The Roles of Sherlock Holmes in The Speckled Band and The Cardboard Box

  • Length: 917 words (2.6 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

Examining the roles of Sherlock Holmes in two short stories. ‘The
Speckled Band’ and ‘The Cardboard Box.’

I am going to compare both ‘The Speckled Band’ and ‘ The Cardboard
Box’ which are Sherlock Holmes stories written by Arthur Conan Doyle.

‘A Study in Scarlet’ was Arthur Conan Doyle’s first novel, introducing
both characters Holmes and Watson and including how they met. ‘A study
in Scarlet’ was written in three weeks in 1886 and published in 1887.
A.C. Doyle based Sherlock Holmes on Dr Joseph Bell, a surgeon and
teacher he had studied with while attending Edinburgh University. Sir
Henry Littlejohn, who taught forensic medicine to Doyle also made a
large impression and contributed to the development of Holmes’s
character. Dr John Watson a fellow Southsea doctor who served time in
Manchuria received the honour of having Holmes’s partner named after
him. The Strand Newspaper newly founded in 1890 published a series of
short stories called ‘The adventures of Sherlock Holmes.’ From that
point on the public could not get enough of Holmes and his always
reliable, confident, John H Watson, a retired military doctor.
Sherlock Holmes was one of the first fictional detectives ever
created. By 1893 Doyle had tired of Holmes in ‘The Final Problem.’ In
the story Holmes meets Moriarty at the fall of the Reichenbach in
Switzerland and disappears. However public demand brought the return
of Holmes with stories appearing until 1927. A C Doyle gave Sherlock
Holmes 221B Baker Street as his address in the stories which actually
is a real address and is still visited by tourists today.

Sherlock Holmes has a unique way of solving the crimes. He seems to
spot things that others miss “Brown paper with a distinct smell of
coffee.” No one apart from Holmes has yet noticed this, not even
Watson. Holmes has excellent observation skills “You have been cruelly
used said Holmes. The lady coloured deeply and covered her injured
wrist.” Holmes is always looking for clues to unravel the mysteries.
“… A portrait group of three ladies upon the mantelpiece. …Others are
so exceedingly like you that there could be no doubt of the
relationship” here Holmes had observed that the people in the portrait
could be family members making this Miss Cushing the wrong Cushing
family member.

