Essay about A Politics Of The Common Good

Essay about A Politics Of The Common Good

Length: 1569 words (4.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Communitarians argue that a politics of the 'common good ' is needed to develop and maintain social unity. Liberals argue that a politics of the 'common good ' is incompatible with state neutrality and therefore fails to treat all citizens with equal respect and concern. In this essay I shall discuss and assess these arguments, focusing on aspects of each which I hold to be significant. Attention will be given to each theory 's notion of the self, which I see as key in the formation of each argument. In addition, I will note possible problems and challenges facing each position. Following this, the implications posed by each argument in terms of justice, will be considered. Ultimately, I will conclude that the communitarian argument faces too many challenges and should be rejected, whereas the liberal argument has merit and offers a better case in terms of justice.

The communitarian argument for a politics of the common good in order to develop and maintain social unity, is based upon the premise that the self is constituted by the community (Kymlicka 2002: 221-224). For communitarians, it is not individuals who examine and define their own ends, as such ends have already been developed by, and exist within, a given community. According to communitarians, individuals discover their self by deeply immersing themselves in the community 's way of life, internalising the community 's conceptions of good, and embracing social roles that have been pre-determined by culture or custom – the promotion of which is the duty of the communitarian state (Kymlicka 2002: 220-221). However, communitarians see their societies as vulnerable (Kymlicka 2002: 238), and that the vast array of ends in modern societies stand as a threat to the maintena...

... middle of paper ...

...viduals, and this leaves some members of the community vulnerable to discrimination and oppression, if they are unable or unwilling to embrace the community 's doctrine and conception of the good. For liberals, the individual comes first. However, this does not mean anything goes, as one does not have the right to conceive and act upon a notion of the good if it does not respect another 's capacity for self-determination. As expressed in this essay, both arguments face their own challenges, however, those facing communitarians leave their argument looking unattractive, and provide enough weight for its rejection. Conversely, although the liberal argument faces challenges, it is far more appealing, given its grounding premise which holds that people exist as ends, before the community. As such, it is far less likely to lead to arbitrary discrimination and oppression.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Politics, Power And The Common Good Essay

- Contentious politics are a normal and key part of a functioning democracy. Contentious politics consist of the “disruptive, direct and highly conflictive” means individuals use, such as protests, to address their governments or local authorities to change or take action regarding certain issues (Mintz et al. 240) . They play a key part of functional democracy as the fundamentals of a democracy lie on power being vested in the people as well as freedom of expression, both of which are evident in protests....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Better Essays
1230 words (3.5 pages)

The Common Good in Hobbes, De Tocqueville and Marx Essay

- The Common Good in Hobbes, De Tocqueville and Marx Political philosophies are those theories and ideas that seek to study the impact of various political idealisms on society, and their impact in the shaping of social, political, and economic ideas. The questions which political philosophy seeks to turn its attention towards range from describing what the state of Man actually is at the existential level, to the types of social regimes, which are necessary to tame and organise that nature. In this context, there is a measure of truth in the suggestion that the answers, or visions they give are not, necessarily, entirely original....   [tags: Philosophy Politics Papers]

Free Essays
2748 words (7.9 pages)

Detrimental Effect of Television on American Politics Essay

- Image is everything. In the modern world of sleek cars, towering glass buildings, carefully designed websites and carefully designed women on the front of magazines, this comes as no surprise. What does come as a surprise, what should come as a surprise, is that this fascination with image, this obsession with physical appearance, has seeped into the one area it least belongs. Politicians, the men and women who are supposed to be leading our nation, now have to be just as careful of their image as any supermodel or screen star....   [tags: Politics]

Better Essays
1191 words (3.4 pages)

Essay about The Role of Politics in Public Transportation

- Politics plays an important role in any aspect of planning, but none such more than transport planning and the investments and policies that go in to constructing the aspects associated. As with any discipline, politics plays both positive and negative roles in public transport planning, policies and investment; as it shapes decision-making and the degrees of financial support that is given to each project. Because politics brings both positive and negative effects to public transport planning it can both promote and obstruct development....   [tags: public transport planning,politics,transportation]

Better Essays
1989 words (5.7 pages)

The Rise of Modernism through Medieval Politics Essay

- Medieval philosophies had a tremendous impact on both political and social life for many centuries that followed. The 15th century marked the end of the Medieval era and gave rise to a time period known as modernity. Modernity was coined by the famous philosophical thinker Charles Baudelaire; he depicted this time in history as a shift from feudalism to capitalism and the influence of secularization and industrialization. Modernity was truly seen as a major breakthrough from post medieval society into a new and evolving culture....   [tags: Modernity, Politics, Social Life]

Better Essays
964 words (2.8 pages)

Aristotle’s Politics - The Good Man Should Not Rule the City Essay

- Aristotle’s Politics - The Good Man Should Not Rule the City Aristotle contends that the good man is dissimilar to the good citizen in ways he goes a great length to illustrate. He distinguishes the two for the purpose of facilitating his later arguments concerning the appropriate allocation of sovereignty to the rightful ruler, who he subsequently claims is the good man who excels all others in each and every aspect. Aristotle's distinction further prompts the notion that he advocates a monarchial form of constitution, for the rule of a single good man is equivalent to a constitution of kingship....   [tags: Aristotle Poetics Politics Essays]

Better Essays
2514 words (7.2 pages)

Politics, Propaganda, and Hate Essay

- Politics, Propaganda, and Hate Propaganda is very important issue in our society. The word "propaganda" however, has a very negative connotation. This may happen because people tend to associate it with "the enormous campaigns that were waged by Hitler and Stalin,' (Delwiche 2002). Now propaganda has a different face. It may not be as obvious as but it is used regurlarly by politicians, companies and others who are interested in influencing our behaviour. "Propaganda is the control of opinion by significant symbols influence", (Laswell, as cited in Chadwick)....   [tags: What is Politics?]

Better Essays
1010 words (2.9 pages)

Politics of and Without Difference Essay

- Politics of and Without Difference The sociological concepts of "Politics of Difference" and "Politics Without Difference" are more similar than their names suggest, but they are at the same time extremely different. Both political ideals come from progressive civil rights principles beginning during the Enlightenment in Europe and evolving throughout The Civil Rights Movement in the United States in the 60's. The fundamental basis of the two concepts is that all people are created equal, and that all people should have equal political and civil rights....   [tags: Politics Political Multiculturalism Essays]

Better Essays
1471 words (4.2 pages)

The Politics of Pope John Paul II Essay

- Karol Jozef Wojtyla was born in Wadowice, Poland on May 18, 1920, shortly after Marshal Jozef Pilsudski defeated the Soviet Red Army to gain Polish independence. Like most young boys, Karol enjoyed an active childhood, playing soccer and swimming often, although he was most known for his remarkable intelligence and respect at a very young age. When he was eight years old, his mother, Emilia, died of an infection of the heart, and shortly afterward, his only brother, a physician, contracted scarlet fever from a patient and passed away....   [tags: Essays on Politics]

Better Essays
4144 words (11.8 pages)

Essay on Augustine's Concept of Politics

- Augustine's Concept of Politics For Augustine, political life is a necessary evil. Why is it evil and why is it necessary. How then, does his claim influence his political theory. Introduction It is probably prudent to begin by discussing some of the fundamental beliefs of St. Augustine in order to better tackle the question. We must remember that St. Augustine is first and foremost a theologian, and thus his beliefs are firmly rooted in the teachings of Christianity. He accepted the doctrine of the Bible, i.e....   [tags: Politics Theology Augustine Essays]

Better Essays
2408 words (6.9 pages)