A Comparison of Social Trends of the 1950s and 1990s

  • Length: 1482 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

We Americans have a fondness of looking back to certain times with
bouts of nostalgia, clutching closely the burred images of better off
and more secure conditions. We seek to revive those past years, hoping
to cure all of our current societal ills. Why cannot we bring them
back? The economy was good, and the family was happy, we say. We see
1950s in the United States as the golden era for the American people,
and likewise, the late 1990s was considered as a prosperous time.
However, the former decade observed the height of the nuclear family
and low divorce rates, while the latter recorded higher rates of
marriage dissolution and nonmarital births, as well as low rates of
marriage. What was happening differently in these two decades? In
order to rationalize these trends in conditions and inequalities among
U.S. household and families, it is necessary to study the development
in economy and employment and occupational structure in the United
States. (It should be noted that the following discussion of these
social developments is primarily of the general, dominant, white,
middle-class American and does not address trends related to race or

Stephanie Coontz does just this in her book, The Way We Really Are:
Coming to Terms with America’s Changing Families. She addresses the
several trends that have been misguidedly converted into the
popularized images we hold of the 1950s. Indeed, begins Coontz in her
argument, the 1950s was a decade in which “greater optimism did
exist…even among many individuals and groups who were in terrible
circumstances” (Coontz, 1997: 35). The postwar economic boom was
finally the opportune moment for individuals to build a stable family
that previous decades of depression, war, and domestic conflicts had
restricted. We see that this decade began with a considerable drop in
divorce rates and rise in marriage rates, which is often assumed as
the result of changed attitudes and values.

