A Critical Comparison of Shakespeare's "Sonnet 130" and Elizabeth Barrett-Browning's "Sonnet 14"

A Critical Comparison of Shakespeare's "Sonnet 130" and Elizabeth Barrett-Browning's "Sonnet 14"

Length: 1338 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Petrarchan sonnets are like all the other typical sonnets in the early sixteenth which consist of 14 verses in the poem and 10 syllables per line. In comparison, they all instigate the traditional theme of love where women were admired and sometimes worshipped in order to express deep love that emissaries her beauty.
However, Petrarchan sonnet could not said be too congruent to sixteenth style of writing sonnets. Nevertheless, they share identical theme in the sonnets which is the traditional theme of love where Petrarchan sonnets uses clichés in order to describe his mistress as “lucid gold” and her smile as “angelic smile”. It is implicit where intensely romantic images are clearly used in here to challenge the conventional representations of females’ beauty and is to create beauty and communicate meaning within a tightly structured format. It is to work within self-imposed restrictions to discover just how much one can accomplish. “Shall I compare thee to a summer’s day?” this is found in the courtly love poems which mesmerizes to his mistress that awes at her beauty clearly in this verse. Women were clearly challenged which implicit from the tone, but in comparison they show great identity to the challengeable images to describe their mistresses in their own ways.

Shakespeare’s style of writing sonnets subverts the Barrate-Browning’s style of writing sonnets, where they antithesis the traditional view of love. The most basic gist in both sonnets that they both address to their loved ones which is courtly described the reality in both sonnets. In comparison Shakespeare addresses his sonnet to a “Dark Lady” which lacks of clichés and very touched poignancy. In addition Elizabeth Barrett –Browning addresses her sonnet t...


... middle of paper ...


...of love according to their base of love and how do they in fact subvert it.
In comparison, both sonnets has the equivalent feelings on the reader which is to love a person for a sake of love and that love does not forever come from the physical attractions with whichever person.
In contrast both sonneteers have not the same point of view; one is literally describing his mistress and the other telling to love for the sake of love. So my point of view is that both have not the identical effect on the reader, it varies a lot according to the base and their point of view.
If to ask for an opinion, I would say I prefer the one that subverts the tradition, is because honesty and truth it tells, besides if someone wants to love a person should not love of thy eyes sparkling like a sun, nevertheless I mean the logic there is none who can be depicted in that way anyway.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Analysis Of ' Sonnet Xliii ' By Elizabeth Barrett Browning Essay

- ... Already in the beginning of the sonnet, Browning uses such a strong intangible descriptor of her love (her soul) that it is almost impossible to wrap one 's head around, let alone imagine, the volume, or "the depth and breadth and height" (2) of her soul. If Browning were to compare the volume of her love to something tangible, physical, and visual rather than her soul, the reader be able to have a reference to begin to imagine an image of said tangible object 's volume. This very case also appears when Browning writes, "I love thee to the level of everyday 's / Most quiet need, by sun and candlelight" (5-6)....   [tags: Elizabeth Barrett Browning, Love, Immortality]

Strong Essays
784 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Rhetorical Analysis Of Elizabeth Barrett Browning

- Elizabeth Barrett Browning, married to poet Robert Browning, was a very prominent poet during the Victorian Era. Although she has written countless love poems, she had “established herself as a woman who was never afraid to express her views on contemporary social and political issues, a position which often marked her out as unconventional and combative” (Avery). Her fearless attitude poured through her poems, and as a result she influences people across the world, most famously Emily Dickinson, who idolized Browning and her achievements (“Elizabeth Barrett Browning”)....   [tags: Elizabeth Barrett Browning, Robert Browning]

Strong Essays
1123 words (3.2 pages)

Elizabeth Barrett Browning And William Shakespeare Essay

- ... The two poems, "S43" by (EBB) and "S130" by (WS), share similarities and differences. During the “sixteenth” century, poetry was expected to follow the popular "Blazon" style for which is used to define heraldry. “This method of depiction was translated into poetry and was used to portray the features of the human, usually the female body. A typical blazon would start with the hair and work downward, focusing on eyes, ears, lips, neck, breasts and so on.” (Woolway). In other words, the speaker describes the physical beauty of a lover 's body as it focuses mostly on the woman’s characteristics....   [tags: Poetry, Elizabeth Barrett Browning, Sonnet]

Strong Essays
782 words (2.2 pages)

