A Conservative Response to Restorative Justice Essay

A Conservative Response to Restorative Justice Essay

Length: 696 words (2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

How would a conservative reply to a proposal for restorative justice? How would a restorative justice advocate respond to a conservative proposal for more prisons?
Restorative justice is defined as “using humanistic, no punitive strategies to right wrongs and restore social harmony” (Siegel, 2008, p. 189). Instead of imposing harsh penalties on offenders like long prison sentences or even the death penalty, restorative justice calls for a more rehabilitative approach, such as reconciliation and offender assistance.
Even though restorative justice has many supporters, it also boasts numerous opponents as well. In response to a proposal for restorative justice, conservatives largely contest the idea in favor of a more “get-tough” on criminals approach. “According to conservative theory, human beings are obliged to curb their drive for self-gratification. Offenders are to be punished harshly in order to provide them with a moral lesson and to serve as a general deterrent” (Mantle, Fox, & Dhami, 2005, p. 20). Many citizens worry that with the advancement of restorative justice comes the loss of state and government power. Because formal court processes are usually avoided and communities execute their own “judge and jury” practices when a crime is committed, restorative justice is sometimes seen as a threat to traditional U.S. state and federal court systems. A reduction in the involvement of the American court systems is viewed as a “breakdown of traditional social and legal authority” (Mantle et al., 2005, p. 20). With “a culture that is becoming increasingly conservative and focused on security rather than personal freedom,” (Siegel, 2008, p. 194) many conservatives are resistant to a form of justice that gives more liberty an...

... middle of paper ...

...r person in authority” (Mantle et al., 2005, p. 7). Native Americans are also historically known for using the “sentencing circle “where villagers could discuss an offender’s crime with him or her and jointly decide on a rehabilitative measure.
Restorative justice has many opponents and advocates. Whether or not this approach to criminal justice will gain a stronger foothold in our society is yet to be determined, but restorative justice is not likely to disappear anytime soon.
Erin C. Young

Greg Mantle, F. D., & Dhami, M. K. (2005). Restorative justice and three individual theories of crime. Internet Journal of Criminology IJC , 1-36. Retrieved from http://www.restorativejustice.org/articlesdb/articles/5914
Siegel, L. J. (2008). Critical criminology: It's a class thing. Criminology: The core (pp. 173-196). Belmont, CA: Wadsworth Publishing.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Restorative Justice And The Justice System Essay

- Restorative justice is an alternative process through which the offender must embrace the core values of accountability and responsibility. The offender must focus on the harm done to victims and their needs in recovering are at the center of the restorative justice process. Offenders have to recognize their obligation to their victims in attempt to repair the harm their crimes have caused. The community also carries an obligation to aid the victim in recovering and the offender’s need for transitional support to prevent re-offending and recidivism....   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Restorative justice]

Better Essays
1356 words (3.9 pages)

Restorative Justice : The Restorative Theory Essay example

- In order for this model’s implementation to be successful, Torres first needs to accept guilt for the crime he committed and then admit sole responsibility for his own actions. This is one of two major perquisites for the restorative model to work. One method used to lay the groundwork for this acceptance of accountability is for the offender to meet face-to-face with those that he or she victimized. In this case, that would be the immediate family members of John Geer and the decease’s former best friend....   [tags: Crime, Criminal justice, Restorative justice]

Better Essays
982 words (2.8 pages)

Community Involvement And Restorative Justice Essay

- A community is made up of individuals who feel connected. Communities hold a sense of belonging and connection (Elizabeth Elliott, 2011, p.192). Therefore, communities play a significant role in criminal justice in particular restorative justice. Restorative justice recognizes the social aspect of human beings and focuses on citizen participation. This essay will explain the role of the community in restorative justice. Elizabeth Elliott (2011, p.199) saw community involvement as the opportunity to tell stories, relationship building and create accountability....   [tags: Crime, Criminal justice, Restorative justice]

Better Essays
899 words (2.6 pages)

