Scientific Advance: Friend or Foe?

  • :: 2 Works Cited
  • Length: 1103 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

Scientific Advance: Friend or Foe?

Scientists and non-scientists see the advances of technology in different ways. Scientists, like J. Michael Bishop, look at the possibilities technology offers while non-scientists, like Jeremy Rifkin and Mary Shelley, look at the potential chaos that could be caused by it.

J. Michael Bishop is a professor of microbiology at the University of California, San Francisco. He is also winner of the Nobel Prize. He wrote, "Enemies of Promise" because he wanted to dispel the misconceptions that many people have about science, since he feels that these could have serious consequences for all Americans.

Jeremy Rifkin is a well-known social activist who organized the 1968 March on the Pentagon and brought public attention to alleged U.S. war crimes in Vietnam. He is president of the nonprofit Foundation on Economic Trends. He is both criticized and admired for his condemnation on Biotechnology.

Mary Shelley was the daughter of 2 influential people and became an influential writer herself in the early 1800s. Mary Shelley created a monstrous, powerful myth, which she used to warn ambitious scientists of the potential dangers contained in their creations. Her creation, Frankenstein, will forever be known as the monster that was created by Victor Frankenstein. The monster, a creature without a name of its own, that took the identity of its maker.

Bishop argues that "Resistance to science is born out of fear." He blames ignorance of breeding this fear, and he blames ignorance of being, "our deepest malady" (241). Rifkin and Shelley on the other hand, accuse science of having the potential to evolve into something grotesque, monstrous and frightening. Bishop would say that this fear is born of ignorance while Rifkin and Shelley would argue it to stem from the potentiality of catastrophe, from the inability of man to predict the adaptability of nature, from the inability of man to anticipate the benefits that are likely to result from such experiments, and from the danger of acquiring knowledge and becoming greater than "his" (man's) nature will allow (321).

J Michael Bishop in "Enemies of Promise" argues that we live in an age of scientific triumph in which science is mistrusted and under attack. He claims that some of the opposition to science comes from familiar sources. Some of these stem from religious fanatics who constantly push for creationism education in the public arena. These groups have a theological foundation to their opposition to the advances of science.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Scientific Advance: Friend or Foe?." 25 May 2018
Title Length Color Rating  
Essay on Phorid Flies: Friend or Foe Against the Fire Ants - Since the beginning of human existence this race has been using science in order to protect and advance their society. However as time has progressed the use of this modification has created both positive and negative repercussions. In 1999, the community of Denton, Texas brought in an un-indigenous species to eradicate their fire ant problem. While bringing in this species, the phorid fly, did immediately benefit the community, it will also have long lasting effects on the ecosystem in Denton. In order to weigh both the risk and reward of the phorid fly, it is important to examine all sides of the arguments for and against them....   [tags: biological solutions to pest problems]
:: 6 Works Cited
1142 words
(3.3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Science: Friend or Foe? Essays - Science: Friend or Foe. Science, a field of study featuring a relentless stream of change and advancements, is widely viewed as both the scourge and savior of the modern world. It is true that science offers solutions to many problems, suggesting greater convenience, technological improvement, and longer, healthier lives. Still, science is far from perfect, a point that many critics are eager to vocalize. Science has been blamed for invoking fear, reaching inadequate results, and supporting the most immoral of studies....   [tags: Argumentative Persuasive Scientific Essays]
:: 2 Works Cited
2048 words
(5.9 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Metafiction and JM Coetzee's Foe Essay - Metafiction and JM Coetzee's Foe   Is writing not a fine thing, Friday. Are you not filled with joy to know that you will live forever, after a manner. (Susan Barton, Foe, 58) Of the many literary conventions used to describe JM Coetzee's Foe, one of the more commonly written about is metafiction. Since about 1970, the term metafiction has been used widely to discuss works of post-modern fiction and has been the source of heated debate on whether its employ marks the death or the rebirth of the novel....   [tags: Foe]
:: 3 Works Cited
607 words
(1.7 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Essay on Wicca In The Military: Friend Or Foe? - Wicca in the Military: Friend or Foe. Does the word “Wicca” offend you. If you are like most people in the United States, then it does. Why does such a small word invoke such feelings of fear, hatred, and loathing. Ignorance is the reason. Many people do not know what Wicca is nor do they know about the people who follow it. Since there is such a negative connotation of Wicca in everyday society, would it be safe to say that Wiccans in the military are judged just as harshly. Is a Wiccan not as worthy of religious provisions as say, a Christian....   [tags: Religion Religious Wicca] 1308 words
(3.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on English: A Friend or Foe? - Today English is the language of international law, international politics, business and diplomacy. Day by day more minor languages disappear, and English becomes more commonly used and global. Scholars argue about how globalization of English and bilingualism around the world would affect other languages and cultures. Most of my friends think that bilingualism and globalization of English will improve the lives of people around the world; however, the situation will only encourage competition and will lead to a survival of the fittest situation....   [tags: Personal Essays] 665 words
(1.9 pages)
Good Essays [preview]
Technology: Friend or Foe? Essay - Technology: Friend or Foe. There are many differing opinions on the advancement of technology but there are really two main sides to the issue. One side is enthusiastic and ready for new progress and change, while the other side can see the value of technology but is more cautious and wary of the changes technology brings to society as a whole. These sides are simplified but useful for looking at the extreme ends of the issues in order to see the balance between the two. What is technology and why the fuss....   [tags: Argumentative Technology Essays Papers]
:: 5 Works Cited
2237 words
(6.4 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
A Man For All Seasons - Friend or Foe Essay - Friend or Foe In the book, A Man For All Seasons by Robert Bolt there are a few people that can’t be trusted by Sir Thomas More, the main character in the book. Richard Rich is definitely one of those men who can’t be trusted and along with Thomas Cromwell the two destroy More’s life slowly but surely and to the point of death. In the end of the book More is executed for high treason and his family goes from being very well off to having to start over. So this book shows that through deceitfulness of two, one can fall....   [tags: A Man For All Seasons by Robert Bolt]
:: 1 Works Cited
887 words
(2.5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
North Korea: Nuclear Friend or Foe? Essay example - North Korea: Nuclear Friend or Foe. Introduction It is 2025. After decades of bickering and intense fighting, India and Pakistan finally break out into general war. Millions are killed in the nuclear exchange. Other countries are drawn into the fray, ultimately widening the landscape of war. The death toll reaches a billion lives. In essence, you are witnessing a nuclear holocaust. Fortunately, this is a completely fictitious event; something one would think was straight out of a movie. The scary part is that as more and more countries begin to acquire nuclear weapons, further nuclear research, and pursue other nuclear-related projects, this can be very real....   [tags: Nuclear proliferation] 2257 words
(6.4 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Instant Messaging: Friend or Foe of Student Writing? Essay - Instant Messaging: Friend or Foe of Student Writing. Introduction With the commercial advent of the Internet and cell phones in the late 1990’s, technologies such as instant messaging (IM) and text messaging (TM) have achieved increasing prevalence in our society. These types of messaging technologies are widely used among adolescents today. To cite just one personal example of this widespread usage, my friend’s daughter, who is now 11 and lives in Ireland, got a cell phone last year, and, according to my friend, “was the last person in her class to get one.” This is quite an amazing change, given that ten years ago, instant messaging and text messaging were in their infancy, and cell phone...   [tags: Essays Papers]
:: 1 Works Cited
2081 words
(5.9 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Date Rape: When Friend Turns Foe Essay - Date Rape: When Friend Turns Foe There are many sad stories of girls who have been violated by someone that they know. They almost all begin with a wonderful night and eventually get taken advantage of. The woman in the situation may feel as though she asked for it. The male may feel as though she didn't say no, so if I do this I am doing nothing wrong. It is horrifying how many times this has happened to a woman. Men take their strong, masculine image and use it to their advantage. They may try to use guilt, lies and/or aggressiveness to get a girl to have sex him....   [tags: social issues] 585 words
(1.7 pages)
Better Essays [preview]

