Essay A Myth that Shaped Reality: The Native Americans and Discrimination

Essay A Myth that Shaped Reality: The Native Americans and Discrimination

Length: 1120 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Most Americans in the nineteenth century did not appreciate or understand their Indian neighbors. The Native American lifestyle seemed foreign and uncivilized compared with American society, which was experiencing unprecedented revolutions in technology and engineering. For this reason, a myth began to develop in the minds of the American people that the Indian presence in the West was unacceptable and that the American government needed to take action to solve the problem of the “uncivilized” Indians. Over time, two conflicting opinions developed concerning the form that the proposed government intervention should take. Some thought that the Native Americans were pitiful, uncultured people who should be trained to assimilate and succeed in the modern world. Others were convinced that the Indians were a violent, subhuman race who should be exterminated in order to ease westward expansion. These opposing views were expressed not only in politics, but also in paintings. Several nineteenth century painters attempted to capture different sides of this debate in their art, but regardless of the opinions of the painters, all of these paintings were based on the myth of the uncivilized Indian.
In 1863, Albert Bierstadt completed The Rocky Mountains, Lander’s Peak, a painting which fantasizes the Rocky Mountains and portrays the Indians as “noble savages” (The Humanities pg 1047-1048). In the foreground of the painting is a green meadow populated by Native Americans. Some of the Indians are shown sitting down, while others are gathered around the spoils of a recent hunt. Beyond the field is a glassy lake, fed by a foaming cascade from the mountains. The land then gradually rises in wooded ridges and sunlit cliffs, ultimately culminating...

... middle of paper ...

...ccessfully within the confines of that culture for centuries before Europeans ever arrived on the American continent.
Even though Americans had different opinions about the way the government should handle the Native American tribes, the myth accepted by most people was that the Indians were uncivilized and wrong in their way of life. Americans also believed that the government needed to take action, whether by obliterating the Indians entirely or by integrating them into society. In the end, both well-intended policies and actions of violence proved devastating to the natives. Many Indian tribes were either exterminated or relocated in horrible ways (The Humanities pg 1050-1051). While American nationalism increased during the nineteenth century, the first American culture was wiped out because it was deemed to be a hindrance to progress and advancing civilization.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Native Americans And American Indians Essays

- ... These ideas have been popularised however the reality of these situation was quite different. These myths were inaugurated as a result of the Wild West ideology and the publicised events that took place along such trails as the Santa Fe. It is therefore relevant to incorporate such myths into the study in order to discern the historical impact of the Santa Fe Trail. Towards the modern era, there is a more revisionist consideration for the frontier as a border, called the New Western regionalists....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
1635 words (4.7 pages)

The Rituals Of Native Americans Essays

- ... It is said that a spirit named Peyote came to a man or woman in dire distress, where he then transports them to a spiritual realm where they are taught the ritual. Peyote then returns them to Earth, where the man or woman then disseminates the ritual to the others. It is said that the spirit itself had imbued itself into the cactus. The myth is often altered from tribe to tribe with various alterations, however the idea that among the Kiowa, Comanche, and Navajo tribes this myth exists is a clear example that this myth has crossed cultural and linguistic boundaries....   [tags: Religion, Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
1664 words (4.8 pages)

History of the Mandan Indian Tribe Essay

- The Mandan are an indigenous tribe native to North America. The Mandan’s are known for being one of the earliest tribes to live on the great plains of the Midwest. Unlike other plains Indians the Mandan were a settled tribe who lived along the Big Bend of the Missouri River in what is now called North Dakota. While most tribes that lived in the plains were hunter/gatherers who lived a nomadic lifestyle following their food, the Mandan were planters living mostly off their crops. Warriors left once a year in hunting groups to go out into the plains in search for Buffalo, which was not only their major meat source, but was also used for clothing and shelter as well....   [tags: American History, native americans]

Strong Essays
2521 words (7.2 pages)

The Native Americans Essay examples

- ... It seems appropriate to begin this essay appreciating the complexity and diversity of Native American societies pre-Columbus, in contrast to what historians previously thought of them. The diversity of the Native Americans stems from their distinctive ideas about religion, which largely influenced their political systems. Some communities were ruled by a single person, as in chiefdoms, others were ruled by several leaders, as in confederacies, and some had no underlying political organization at all....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
1762 words (5 pages)

The Native American Native Americans Essay

- ... Secondly, Columbus and Hariot both believed the natives to be “simple in war-like matters” (Document 1). When it came to the type of weapons, Native Americans, “they had no edged tools or weapons of iron or steel to attack with, nor did they know how to make them. The only weapons they possessed were bows made of witch hazel, arrows made of reeds, and flat-edged wooden truncheons, which were about a yard long. As for defense, they wore armour made out of sticks that were wickered together with thread, and carried shields made out of bark” (Document 2)....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
1188 words (3.4 pages)

Native American And Native Americans Essay

- Over the past century, many Native American groups have experienced social and environmental change and have had to deal with a variety of contemporary issues. Although Native Americans may be associated with the past due to popular culture, many different American Indian groups are strongly affected by modern issues. For instance, while type II diabetes is a major issue in many communities, it disproportionately affects Native Americans. Beginning in the 20th century, Native American groups have been affected by diabetes, and they are currently one of the populations that are at particularly high risk for developing the disease....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
3303 words (9.4 pages)

Native Americans: Good or Evil People Essays

- Over the course of history, there have been many different views of Native Americans, or Indians, as many have referred to them. Some have written about them in a positive and respectful manner while others have seen them as pure evil that waged war and killed innocent men, women, and children. No matter what point of view one takes, though, one thing is clear and that is if it were not for these people the early settlers would not have survived their first year in the new land now called the United States of America....   [tags: Native Americans]

Strong Essays
932 words (2.7 pages)

The Native Americans' Lack of Materialism Essay

- People have been living in America for countless years, even before Europeans had discovered and populated it. These people, named Native Americans or American Indians, have a unique and singular culture and lifestyle unlike any other. Native Americans were divided into several groups or tribes. Each one tribe developed an own language, housing, clothing, and other cultural aspects. As we take a look into their society’s customs we can learn additional information about the lives of these indigenous people of the United States....   [tags: Native Americans, USA, ]

Strong Essays
610 words (1.7 pages)

Stereotypical Images Of Native Americans Essays

- ... However it has subconsciously influenced its readers with the stereotypes of the Native Americans, mainly the idea that the natives are a vanishing race which is exemplified by the death of Uncas (p340) leaving his father Chingachgook as the last of the Mohicans. Native Americans nowadays are far from gone but the myth of the vanishing race make people believe that it is harmless to have stereotypes of them since there is a low chance that they would successfully retaliate. Edward Curtis ' self-approved photographs of Native Americans were influential as it garnered interested for the supposed vanishing Native American race at the time....   [tags: Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
1395 words (4 pages)

Essay about Native American And Native Americans

- ... The Paleo-Indian Era can be dated back to 10,000 B.C, until around 7,000 B.C. which began the Archaic Period Native American during this time had developed knowledge to build basic shelters, make stone weapons, and stone tools. Around 1,000 AD began the Woodland period which included the Adena Culture this culture consisted of the building of mounds, burial complexes, and the use of ceremonial systems. The Woodland Era saw the introduction of pottery and the beginnings of settled farming communities, the Native Americans began the construction of burial mounds....   [tags: Cherokee, Native Americans in the United States]

Strong Essays
1079 words (3.1 pages)