A Case for the Court of Conscience or Justice? Essay

A Case for the Court of Conscience or Justice? Essay

Length: 640 words (1.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

“There is a higher court than courts of justice and that is the court of conscience. It supersedes all other courts.’’(Mahatma Gandhi) Having an inner voice is what allows people to decide what is morally right or wrong, not following it can make someone feel guilty. When facing righteousness, an individual must realize what he has done can only truly be judged by his moral sense. In The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, a novella by Robert Stevenson, and in A Separate Peace, a novel by John Knowles, one character from each novel acts unjustly and does not listen to their conscience. Dr. Jekyll and Gene both realize that what they are doing is considered wrong and yet they still do it. Both of them feel very guilty for it, but neither really try to completely make up for their wrongdoing. They are truly committing an injustice because they understand they are being dishonorable and yet still commit the crime.
In fact, Dr. Jekyll at first appearance seems to be a good person, he gives to charity, he is a doctor and he seems to be very religious, but he only does this because of the guilt he feels. The truth is that he longs to be evil and to do this he makes himself a different persona, named Mr. Hyde. As Mr. Hyde, he commits crimes such murdering Sir Danvers Carew and trampling a young girl. Stevenson’s tone throughout the novel is shocking and even melodramatic at parts, but it serves to show the reader a sense of disapproval at what is occurring. It is very hard to understand how such a nice person could do such bad things, but it makes the most sense in the end. His conscience makes him feel so bad that he wants to try to make up for his mistakes, but in the end he is still too tempted by the bad to abandon his altern...

... middle of paper ...

...is weakness to the evil because he can’t stop his acts, unless he goes that as far as to commit suicide. Gene also feels guilt, when Phineas dies he believes that he has also died with him and will never be the same again. Unfortunately neither one completely and whole heartedly repents or changes their actions allowing the reader to decide whether they ever are really worthy of receiving any forgiveness.
In summary both Jekyll and Gene are in acknowledgment of their injustices and yet each still commit their crime making them guilty. In the world today a child cannot be put in prison for a crime. The reason for this is, it cannot be proved that they truly understand what they had done was wrong. In each book although, it can be said that each character understood the morality of what they were doing. So to this fact they are both guilty in the court of justice.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Conscience of the Court, by Zora Neale Hurston Essay

- “The Conscience of the Court” written by Zora Neale Hurston explores the life of a courtroom in the late nineteenth century. Laura Lee Kimble is a strong, loyal, and humble African American woman. Laura has a close connection with Mrs. Clairborne, her close friend and employer, and is loyal to their friendship. This friendship and loyalty is so strong that Laura refused to leave Mrs. Clairborne three times even when her husband asked if they could live somewhere with more money. Clement Beasley, the plaintiff, claims that Mrs....   [tags: Research Paper]

Better Essays
2032 words (5.8 pages)

The Death Penalty Is A Controversy Plaguing The Conscience Of Law And American Public Sentiment

- The death penalty or ‘capital punishment’ is a controversy plaguing the conscience of law and American public sentiment in the decades since Furman v. Georgia (1972) which dealt with the various biases and overall breadth of the death penalty in the United States. Yet are its implications— rather, the core of its general justification—still relevant today where greater emphasis is placed on individual rights. The most succinct and credible way of invalidating the death penalty is by turning to the US Constitution itself, with particular emphasis on the Eighth Amendment and its ‘Cruel and Unusual Punishment’ clause....   [tags: Supreme Court of the United States]

Better Essays
1274 words (3.6 pages)

The Purpose of Restorative Justice Methods Essay

- The Purpose of Restorative Justice Methods Introduction High rates of recidivism demonstrate that the judicial system has been unsuccessful in determining criminal activity. Alternatives to incarceration known as restorative justice has existed for centuries, yet has only been recently implicated into the Canadian judicial system. The practices of restorative justice have been proven very successful for minor offences among adults and youth in bringing together the offenders, victims, and the community....   [tags: Law, criminal justice system, criminology]

Better Essays
2057 words (5.9 pages)