Related Searches

The hard-core antagonists of science are the so-called "post-modernists", who accuse science of being a "socially constructed fiction" (238).

According to Bishop, "Fear is one of the great enemies of science" because "resistance to science is born out of fear." The greatest enemy of science is mass ignorance. According to Bishop, it is up to scientists to eliminate the ignorance so that fear can be eliminated in people. He also argues that this will have to be done because "The price of science seems large" but "to reject science is to deny the future" (242).

Jeremy Rifkin in "Biotech Century: Playing Ecological Roulette with Mother Nature's Designs" argues that Biotech trends are dangerous and might lead to the destruction of the "natural" way of life.

Rifkin criticizes most forms of genetic manipulation calling it irresponsible and a danger to the survival of the human species. Rifkin argues that most forms of genetically altered plant and animal organisms are a potential danger to the environment and could, as a result, alter the biosphere along with the ecosystems. This could happen as genetic pollution, in the form of health allergies and as depletion of gene pools.

Mary Shelley's "Frankenstein" is a tale of a man who tried to be God-like and create a being only to discover that his creation was grotesque and un-Godly. Victor Frankenstein, according to Mary Shelly, was consumed by the idea of creating a "being like himself" (231). He longed for the adoration that he imagined these beings would feel toward him. He worked at accomplishing his goal with great passion until he was successful, only to discover that the "wretch" that he had created was not human. Frankenstein calls it, "the demoniacal corpse to which I had so miserably given life" (235). His bitter disappointment might have stemmed from the knowledge of the sacrifices he had made to get to the point of creation, only to discover that the being had not merited such sacrifice.

Mary Shelley describes Victor's passion with such eloquence that we want him to succeed. We also feel disappointment at the time of creation since such creation was grotesque and monstrous. At a time in modern science when scientists are considering the possibility of cloning human beings, Shelley's story of failure is more powerful and meaningful that it was in 1816, when she invented the possibility of a mere man giving life to a human-like creature. Scientists today should consider Victor's disappointment and horror before attempting to play God.

Bishop argues that we live in an age of scientific triumph (237) while Rifkin and Shelley would contradict by arguing that "to ignore the warnings is to place the biosphere and civilization in harm's way" (253), because the change can be "so rapid," and "the overthrow so complete!" (235)

Bishop blames the opposition to science on misapprehension about what science can and cannot do, while Rifkin blames the Technology Revolution for the proliferation and spread of genetic pollution and the wholesale loss of genetic diversity (253). Shelley blames scientists whose ambitions exceed their, understanding, for the monstrous results of science.

Bishop accuses the religious zealots and the "postmodernists" (237) of labeling science truths as, 'socially constructed fictions,' and 'useful myths' (238). Rifkin accuses "human beings of remaking the Earth for as long as we had a history" (245). He blames scientists, corporations, and governments for manipulating the natural world at the genetic level. He warns that such alteration will bring about the end of the natural world, as we know it. He fears the power of nature to find a way to adapt. Shelley would argue that this adaptation could be dangerously demoniacal. Shelley accuses scientists of wanting to play God without regard to the un-Godly outcome.

Scientists and non-scientists will continue to see the advances of technology in different ways. We need to educate ourselves to logically evaluate technological advances without being biased by our fears. We also have to look at the potential chaos that could be caused by the misuse of technology and genetic manipulations.

Works Cited

The Presence of Others. ED. Andrea A. Lunsford. Boston: Bedford / St. Martin's, 2000. 235-321. Last revised: December 15, 2001

Return to