Victims' Rights and Restorative Justice Essay

- Introduction Agreeing on a definition of restorative justice has proved difficult. One definition is a theory of justice that focuses mostly on repairing the harm caused by criminal behaviour. The reparation is done through a cooperative process that includes all the stakeholders. Restorative justice can also be explained as an approach of justice that aims to satisfy the needs of the victims and offenders, as well as the entire community. The most broadly accepted definition for restorative justice, however, is a process whereby all the parties that have a stake in a specific offence collectively resolve on how to deal with the aftermath....   [tags: Restorative Justice]

Better Essays
3099 words (8.9 pages)

Restorative Justice And The Justice Essay

- Defining justice can be very complicated, everyone has their own distinct way of defining what justice is and how it should be applied throughout society. Some people believe that justice needs to be swift and harsh, to ensure change. While others believe in restorative justice is in order. Many institutions (Criminal justice, Education, Workplace Religious) are deciding to move from a solely punishments based form of justice, into more restorative justice practices. All though restorative justice has been around for many years, it is often not utilized, but has many benefits for the victim, offender, and the community....   [tags: Criminology, Crime, Justice, Restorative justice]

Better Essays
807 words (2.3 pages)

Restorative Justice Practices And The Justice System Essay

- The criminal justice system is made up of several different aspects that help operate it as smoothly as possible. A relatively new and promising feature of the criminal justice is restorative justice. Restorative justice looks at rehabilitating offenders and reconciling them with their victims and the families. The practices found in restorative justice differ from the adversarial system; they include victim-offender mediation, circle sentencing and restitution to the victims. This paper will discuss how restorative justice practices work and the positive outcomes that follow a restorative justice framework....   [tags: Criminal justice, Crime, Restorative justice]

Better Essays
980 words (2.8 pages)

Restorative Justice By Howard Zehr Essay

- “Restorative justice is an approach to crime and other wrongdoings that focuses on repairing harm and encouraging responsibility and involvement of the parties impacted by the wrong.” This quote comes from a leading restorative justice scholar named Howard Zehr. The process of restorative justice necessitates a shift in responsibility for addressing crime. In a restorative justice process, the citizens who have been affected by a crime must take an active role in addressing that crime. Although law professionals may have secondary roles in facilitating the restorative justice process, it is the citizens who must take up the majority of the responsibility in healing the pains caused by crime...   [tags: Crime, Criminology, Restorative justice, Victim]

Better Essays
1095 words (3.1 pages)

Forgiveness And Restorative Justice Essay

- Forgiveness and restorative justice are healing tools for victims and offenders. The benefits of forgiveness can help heal a broken heart of a victim, secondary victim, or offender. Forgiveness and restorative justice relieves a victim of malice, rage, vengeance, revenge, bitterness and regret. It is very difficult to forgive someone for a crime, violation, or misdeed they have done to you or a loved one. Forgiveness is not mandatory in order to get restorative justice. Forgiveness does not excuse the offender from the harm they have done but benefits the people involved to move on with their lives....   [tags: Restorative justice, J. M. Coetzee]

Better Essays
1516 words (4.3 pages)

Essay on Australia 's Restorative Justice System

- When you think of the United States criminal justice system, two words come to mind: retribution and punitive. However on the other side of the spectrum is Australia. Australia which is very well known for its restorative criminal justice program has become the top country in regards to what a lot of people think the United States criminal justice system should become more like. Especially in regards to how juvenile offenders are treated in both countries. By looking at Australia’s restorative justice program in regards to juvenile offenders, maybe there can be a balance found between the United States punitive criminal justice system and Australia’s restorative justice program when looking...   [tags: Crime, Criminal justice, Restorative justice]

Better Essays
1527 words (4.4 pages)

Restorative Justice Handbook Essay

- Introduction Just Schools: a whole school approach to Restorative Justice is a practical handbook that presents a whole school approach to repairing harm using a variety of means including peer mediation, circles, and restorative conferencing. The thesis of this book is that the key to successful teaching and learning is: working in an atmosphere where people care about each other, have good relationships, mutual respect, and a sense of belonging. The main argument is that when harmful behavior or conflict occurs the emphasis should be on repairing the damage caused to the relationship and on finding mutually acceptable ways forward....   [tags: Peer Mediation, Restorative Conferencing]

Better Essays
1295 words (3.7 pages)