A Response Paper To The Good Black

A Response Paper To The Good Black

Length: 1439 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
A Response Essay to The Good Black

The experiences of Larry Mungin, as detailed in Paul Barrett's novel, The Good Black provide the reader with a good framework for understanding the complex issues that face companies and employees when racial questions are on the table. Mungin's experiences at Katten Muchin & Zavis reflect the problems that are involved when a company moves to diversify its work force and the challenges minorities face when considering employment opportunities. One can see that the problems of defining racism against the context of poor management and the typical corporate working environment is extremely difficult. The subsequent litigation in this dispute also gives one insight into the problems of trying a racial discrimination suit.
To best understand the problems that developed between Larry Mungin and his employers as Katten Muchin & Zavis one must consider the reasons why he was offered employment. The position that Mungin was to fill was a recent construct of Mark Dombroff. Dombroff had only recently become a member of the firm himself and was recruited as a "rainmaker" for the firm. Dombroff's first move at Katten Muchin and Zavis was to aggressively pursue a new track for the firm. He envisioned as inclusive Insurance and bankruptcy practice which would cater to the needs of large corporate clients.
Enter Larry Mungin. Mungin was a burgeoning bankruptcy lawyer ready to aggressively pursue a partnership. This was not Mungin's first job, in fact he was looking for a firm in which he could launch his bid for a partnership as he entered his eight year of practicing law. He sought the services of a headhunter who paired him up with Katten Muchin & Zavis. Mungin's headhunter overplayed the possibility of Mungin bringing the FDIC with him if he were to accept an offer from Katten Muchin & Zavis. One can speculate that Dombroff initially considered Mungin because of the possibility of K.M.&Z adding the FDIC to their client list. However, it is also clear that Mungin's race became a deciding factor in his hire. As Dombroff noted " Harvard-Harvard, Weil Gotshal. His experience is bankruptcy, bankruptcy, bankruptcy. He's perfect! And he's black."(Barrett,p.9) Ergo, despite the reservations of partners like Vincent Sergi, concerning the amount of work available for Mungin, Dombroff offered Mungin a job.
Larry Mungin also had some expectations of his own as he considered taking a job at Katten Muchin & Zavis. As we know Larry Mungin sought a job with a firm in which he would be able to make partner.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"A Response Paper To The Good Black." 123HelpMe.com. 01 Apr 2020
    <https://www.123helpme.com/view.asp?id=156244>.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Walk Across America Response Paper

- Walk Across America Response Paper In Walk Across America, Peter Jenkins takes a cross country walk to rediscover himself and the nation. In his journeys, he crosses through various states and meets many different kinds of people. From New York to New Orleans, Peter treks around this great country of ours and falls back in love with the place that he has called home for his entire life. After losing faith in the hypocrisy of America and how we are perceived around the world, Pete wants to find out what everyone thinks is so great about the country....   [tags: essays research papers]

Research Papers
940 words (2.7 pages)

Reflection Paper On Cultural Self

- Cultural Identity Reflection Paper Annise P. Herbin Eastern University Introduction Contemplation of the cultural self involves examination of the development of one’s personality, identity, character, behaviors, and cognitions. These aspects of existence are shaped by family and community and, for me, are elements I strive to connect to the scriptural assertion that humans are created in the image of God. Rubio (2003) states, “Humans aren’t meant to live alone. Rather, they are called to live in relationship—in community—with one another” (p....   [tags: Family, Black people, Race, Long hair]

Research Papers
2429 words (6.9 pages)

Hollywood Vs. America by Michael Medved Essay

- The book that stuck out the most to me this semester was “Hollywood Vs. America”. The reason why I seemed to disagree with this book the majority of the time was because Medved had no sound arguments or sources. The only sources he had within the book were people who basically had the same mindset and worldview as he. This book mainly stuck out to me, purely because it made me mad every time I read it. I really thought, based upon the first couple of pages, that this would be a book I would enjoy....   [tags: extended response paper]

Research Papers
873 words (2.5 pages)

Black And Black Studies Program Essay

- In the late 1960’s America saw a nationwide surge in the demand from Black college students for a Black Studies Program. As these black students watched other movements, such as the Montgomery Bus Boycotts, Brown vs Board of Education and the Freedom Riders, they “became impatient with the slow pace of securing freedom through the courts” ( Anderson and Stewart 29) . The black students at Dickinson College formally began their quest for a Black Studies Program in 1969. While these student leaders organized the student body, various faculty members began to organize in order to petition on the administrative level for the Black Studies Program....   [tags: African American, Race, White American, Racism]

