to the existence of beliefs that promote inferiority of women. This remains a major problem because the society of country X doesn’t respect women’s political or civil rights that involve making decisions regarding their bodily integrity, which forces women to carry fetuses to term. In this paper, I will argue that we ought to reject Don Marquis’ notion of opposing abortion due to the presence of the fetus’s future of value because Marquis fails to properly account for the type of future that the female fetus would eventually have in a particular setting like country X where civil and political rights are extremely limited.... [tags: Abortion, Abortion debate]
1323 words (3.8 pages)
- Mrs. Smith is faced with the decision on whether or not to have an abortion. She has already two kids of her own and is struggling to make ends meet. Mrs. Smith does not know why she is once again pregnant when she has been using contraception consistently. At the end, she makes the conscious decision of having the abortion. Is her abortion morally justified. The view of abortion simply depends on the person’s point of view on life. The philosopher Don Marquis, argues that abortion is morally wrong because we will then be depriving a fetus of a future life while Judith Jarvis Thomson argues that having an abortion is morally justified because Mrs.... [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Fetus, Embryo]
1718 words (4.9 pages)
- In Dan Marquis’ article, “Why Abortion is Immoral”, he argues that aborting a fetus is like killing a human being already been born and it deprives them of their future. Marquis leaves out the possible exceptions of abortion that includes: a threat to the mom’s life, contraceptives, and pregnancy by rape. First, I will explain Marquis’ pro-life argument in detail about his statements of why abortion is morally wrong. Like in many societies, killing an innocent human being is considered morally wrong just like in the United States.... [tags: Abortion, Morality, Pregnancy, Human]
1145 words (3.3 pages)
- Gonzales V. Carhart “Since human beings are valuable in the way that qualifies them as having a right to life in virtue of what they are, it follows that they have that right, whatever it entails, from the point at which they come into being--and that point (as shown in our first Section) is at conception” (Lee and George 82). The authors of The Wrong Abortion make a clear stance on the issue of abortion, and they make it very clear that abortion is morally wrong and that it strips humans of their birth given rights.... [tags: Roe v. Wade, Abortion]
992 words (2.8 pages)
- Some individuals can get into a heated discussion about abortion. Abortion is a huge ethical topic on whether it is morally right or wrong. There are generally two sides that are taken “pro-life” or “pro-choice.” In this paper I will evaluate two arguments, one taking each side. After reading and evaluating each article I will state where I stand. Although, there is no clear-cut answer for some people, for me personally I am pro-life. I believe abortion is morally wrong. The first article I read was A Defense of Abortion and the author Judith Thomson took the pro-choice stance on abortion.... [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Fetus, Human]
1273 words (3.6 pages)
- What is abortion. When does life begin. These are just some of the controversial questions being asked in the United States today. Abortion is the deliberate termination of a human pregnancy. It is the medical procedure used to end a pregnancy and causes the death of the growing fetus. While abortion should be the most urgent practice to put an end to, it is far from that. Since the Roe v. Wade case in 1973, abortion has been legal in the United States. Since when did creating laws, regulate the killing of innocent children.... [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Utilitarianism, Birth control]
993 words (2.8 pages)
- In discussions of abortion, a controversial issue has been whether abortion is morally permissible. According to anti-abortionists, abortion is the killing of an innocent fetus and is therefore not morally permissible. According to Judith Jarvis Thomson, however, abortion is not morally wrong in most cases and she attacks the anti-abortionist argument. Therefore, they disagree on whether abortion is morally permissible or not. In this paper, I will outline the anti-abortionists argument in numbered premise-conclusion form and show which premise Thomson attacks.... [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Human, Trolley problem]
1580 words (4.5 pages)
- Abortion is the ending of pregnancy before birth and is morally wrong. An abortion results in the death of an embryo or a fetus. Abortion destroys the lives of helpless, innocent children and is illegal in many countries. By aborting these unborn infants, humans are hurting themselves; they are not allowing themselves to meet these new identities and unique personalities. Abortion is very simply wrong. Everyone is raised knowing the difference between right and wrong. Murder is wrong, so why is not abortion.... [tags: Abortion Essays]
1751 words (5 pages)
- Abortion is Morally Wrong Abortion, the termination of pregnancy before the fetus is capable of independent life, can either be spontaneous or induced. It is called "the knowing destruction of the life of an unborn child." (Mass General Laws Chapter 112 Section 12K) When abortion occurs spontaneously, it is called a miscarriage. However, when the loss of a fetus is caused intentionally, it is regarded as a moral issue. Abortion destroys the lives of helpless, innocent children and is illegal in many countries.... [tags: Pro Life Pro-Life]
2161 words (6.2 pages)