Essay on A Research Study On Patient Autonomy

Essay on A Research Study On Patient Autonomy

Length: 954 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The difficulty that may arise when addressing the principle of beneficence, lies in determining what exactly is “good” for another person, and who can best make that decision (Aiken, 2004). When determining whether or not an action is “good”, considerations must be made about outcomes and benefits, both present and future, and personal or communal, as well as rights and costs to the patient (financial, loss, etc.) (Ivanov and Oden, 2013). Sometimes the obligation of beneficence can conflict with respecting patient preferences and patient rights (autonomy). Some even say that patient autonomy should take precedence over beneficence, but this can be difficult to determine and should be considered on a case by case basis (Byrd and Winkelstein, 2014). This point can be illustrated using a clinical example. An elderly patient has been hospitalized for dehydration and a urinary tract infection. The patient has been diagnosed with Alzheimer’s, is at risk for falls, has a history of falls that caused patient injury, and has a tendency to wander. The patient has an IV in place with fluids running, and concerned that the patient may fall or wander off somewhere and dislodge his IV, the staff believes restraining is an optimal solution. However, the patient is adamant about not wanting to be restrained. In this situation, the healthcare team has to decide whether or not beneficence will take precedence over autonomy. In this example, the course of action will take some serious consideration, but if the healthcare provider chooses to uphold the patient’s wishes and it causes harm, the principle of beneficence may be violated (Aiken, 2004). In a more obvious example of beneficence being upheld, a nurse who suspects a child of being ...


... middle of paper ...


...ng justice. An example of justice being violated is a nurse or physician providing different levels of care according to a patient’s socioeconomic status. Say that a patient on welfare has developed respiratory complications associated with a procedure performed earlier in the day, and would greatly benefit from being transferred to the intensive care unit (ICU). The problem is that there is only one bed available in the ICU, and the physician knows that a patient with a higher socioeconomic standing is going to need the bed tomorrow following a surgical procedure. The physician knows that the patient in need of the bed tomorrow will be able to afford the ICU stay without a problem. If the physician makes a decision as to who is to receive the bed based on the patients’ socioeconomic standings, this would be a violation of the principle of justice (Aiken, 2004).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Involuntary Commitment Laws Revolve Around Patient Autonomy Essay example

- Issues relating to involuntary commitment laws revolve around patient autonomy used for and against involuntary treatment. The restoration of autonomy in patient who were once unable to make their own decisions was the goal of treatment. It was presumed that patients in need of treatment were also incapable of decision making. An argument can be made that ethical principles are the underlying the reasoning’s for the promotion of good, and the prevention of harm rather than patient autonomy. Patient autonomy comes from Emmanuel Kant’s ideal of respecting the person, which takes into account the patients liberties....   [tags: Psychiatric hospital, Psychiatry]

Better Essays
1258 words (3.6 pages)

A Research Study On How Nursing Home Excellence And Value Can Be Apprehend From Denizenopinion And Ideas

- Plagiarism approximately 77% in 1 Sources Sources found: all sources 77% www.ukessays.com Purpose of the essay- The objective of this project is to grow a concreteand positive understanding of the capabilities, skillsand the contribution of residents in nursing home care by evaluating a printed qualitative health research study. INTRODUCTION STATEMENT OF PROBLEM: The problem statement is unambiguously and simplyfound in the initialpassage of the critique article. The investigator or the researcherconcentration on how nursing home excellence and value can be apprehend from denizenopinion and ideas....   [tags: Research, Nursing, Nursing home]

Better Essays
1011 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Nursing Assessment and Patient Care

- ... Manual of critical care nursing. St. Louis, Mo: Elsevier Mosby. Baxter, S. K. and Brumfitt, S. M. 2008. Professional differences in interprofessional working. Journal of Interprofessional Care, 22 (3), pp. 239-251. Beauchamp, T. L. and Childress, J. F. 2004. Principles of biomedical ethics. New York, N.Y: Oxford University Press. Bench, S. 2004. Clinical skills: assessing and treating shock: a nursing perspective. British journal of nursing, 13 (12), pp. 715-721. Bentley, J. 2001. Promoting patient partnership in wound care....   [tags: NICE guidelines, ABCDE approach, MEWS]