Research Papers
1425 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on Response to Welcome to the City by Murray Forman

- My response paper speaks directly to Murray Forman’s “Welcome to the City” essay, pecifically, the complex relationship the ghetto has with its inhabitants as well as outsiders. In the essay Forman says, “Youth continues to be framed against the American middle-class ideals of a liberated consumer culture” (47). Since our course is focused on black popular culture, I thought it would be interesting to examine the portrayal of domestic space occupied by black families on television sitcoms, a genre defined heavily by shows from the 1950s....   [tags: argumentative]

Research Papers
2211 words (6.3 pages)

Reflection Paper On Stress Management

- REFLECTION PAPER During the course of this class, I have learned a lot about stress and how it affects different aspects of our lives as human beings. Stress management to me refers to the different techniques and other controlling factors that helps regulate or control a person’s level of stress, in other to improve their everyday functioning. The key concepts that has impacted me so far in the course are as follow; MINDFULNESS: According to (Olpin & Hesson , 2015, p. 99) “Mindfulness is commonly defined as the state of being attentive to and aware of what is taking place in the present....   [tags: Emotion, Psychology, Thought, Mind]

Research Papers
2665 words (7.6 pages)

Black Lgbt Collective Identities : Black And Other Non White Essay example

- Black LGBT Collective Identities Black and other non-white LGBTs occupy a unique position in the social world with multiple marginalized identities and this affects the ways in which they navigate through their everyday lives. However, both public and academic discussions of black LGBTs identities have treated their racial and sexual identity as mutually exclusive categories. Previous studies have shown that heterosexual blacks often perceive non-conforming sexual and gender identities to be a white phenomenon, and that many black community leaders and members as well as scholars of black and LGBT civil rights movements have also treated the categories of black and LGBT to be mutually exclu...   [tags: Homosexuality, Gay, Sexual orientation]

Research Papers
1116 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Police Violence On Black Of The United States

- Jah-Wilson Teeba PHILOSOPHY 357 Police Violence on Black In The United States Police violence remains one of the most serious human rights violations in the United States. Over the past decade, police have acted out in ways that have made people wonder “are our officers of the law really doing their job?” Unjustified shootings, severe beatings, fatal choking’s, and rough treatment have all contributed to the ever-present problem of police brutality in America. The fact of the matter is that most of these incidents go un-reported or un-noticed....   [tags: Police, Police brutality, Police officer, Race]

Research Papers
1468 words (4.2 pages)

Essay The Educational Researcher: Review and Response

- 2.1 Forum Analysis A. Research and Identify: Background / History of Forum Although the Educational Researcher does not have a stated political position and is not interested in politics on the surface, some political ideas and opinions are very evident within its pages. In my opinion, the Educational Researcher tends to lean more towards the liberal/progressive side, because the articles they publish tend to have some very progressive ideas, theories and research. The journal also tends to side with educators and professors who for the most part usually lean a little to the left....   [tags: Literary Review]

Research Papers
1920 words (5.5 pages)

African American Response to Uncle Tom's Cabin by Harriet Beecher Stowe

- African American Response to Uncle Tom's Cabin     Many African American 19th Century critics saw Harriet Beecher Stowe's Uncle Tom's Cabin as a ray of hope and a means out of oppression. Critics praised the dialogue, the interjected sentimental stories, as well as the characterization. In fact, many considered the novel to be a gift from God. Uncle Tom's Cabin was the only popularized writing at the time that touched upon slavery as negative. The novel was popular in general but more importantly to African Americans....   [tags: Uncle Tom's Cabin Essays]

Free Essays
1197 words (3.4 pages)