A Historical Journey through the American Conscience: The Public and its Courts

- America has long taken pride in being a nation of idealism and of freedom. Still, while these values have remained constant, other areas of the American mindset have evolved repeatedly over the brief course of America’s history. Nothing could illustrate this change more than the complex, developing, relationship between American citizens and their criminal justice system. Each era of American history shows the mindset of its time through the courts. From the extreme Puritans, and their deeply spiritual, irrational cases, to the politically charged events of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, and forward into the hodgepodge of contemporary justice, one can read the American conscience b...   [tags: Criminal Justice]

Better Essays
1554 words (4.4 pages)

Criminal Justice: Racial Disparity and Discrimination and O.J. Simpson Essay

- Criminal law is based on the principle of actus non facit reum nisi mens sit rea. The principle is to the extent that a man is not guilty of his acts, actus in the absence of a guilty conscience, mens rea (Gardner, 2009). To this end, criminal law justice provides that the person alleging the commission of a crime must proof beyond reasonable doubt that the accused person(s) possessed mens rea, if the court is to hold a criminal liability against the accused. In the case of People of the State of California v....   [tags: criminal law, O.J. Simpson Trial, justice system]

Better Essays
763 words (2.2 pages)

Conflict And The Symbol Of The Case Of Kill A Mockingbird By Harper Lee Essay

- The dictionary definition of the word “justice” expounds upon righteousness; however, the consequences given to some is anything but right. Harper Lee, author of To Kill a Mockingbird, stresses upon the corruptness of society’s version of impartiality. Only a handful of the characters in her story truly understand the means of which justice should be dealt and who in fact deserves it. In her novel, Lee accentuates the use of conflict and the symbol of the mockingbird to establish the notion that justice is as corrupt as those who deal it....   [tags: To Kill a Mockingbird, Jury, Court, Law]

Better Essays
1021 words (2.9 pages)

Bleak House: Justice Served Essay

- Bleak House: Justice Served Bleak House written by Charles Dickens is a representation of the corruption of England’s court system as the author clearly sets out to criticize the cornerstones of the nation. Through his novel, Dickens redeems the idea of justice by bringing Inspector Bucket into the plotline as a spokesman for the people seeking the truth. Dickens presents the detective/police as the symbol of true justice who serves the law with good intentions for the people. The contrast of these two types of justice systems is that Inspector Bucket serves the law with the true interest of people while the lawyers of the Court do it for their own gain and personal interests....   [tags: Charles Dickens, story/literary analysis]

Better Essays
1487 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Chief Justice Taney and Slavery

- The Art of Avoidance; Chief Justice Taney and the Question of Slavery “Their present decision is equivalent to a repeal of law and the making of law. This is not adjudication, it is mere usurpation. It is the substitution of mere arbitrary will in the place of the solemn and responsible functions of an impartial judicature.”[1] The 1857 Dred Scott decision proved that Chief Justice Roger Taney’s sadistic racism could be eclipsed only by his unbounded arrogance. Using outright lies regarding the intentions of the Framers, he temporarily sacrificed the entire African race, and directed the Supreme Court to move in and illegitimate and supercede the powers vested...   [tags: History Slavery African American Essays]

Better Essays
1736 words (5 pages)

criminal justice Essay examples

- Tushnet's A Court Divided By R. Anastasia Tremaine - February, 2005 Tushnet's A Court Divided Tushnet (2005) takes an insightful look into the current Supreme Court and what it means for the future in his work entitled A Court Divided. Much has been discussed about the Court, particularly since the 2000 election ended up being referred to the judicial branch of government. Constitutional law has always been fascinating subject, as it broaches the areas of guaranteed legal protections....   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
1334 words (3.8 pages)

Essay about Criminal Justice System

- I do feel that they will be effecitve and in the next few pages I will explain why I feel this way and why I have taken this stand. First of all I read through the whole charter and as boring as it was I made it through unscaved. Just like anything in order to have something you need a purpose. A reason for doing something. The reason why this charter was brought forward was because that they realized that during that century millions of children, mean and women have been victims of unimaginable atrocities that deeply shock the conscience of humanity....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
730 words (2.1 pages)