Better Essays
1179 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on The Patient Intake Interview

- The intake interview assists in establishing and diagnosing any problems the client may have. The therapist may then explain to the client what to expect during the interview, including the time duration. A good assessment/ or intake will focus on the individual situation, strength and coping mechanism. The intake form is for the client, it gives the therapist more information and an idea of who you are. The intake process that is considered of a series of questions and consent form that the client has to sign and agree to....   [tags: counselor, mantain boundaries]

Better Essays
896 words (2.6 pages)

Critical Analysis of the Article Everyday Ethics: Ethical Issues and Stress in Nursing Practice

- Author’s Credentials and Other Information Connie M. Ulrich, PhD, RN is an associate Professor of Bioethics and Nursing center for Bioethics, Department of Medical Ethics, and Senior Fellow. Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics, New Courtland Center for Transitions and Health, School of Nursing, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Carol Taylor PhD, RN is the Director for the Center for Bioethics at Georgetown University, Washington, District of Columbia. Karen Soeken PhD is a Professor Emeritus at the University Of Maryland School Of Nursing, Baltimore, Maryland....   [tags: autonomy, rights, healthcare]

Better Essays
712 words (2 pages)

The Long Term Side Effects Essay

- In September 2014, a 17-year-old girl by the name of Cassandra was diagnosed with stage 3-4 Hodgkin’s lymphoma. Her doctors compromised and recommended her to start chemotherapy because it had an 80 to 95 percent success rate in treating Hodgkin’s lymphoma. If she opts out from the chemotherapy, her life expectancy was approximately two years. Both Cassandra and her mom were weighing in the pros and cons of the chemotherapy especially the long term side effects such has heart damage and infertility....   [tags: Medicine, Physician, Autonomy, Chemotherapy]

Better Essays
945 words (2.7 pages)

Ethical Implications of Egg Donation Essay

- Many studies have been done pertaining to egg donation and its medical aspect, but very few studies shows the ethical implications of egg donations. Health Laws such as Fertility Clinic Success Rate and Certification Act,1992 regulates the advertisement of success rate of fertility clinic. Only few states have federal laws for informed consent from egg donors (1-3). Informed consent means that donor understands all the minor details surrounding the egg donation procedure, its side-effects- medical, legal, ethical and emotional and gives permission to undergo the procedure without hesitation or coercion....   [tags: risky, autonomy, ovarian hyperstimulation]

Better Essays
544 words (1.6 pages)

A Research Study On Buying A Car Essay

- Introduction Buying a car is a regular occurrence in most peoples’ lives. If that car breaks you get upset, and you have to buy spare parts. This is a common analogy pitted with the idea of having a savior baby. Savior siblings are children who are born to provide transplant parts to a sibling that is affected with a fatal disease. The embryos are conceived through in vitro fertilization and the zygotes are tested for genetic compatibility and for the disease their sibling has. Compatible embryos are then implanted into the mother....   [tags: In vitro fertilisation]

Better Essays
1347 words (3.8 pages)

How Interprofessional Collaborative Practice Improve Patient Outcomes Essay

- III. Change Implication to Evaluate Interprofessional Collaborative Practice It is obvious that a great deal of interprofessional research has been aimed to educate practitioners and nurses over the past decade for interprofessional practice (Orchard, King, Khalil & Beezina, 2012). The Institute of Medicine (IOM) “The Future of Nursing Leading Change, Advancing Health” (2010) recommend that private and public organizations, nursing programs and associations increase opportunities for nurses to lead and manage collaborative teams....   [tags: Health care, Health care provider, Healthcare]

Better Essays
1467 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on Doctor Patient Communication

- Doctor Patient Communication The main purpose of the medical interview is to collect historical information that can be used to make a diagnosis of the disease and to understand the patient’s problem. (Henderson, 11) This is the beginning of the physician – patient relationship. The interview generally begins by the doctor greeting the patient, introducing himself/herself, and defines his/her professional role. Common courtesy dictates that the physician learns the patient’s name and refers to them with the proper title....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
1912 words (5.5 pages)