Essay on Elizabeth Barrett Browning 's Sonnet 32

- ... Ultimately, there is a disconnect between the social events taking place in the poem, and how the speaker feels about the advancement of their relationship. The following lines, four and five, continue the issue of the speaker being remorseful of the timing of her union with her lover. Examining line five, the speaker relays that she has been “quickly tied” to her partner into a “lasting troth” or engagement. (4) Both have two syllable words followed by a single syllable word that creates a brisk rhythm....   [tags: Elizabeth Barrett Browning, Robert Browning]

Strong Essays
994 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on How Do I Love Thee, By Elizabeth Barrett Browning

- Well known for one of her most famous poem How Do I Love Thee, Elizabeth Barrett Browning, was a respected poet long before her marriage to Robert Browning. It seems that her memory is known for this poem written about her husband. The quiet romance that happened between the two is what seems to pull readers in, as well as Mrs. Browning 's life. From a life threatening sickness to a famous poet and a love filled marriage, Elizabeth Barrett Browning had a life that people would want to know about for centuries....   [tags: Elizabeth Barrett Browning, Robert Browning]

Strong Essays
1066 words (3 pages)

How Do I Love Thee By Elizabeth Barrett Browning Essay

- “How Do I Love Thee” by Elizabeth Barrett Browning: An Analysis Poetry has been used for centuries as a medium for expressions of love. From romantic to familial love, there is a poem for it, describing its nature. These poems typically also convey clear or implicit ideologies relating to gender and gender construction. Sonnet 43 or “How do I Love Thee?” is arguably one of the greatest love poems of all time. Written by Elizabeth Barrett Browning in 1850, it can only be described, as an outright expression of romantic love, of which is unusual for females in Victorian England....   [tags: Poetry, Elizabeth Barrett Browning, Sonnet]

Strong Essays
1107 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about Analysis Of Elizabeth Barrett Browning 's Sonnets From The Portuguese

- Elizabeth Barrett Browning was known as one of the most prominent English poets in the Victorian era (1837-1901) and one of her books was popular in Britain but also in the United States. These book of sonnets that she has created was influenced by her Husband Robert Browning who called her “his Portuguese” which is why she named her book “Sonnets from the Portuguese” which consists of 44 sonnets and 60 other poems of hers. As she grew up in London during a time of slavery and her father’s mismanagement in 1826, I find that these occurrences affected her poetry and how she wrote them....   [tags: Poetry, Sonnet, Elizabeth Barrett Browning]

Strong Essays
1072 words (3.1 pages)

How Do I Love Thee? Let me Count the Ways by Elizabeth Barrett Browning

- A flame of passion is contained within the heart, yet is love contained in a mere flame of passion. This timeless saying embodies the ultimate declaration of love written by Elizabeth Barrett Browning. “How Do I Love Thee. Let me Count the Ways” is a poem bathed in rhyme and inundated in sentimental avowals. This sonnet shows the perpetual love that Browning shares with her husband and how that love can never be destroyed by any power of human or spiritual nature (Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s: Sonnet 45)....   [tags: Elizabeth Barrett Browning Poem]

Strong Essays
1159 words (3.3 pages)

Elizabeth Barrett Browning : Ideal Love By Breaking The Social Conventions Of The Victorian Age

- ... Even though the conventions of society were against her, she was able to fight conventions and wait till her true love was discovered Body 2 Ideal love by following Social Conventions Unlike Barrett Browning, Gatsby tries to achieve his ideal love by following the social conventions of the Jazz age. The Jazz Age was a period after World War 1, where there was an increased emphasis on materialistic desires due to the economic boom that was due to the war. “The Great Gatsby” is a novel about Nick’s view of the relationship between Gatsby and Daisy....   [tags: Elizabeth Barrett Browning, F. Scott Fitzgerald]

Strong Essays
1038 words (3 pages)

The Life of Elizabeth Barrett Browning Essays

- Elizabeth Barrett Moulton-Barrett was born March 6, 1806 in Durham, England to Edward Barrett Moulton-Barrett and Mary Graham Clarke. She was the eldest of twelve. Her father made the family fortune from a sugar plantation. In 1809, the Barretts moved to an estate called Hope End in England. Elizabeth Barrett’s childhood was spent happily at the family’s home in England. She had no formal education, learning solely from her brother’s tutor and from her continuous reading. She managed over the years to learn Greek, Latin, Hebrew, French, Italian, German, and Spanish....   [tags: Essays Papers]

Strong Essays
1294 words (3.7 pages)