Mungin was apprehensive about the opportunities at Weil Gotshal, because the firm was extremely competitive and partnership was only awarded to those willing to put in extreme hours. At Katten Muchin and Zavis Mungin saw the opportunity to move up in a burgeoning law-firm that was dominated by the under fifty crowd. Mungin was well aware of the possibility that his race combined with his double Harvard pedigree would be an asset for him in the job market. He also wanted to be involved in a firm where his hard work would not be overlooked and the relatively small Katten Muchin & Zavis office in Washington appeared to be just what Mungin had been searching for in a new employer.
The problems that ensued after Larry Mungin was hired can be attributed to three main areas. First, Dumbroff's vision for nation wide insurance and bankruptcy litigation covered by the all inclusive service offered by Katten Muchin and Zavis was never realized. Second, Katten Muchin and Zavis attempted to retain Mungin after the bankruptcy work dried up because of his race. And thirdly, Larry Mungin's life experiences and personal inklings added to the complexity of the situation.
Larry Mungin was recruited to work for Katten Muchin and Zavis because Dombroff believed that bankruptcy work at the firm was going to increase. However, as time wore on business shrunk. When the firm lost a majority of AIG's business Jeff Sherman, Mungin's immediate supervisor, left the firm. Upon Sherman's departure it became clear that the remaining work that Katten Muchin & Zavis had for Mungin was routine at best. This was combined with Gilmore and Dombroff's tendency to cut all other lawyers, at the D.C. office out of the loop on important decisions, both about clients and the functioning of the office. This left Mungin adrift in the office, with work that was not inclined to propel toward a partnership opportunity.
The second major problem was the effort that Katten Muchin and Zavis made to retain Mungin after his job opportunities at the firm folded. Here we see the first point at which Mungin's race separated him from other employees. Had Mungin not been black he may have been fired soon after bankruptcy litigation futures at KMZ were not forthcoming. On the surface and indeed in the minds of senior partners at KMZ, the firm was helping Mungin by keeping him employed. However, his retention was not contingent on placing him in a position where his chances of making partner could be realized.
This brings us to our third area of conflict between Mungin and KMZ. Mungin was a bright, motivated and proud man. He was committed to being the type of black who could distinguish himself from his fellow blacks and integrate seamlessly into a white dominated working environment. While he was certainly no Uncle Tom he sought to make whites, who generally responded differently to him regardless of his level of achievement, comfortable with his presence. To put it simply he did not want his race to effect his prospects. As a consequence of his readiness to put the race issue aside KMZ was able to shuffle him around for an extended period of time before eliciting a response from Mungin.
The conclusions that can be drawn from the experiences of Mungin and KMZ are twofold. Firstly, the hiring and firing practices of firms wishing to increase the number of minorities in their ranks must be carefully thought out. While this goes without saying to some degree the issues in the Mungin case bring some important issues to the fore. KMZ was certainly not unethical in awarding Mungin the job over a white lawyer qualifications qualifications possessing similar qualifications. They were however mistaken to continue to employe Mungin after he was no longer of use to the firm in the capacity for which he was initially hired. Indeed retaining Mungin without retooling him in some other capacity in which his expectations could be met was a disservice to him and useless to the firm.
The other conclusion that can be drawn from Mungins experiences at KMZ pertain to how minorities might approach the hiring process. One may agree with Mungins friend Bruce Shortt when he warned "Think real hard about this," (Barrett, pg. 16) in the context of Mungins excitement for seeking employment with a firm that was dominated by one man (Dombroff) and had grow quickly. Mungin himself could relate to the problems associated with working for a company that had grown to quickly, as his current employer, at the time of the switch, had frozen salaries and was struggling to keep attorneys hired on during boom years working. This advice would be well heeded by anyone seeking employment at an untried company, not just a minority seeking work. The next issue in the Mungin case that pertains more directly to race is Mungin's consideration of KMZ motives. Perhaps some more savvy research would have unearthed some causation to explain the low number of minorities employed by the firm. Minorities face a number of challenges when deciding who to seek employment with and companies with proven histories concerning race relations may offer better long term employment options.
As the verdict and subsequent overturn of that verdict prove the issues in the Mungin case are not clear. A jury of reasonable people, albeit a mostly black jury, found that Mungins civil rights had been violated. However upon review a panel of appellate judges found that the evidence did not bear out the verdict that the jury had reached. Mungin's personal struggle to reach the level of achievement in the legal profession that he did is a compelling story and the callousness of KMZ certainly extinguished some of his prospects. However defining racism in a law firm where no racial insults have been thrown about is a murky endeavor. Was Larry Mungin's life adversely effected by the trial? Maybe or maybe not perhaps the trial offered him a way to define his goals in life rather then striving to succeed merely for the sake of reaching a goal set by his adverse early life experiences.
Return to 123HelpMe.com