In these short stories about Sherlock Holmes, Arthur Conan Doyle tries
to get across the fact that Holmes is better at solving hard mystery
crimes. Holmes came to hear about the cases many ways one of which is
through the Police. When the Police get a case they cannot solve they
go to Holmes for help. “..Our friend Lestrade.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"The Roles of Sherlock Holmes in The Speckled Band and The Cardboard Box." 25 May 2018
Title Length Color Rating  
Comparing Villains and Victims from The Speckled Band, Twisted Lip and The Cardboard Box - Comparing Villains and Victims from The Speckled Band, Twisted Lip and The Cardboard Box The three villains which I am going to compare / contrast are Dr Roylott from The Speckled Band, Mr Neville St Claire from The Man With The Twisted Lip and Sarah Cushing from The Cardboard Box. The three victims I am going to compare / contrast are Helen Stoner from The Speckled Band, Mrs St Claire from The Man With The Twisted Lip and Susan Cushing from The Cardboard box. Dr Roylott is a stereotype villain....   [tags: Speckled Twisted Cardboard Essays] 1805 words
(5.2 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Victims and Villains in The Speckled Band, The Cardboard Box, and The Red Headed League - Having read a range of detective stories by Conan Doyle, compare the presentations of victims and villains in The Speckled Band and two other stories. In this essay, I am going to look at how Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, has written the Sherlock Holmes stories, looking at the victims, villains, Holmes and his dear friend Watson. The Sherlock Holmes, stories are written in the detective genre, all of the stories that I have looked at to compile this essay, have a crime, victims, and villains. It also shows this as there is always a crime that Sherlock Holmes solves, by his intelligence....   [tags: English Literature] 2435 words
(7 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Comparing Villains in The Speckled Band, The Final Problem, and The Cardboard Box - Comparing Villains in The Speckled Band, The Final Problem, and The Cardboard Box I have chosen to look at three villains from three different stories. These are Dr Roylott from ‘The Speckled Band’, Professor Moriarty from ‘The Final Problem’ and Jim Browner from ‘The Cardboard Box’. Each of these villains has his own distinctive qualities. One is a victim but also a villain, one is just plain horrible, and one is the most cunning head of crime in the world. They are all diverse in the way they go about their ‘dirty work’ and they all have completely different motives....   [tags: Papers] 898 words
(2.6 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
The Speckled Band by Sherlock Holmes Essay - The Speckled Band by Sherlock Holmes Detective stories first became popular in the Victorian era following the emergence of organized police forces in the 1830's. Fascination with the criminal heros accompanied a corresponding interest in the methodical uncovering of crime. Public hangings were frequent and Victorian people feared crime greatly. This meant that when the detective stories came about they felt the fictional character that cracked every case became the perfect detective i.e....   [tags: Papers] 1565 words
(4.5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay about Sherlock Holmes's The Speckled Band - Sherlock Holmes's The Speckled Band Sir Arthur Conan Doyle wrote many fictional detective stories. His first story "A Study in Scarlett" was published in 1887. Since then he has written many more. The famous detective in all his stories is Sherlock Holmes who also has an associate called Dr Watson. Sherlock Holmes became a household name usually pictured with a hat and magnifying glass. "The Speckled Band" was one of his stories which was published in 1892 and is still being enjoyed by many more than 100 years later....   [tags: Papers] 679 words
(1.9 pages)
Good Essays [preview]
The Role of Sherlock Holmes in The Speckled Band Essay - Examine the role of Sherlock Holmes as a Detective in the Story Of The Speckled Band The creator of the very legendry stories of Sherlock Holmes was Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. Sir Arthur. As a child he was sent to a harsh, strict and then applied to study medicine. After qualifying, he travelled as a ships doctor, however he had very little success. Without his career, Conan Doyle had much spare time and decided to write stories as a pass time. These stories he wrote were detective stories with Sherlock Holmes as the main character....   [tags: English Literature] 884 words
(2.5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes Essay - The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes As my first point I would like to comment on the use of Watson as a narrator. I think that the writer does this to show how clever Sherlock Holmes is compared to an ordinary person. We see this as Watson often gets confused and doesn't know what's going on, where as Holmes always seems to be in control. An example of this is in the story 'The Blue Carbuncle', before the mystery has even come to light, Sherlock Holmes deduces certain things from a battered hat....   [tags: Sherlock Holmes Essay] 655 words
(1.9 pages)
Good Essays [preview]
Sherlock Holmes & The Speckled Band / Lamb To The Slaughter Essay example - Sherlock Holmes & The Speckled Band / Lamb To The Slaughter "Lamb to the slaughter", by Roald Dahl, and "The Speckled Band" by Arthur Conan Doyle share many features, despite the difference in eras in which they were written. Each story has its own distinctive style when creating both tension and an atmosphere of suspense. "The Speckled Band" has a sense of urgency about it, yet manages to build up suspense until the climax of the story. "I have reasons to know....which tend to make the matter even more terrible than the truth." This quote, found in the first paragraph, immediately begins creating an atmosphere for the story, and intriguing the reader as to what the narrator (Dr....   [tags: English Literature] 916 words
(2.6 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
The Speckled Band and the Man with the Twisted Lip Essay - The Speckled Band and the Man with the Twisted Lip In the beginning of the story, The Speckled Band, a young woman arrived at Sherlock Holmes house at quarter past seven in the morning, with a very urgent matter that she needed to talk to him about. The matter being that the young woman, Miss Helen Stoner, is fearful for her life, because her sister, Miss Julia Stoner died in the usual circumstances such as she died two weeks before her wedding. She died in her room, and before she died, she would regularly hear low whistling and low metallic clanging noises at around three in the morning....   [tags: Speckled Band Twisted Lip Compare Essays] 3803 words
(10.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Holmes and Watson in the Detective Genre - Holmes and Watson in the Detective Genre The detective performs a key role in the story and provides hope to the reader, especially in the time when Sherlock Holmes was written. Victorian life was hard, law-less and dangerous and especially in London. In every story Conan Doyle A vital component to the detective genre is the sleuth himself who in these stories is portrayed as a convincing, sharp, and witty character; a gentleman with intelligence, more so than the reader and side kick, well rounded and good natured....   [tags: Sherlock Holmes Dr. Watson Detectives Essays] 4049 words
(11.6 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]

I had a note from him
this morning.” Lestrade is a Police Inspector with Scotland Yard and
needs help from Holmes with this case. Holmes only like’s cases which
challenge his intellect “this case is very much in your line” this is
contained in the note sent by Lestrade. Sometimes the cases come to
Sherlock Holmes by past clients “it seems that a young lady has
arrived in a considerable state of excitement.” Here the person
involved has come straight to Holmes so he can solve the mystery

The relationship between Holmes and Watson is strange. To begin with
the readers are under the impression that it is a partnership but this
quickly changed by a few hints “insists upon seeing me.” The person
the client wishes to see is Holmes and not both Holmes and Watson
together. The relationship is also unbalanced as you always hear
Watson go on about our great Holmes is “I had no keener pleasure than
in following Holmes in his professional investigations, and in
admiring the rapid deduction, as swift as intuition.” Here Watson even
said to himself “following Holmes” and that he admires Holmes as well.
Again here “remarkable mental qualities of my friend Sherlock Holmes”
Watson is relaying how much he looks up to Holmes.

Another relationship Sherlock Holmes has is one with the police. This
is also an unfair relationship as Arthur Conan Doyle tried to get
across that Holmes is better than the police “fancy his having the
insolence to confound me with the official detective force!” here
Holmes is a bit concerned with people associating him with the normal
police force and unworthy crimes. “I should prefer that you would not
mention my name at all in connection with the case, as I choose to be
associated only with those crimes which present some difficulty in
their solution.” Here Holmes feels that this case was easy and he
would rather people did not know he solved such a case and humiliate
the police force.

What made Sherlock Holmes so successful was the fact that he did not
work with the police force and the way the police and detectives
actually came to Holmes for help also his characteristics that made
Holmes attractive to the readers were his integrity, sensibility,
rational decisiveness, lack of emotionalism and intellectual
superiority which were measured and reported by Watson. The
relationship between Holmes and Watson are similar to detectives
today. Take Inspector Morse and the relationship he has with Lewis, it
is obvious that Morse is in charge and Lewis is his side kick in a
similar way to Watson. I think that Sherlock Holmes has a unique way
of solving mystery crimes but if the stories were to be brought out
today the crimes would need to be more intense and not so easy to

Return to