A Comparison Of Dystopia In The Movie 'The Truman Show' Essay

A Comparison Of Dystopia In The Movie 'The Truman Show' Essay

Length: 1272 words (3.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

How does Weir/Ross demonstrate that a world controlled by the media can only be dystopian in nature.
Utopia, as defined by Thomas Moore, is “a community or society possessing highly desirable or perfect qualities”. Peter Weir’s satirical science fiction film, ‘The Truman Show’ focuses on a man, Truman Burbank, whose life is part of a massive television set disguised as a town called Seahaven – orchestrated by executive producer, Christof. His every move is captured by hidden cameras and broadcasted live. However, Truman is unknown to all this unlike in Gary Ross’ adventure movie, ‘The Hunger Games’. In what was once North America, the Capitol of Panem maintains its hold on its 12 districts by forcing a boy and a girl from each district to compete in a nationally televised event called the Hunger Games. The youths must fight to the death until only one winner remains. Both films explore the concept of dystopia in a media controlled society and the true power which hope possesses. Moreover, both texts highlight the way leaders use their positions to manipulate to their advantage. However, both texts exemplify the oppression the characters are confronted with and endorse the way certain individuals challenge unjust authority figures.

Both texts demonstrate the influence that hope has on an oppressed society which accompanies destabilisation of superior powers. Hope in both narratives is expressed as the pinnacle of human nature and an intrinsic part of any society. However, although these traits are recognised by the leaders in both texts, both also understand that hope must be contained in order to ensure that an uprising does not occur. President Snow, in ‘The Hunger Games’, enforces the Hunger Games to instill terror in the cit...


... middle of paper ...


...believing that his family and friends undoubtedly loved him, only to come to the realisation that everything was instead all a fantasy. Christof’s treatment of Truman was a thirty-year prolonged cruelty and unjustly. Therefore, both Weir and Ross’ fictional worlds explore two different assortments of dystopia and oppression – one, sadistic and the other a lie but both equally cruel.

Peter Weir’s ‘The Truman Show’ and Gary Ross’ ‘The Hunger Games’ both illustrate the concept of a corrupt world controlled by a medial government. In both of Weir’s and Ross’s societies, the protagonists utilise emotions such as hope and fear to manipulate their subordinates into keeping in order. Consequently, this becomes an oppressed society due to the unjust treatments and exercise of power from those who are taking advantage and manipulating the power which their position receives.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Utopia And Dystopias In The Truman Show

- Utopias and dystopias are vastly explored in modern day. However, the thin line between them is rarely investigated. In a way, they are two sides of the same coin. One could argue that neither could exist without the other. Generally, the definitions of both are generic, subjective, and are always too easily corrupted to be realistic. Elements of this are present in the brilliant movie The Truman Show, in regular life, and are shown in Truman’s ultimately wise decision. In Christof’s eyes, he has created the perfect world for Truman....   [tags: Utopia, The Truman Show, Dystopia, Reality, Truth]

Better Essays
933 words (2.7 pages)

Dystopia In The MoviePleasantville Essay

- Pleasantville is a movie written and directed by Gary Ross that reveals the dystopian elements hidden within seemingly utopian worlds by portraying the contrast between modern society and the idyllic setting of suburban 1950s’ America. The film follows the adventure of twin teenagers David and Jennifer as they find themselves transported into the world of the 1950s’ television show “Pleasantville”, replacing the main characters Bud and Mary Sue. In various events throughout the movies, both characters spark a series of changes in the conservative Pleasantville society that result in the town gradually transforming from repressive black-and-white to liberating Technicolor....   [tags: Utopia, Dystopia, Pleasantville, Street, Gary Ross]

Better Essays
937 words (2.7 pages)

Analysis Of The Movie ' The Truman Show ' Essay

- The Truman Show engenders question on the authenticity of behavior and virtue in the face of pervasive voyeurism(which I will refer to in an exclusively non sexual manner). The Truman Show expostulates that an unaware participant in this perverted voyeurism, no matter the level of cognizant awareness, is still inauthentic because of the pervasive manipulation by Cristof and his cronies and the willing deception by Truman Show 's costars. These factors engender a contrived scenario that forces Truman to act in an expected manner—rather than natural--much like the intrusive Mr....   [tags: Reality television, The Truman Show]

