Divorce and children
Length: 819 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
West Hills Community College
Parent and child relationship before, during, and after divorce
I, have done a reading on a particular topic regarding parent-children relationships that can and do affect divorce. It was a magazine article from the family journal (Amato, Paul R., Booth, Alan). In its context it explained many different aspects and angles of the relationships. Now myself being of the knowledge of research, I have found this article to be relatively well put together: only in some ways. I have also noticed it to be very sporadic in other directions.
In the first way I feel that it brings up phenomenal points in the regards to the length of the study. I feel that a well put together research takes much time and effort of collecting information. The ten year span they have really shows the heart and soul put into everything.
The second way is the diversity of people from which they asked to participate in the study. In my opinion, many people have many different life styles. When you receive the answers back and notice a resemblance in most of them, then you have a strong leg to stand on.
The third way is the way the researchers remained consistent in there findings. There wasn’t an abundance of ups and downs. This could have been just a coincidence, but for the average person reading they are much stronger to believe the findings.
Now onto the negative side of how I feel about this research. The first finding is the way they proclaimed there to be problems in the relationships of the parent-children before divorce. I don’t feel that you can compare the relationship problems in that time period. They suggest that because of the strained relationships at this point, around ten years before the divorce, is the reason why the divorce happened. I completely disagree with this. There are two many variables in a parents marital relationships to start then blaming the children. Now I know that the children can create some what of a hardship at times, but it is not the cause of divorce. Marital relationships carry many hardships and burdens at times. They have financial problems, work issues, and outside interferences. Children may be the case for a very few individuals, but not the majority or the end result for divorce.
The second pessimistic side is the average age of the children, which they chose to use: also they didn’t bare any information on how many children were in each house hold.
They did the research on families that have an average ten year old. Stress seems to be in families with smaller children and houses that have more then two children. This part of the study just doesn’t hold together. They are choosing to blame the children for the problems in the relationships, but not backing up all the different parameters. The adults are the more cognitive ones in the relationships and are going to use more maturity than the child will.
The last reason for not particularly agreeing with this research is the questions they used on the questionnaire. When personal questions are asked then the truth is not always going to come out. For instance, say a mother and father are arguing and you ask them shortly after the argument if they love one another, they of course are going to say that they dislike one another. Then from the other party asking the question they will assume that they don’t get along and hate each other, assumptions then start to happen. One of the questions that they asked was if you want to be away from your children and if you are not happy living with them. Any parent, in their right mind, would agree that at one time or another they would like to be separated from the children: just not forever. This question was irrelevant to there study. Another question was if you have problems with your children. All parents have problems with there children. I am not sure how this has to do with why this would cause a divorce. A strained parent-child relationship will not be the main factor.
In conclusion, I would like to say that the researchers did indeed come up with good factors for there study, but all in all I just don’t feel that it held up well enough. If they were to put in more perspectives, then it would be more put together. They just came across as confirmatory bias: Discussing why they felt the parent-children relationships were damaged. They are so many variables in a marriage that they didn’t even touch on. If I were the chief in charge I would have told them to go back to the drawing board.
Amato, P R.,& Booth, A. (1996). Journal of Marriage and the
Family, Vol.58 Issue 2, p356,10p.