Better Essays
2280 words (6.5 pages)

The Truman Show Idealism Essay

- In modern day, mankind vastly explores the ideas of utopias and dystopias. However, the thin line between them remains rarely investigated. In a way, they are two sides of the same coin. One could argue that neither could exist without the other. Generally, the definitions of both are generic, subjective, and are always too easily corrupted to be realistic. Elements of this concept overflowing with idealism are present in the brilliant movie The Truman Show, in regular life, and shown in Truman’s ultimately wise decision....   [tags: The Truman Show, Utopia, Dystopia, Reality, Truth]

Better Essays
958 words (2.7 pages)

Reality and the Movie "The Truman Show" Essay

- The reality of the world and the truth of it is questioned everyday, especially when something goes wrong. This is shown in the Truman show, when Truman finally starts to question the reality of the world and the truth of the people that surrounds him. So we need to ask to following questions to understand what the film is essentially about. Firstly, do we agree with the statement- We accept the reality of the world which we are presented. Secondly, what messages is the director trying to give us about modern society....   [tags: Truman Show, reality, ]

Better Essays
1041 words (3 pages)

The Dystopia Of A Dystopia Essay

- A dystopia is a place that is undesirable and frightening to live in. The word dystopia literally translates to “bad place”. In a dystopia, people have a lack of personal freedoms. They are oppressed by their governments and are discriminated against based on sex, age or IQ. There are places in the world that can be considered more dystopian than others but no place can ever be considered truly dystopian; or utopian for that matter. Although our world is neither completely a dystopia nor completely a utopia, it does contain aspects that would be considered dystopian in nature such as the monitoring of citizens, war, and the division of citizens by class or ability which facilitate the instit...   [tags: Dystopia, Nineteen Eighty-Four, Donald Trump, War]

Better Essays
1527 words (4.4 pages)

A Comparison of Othello and the Movie O Essay

- A Comparison of Othello and the Movie O When Shakespeare composed the tragedy Othello televisions were not. Along with no televisions, life in the late 1500s had many different qualities than it does today. This time period had no war on drugs and no high school shootings. Peer pressure was not an issue. The audiences of Othello in the 1500s did not face the circumstances that we, American high school students, face today. With these significant differences in daily life, come the attempts of movie creators to help prevent our modern day tragedies....   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Better Essays
1551 words (4.4 pages)

Comparison of the Book and Movie Version of A Clockwork Orange Essay

- A Comparison of the Book and Firm Version of A Clockwork Orange   In the story of his teenage years, starting at fifteen.  He begins his tale as the leader of a small gang that spends its evenings pillaging and wreaking havoc on the town until the gang mutinies and "Your Humble Narrator," as Alex refers to himself, is caught by the police.  From there, Alex travels to State Jail 84F to serve 14 years, but receives an offer from "the Government" which entails undergoing experimental treatment in return for early release.  He seizes what seems to him an opportunity, but is horrified by the "cure" he endures.  The new "good" Alex that is released unto the world is depressed, frus...   [tags: Movie Film comparison compare contrast]

Free Essays
1236 words (3.5 pages)

Americ A Dystopia? Essays

- America: A Dystopia in the Making The United States of America used to be one of the most ideal places in the world. Many people in the past saw it as a great utopia; a place of perfection, especially in laws, government, and social conditions. This so-called utopia, however, is slowly turning the tides; making its way towards a dehumanizing, overcrowded, terrorized hell; a dystopia. One of the main reasons that the United States is no longer a utopia is because of the poverty that is seen everyday....   [tags: United States, Obesity, Dystopia, Nutrition]

Better Essays
940 words (2.7 pages)

Utopia And Dystopia Essay

- “Utopian" describes a society that's conceived to be perfect. However, “Idiocracy” and “WALL-E” portray the exact opposite reality, a dystopian society that is as dehumanizing and as unpleasant as possible. This type of society is often characterized by environmental problems or other characteristics associated with a cataclysmic decline in the future society. In both movies, we see different interpretations of Earth’s future caused by numerous factors (corporatism, technology, consumerism), but mostly by environmental problems....   [tags: Pixar, Dystopia, Environmental movement, Pollution]

Better Essays
905 words (2.6 pages)