However, this situation cannot be only just attributed to women’s

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"A Comparison of Social Trends of the 1950s and 1990s." 123HelpMe.com. 19 Jun 2018
Title Length Color Rating  
The Introduction of the Internet in the 1990s Essays - The introduction of the internet in the 1990s, comprising near-instant messaging solutions (email), instant messaging solutions (IM) and the World Wide Web, changed the nature of both commercial and social interactions. The invention of Web 2.0 (McAfee 2006) technology, which allows for two way method of communi-cation, interoperability and user generated contents (UGC), has enabled enterprises to create virtual communities and a collaborative environment to host web-based communities as a foundation for value creation....   [tags: www, instant messaging, social interactions] 701 words
(2 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
The 1950s Woman Essay example - It is hard to believe that women only 60 years ago were still viewed and inferior to males and had little to no rights to protect themselves. When men returned from World War II some men resulted to domestically violate as a way of punishing his wife for something she did and to affirm dominance that he previously lost. Assaults that were inflicted on to women during the 1950s were seen being a part of male aggression and something that is normal. Women who did report the crime were viewed as being the actually perpetrators and the assault was actually their fault because they were unable to defend themselves....   [tags: The 1950s Woman]
:: 30 Works Cited
1170 words
(3.3 pages)
Good Essays [preview]
Essay on Crimes and Social Deviances in the 1990s - Crimes and Social Deviances in the 1990s *No Works Cited In the nineties the world and society has been faced with many different crimes and social deviancies, most of which have been as a result of rebellion and a form of expression. Whether it is to force a change or to create something new deviance is at a strong high. At the dawn of a new millenium some of society feel the need to express themselves in proscriptive norms and "leave our mark" on the world. The words "deviance" and "crime" are two words often mistaken for each other....   [tags: Papers] 638 words
(1.8 pages)
Good Essays [preview]
Essay on Encapsulating the 1950s Teenager in The Catcher in the Rye - Encapsulating the 1950s Teenager in The Catcher in the Rye Critically acclaimed film director Tim Burton states: “One person’s craziness is another person’s reality.” Our lives are ruled by social hierarchy with the rich at the top and the poor at the bottom. To a rich person who has lived a comfortable life, their idea of craziness would be living on the streets, begging for food and money to stay alive. Yet this idea of craziness is indeed people’s realities although in the fifties, thanks to it being prosperous times, people’s lives were a bit better than living on the streets....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Social Analysis]
:: 4 Works Cited
1947 words
(5.6 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Racial Integration in College Football in the 1950s Essay - In the 1950s, America was viewed as one the strongest nations in the World. America established itself as a strong military super power and dominate country in World War II. The effects of World War II carried over in the 1950s, America saw a lot of economic growth, there was an increase in the amount of people who moved to the suburbs, and the baby boom which came about because of the millions of soldiers returning home from military services. Even though this seemed like a happy time, there was still a thick tension in America....   [tags: Social Reform, Civil Rights Movement]
:: 4 Works Cited
1360 words
(3.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Social Comparison theory Essay - People tend to compare themselves to others in present modern day. Comparison has no limits; they do not just compare their homes, their cars, their families, but also their intelligence. Sometimes questioning their own analogies and wondering why is it that they must compare and contrast. Truth is a large majority of humans cross-cultural all tend to compare each other. When comparing each other’s social intelligence and cognitive intelligence based on academic achievement professionals may find a distinction between social metric popularity a measure of acceptance and perceived popularity a measure of social dominance (Meijs, Cillessen, Scholte, Segers, & Spijkerman, 2010)....   [tags: Intelligence Rating, Social Problem Solving]
:: 9 Works Cited
2421 words
(6.9 pages)
Research Papers [preview]
HIV/AIDS: Medical Breakthroughs and Social Settings of the 1980s, the 1990s - The HIV/AIDS epidemic may be one of the most devastating illnesses in American history due to its incurability and severe effects both on a person’s physical and mental wellbeing. Unfortunately, HIV/AIDS may also be one of the most stigmatized diseases from the period between 1980 and the present day due to its tendency to infect already stigmatized populations, namely intravenous drug users and gay men. Initially, this stigmatization persuaded many researchers to avoid testing potential treatments, which may have impeded progress....   [tags: incurable illness, virus]
:: 1 Works Cited
1955 words
(5.6 pages)
Term Papers [preview]
Increase of Serial Killers and Murderers in the 1920s Through 1990s Essay - If you were to look closely at the population in The United States of America during the 1960s through 1990s, you would notice a significant rise and fall of the nation’s population. If you look even closer at those statistics you will notice the population of murderers, more importantly serial killers were at a prominent high. Serial killings were at an all time high during this quadruple decade period of time. In 1960 the number started to slowly inch from less than ten to forty. Even worse the number exploded to 120 in 1970....   [tags: population, statistics] 793 words
(2.3 pages)
Better Essays [preview]
Social Criticism in the Hollywood Melodramas of the Fifties Essay - Social Criticism in the Hollywood Melodramas of the Fifties In the early 1950s the films of Douglas Sirk led the way in defining the emerging genre of the Hollywood melodrama. "Melodrama" strictly means the combination of music (melos) and drama, but the term is used to refer to the "popular romances that depicted a virtuous individual (usually a woman) or couple (usually lovers) victimized by repressive and inequitable social circumstances" (Schatz 222). Sirk's films were commercially successful and boosted the careers of stars like Lauren Bacall, Jane Wyman, and Rock Hudson, who was in seven of Sirk's thirteen American films (Halliday 162-171)....   [tags: 1950s Film Movies]
:: 6 Works Cited
1764 words
(5 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Challenges Women Confronted in the 1990s Essay - Four important challenges confronted women in the 1990s: increasing practical literacy, gaining access to employment opportunities at all levels in the economy, promoting change in the perception of women’s roles and status, and gaining a public voice both within and outside political process. There have been various attempts at social and legal reform aimed at improving women’s lives during the twentieth century. Indeed there may be contradictions inherent in the gender agenda of some nationalist projects, yet more and more steps are being taken so women can participate actively in programs especially in the area of the physical sciences....   [tags: Feminism Feminist Equality Essays] 2218 words
(6.3 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]

Related Searches

desire to stay at home as a non-working, devoted housewife and
mother. Rather, asserts Coontz, this trend was a response to external
forces, and specifically, a result of societal attitudes and policies,
such as unfavorable employment policies toward “non-ideal”
workers—workers with outside obligations—, that presented the woman
with few options. Also, Coontz writes, “Up through the 1960s an
adolescent girl typically had more responsibilities at home…than she
does today. While such tasks may have prepared girls for adult roles
as wives and mothers, they also held girls back from further education
or preparation for future work outside the home” (Coontz, 1997: 17).
Society’s expectations of women outside the realm of domesticity
numbered few, and women were constrained within their household
duties, a factor to the high numbers of women entering the marriage

In addition, this decade is an example of what Coontz explains as men
and women having dramatically disparate “situated social power”
(Coontz, 1997: 23), or in other words, “unequal social and economic
options (Coontz, 1997: 20) and “unequal bargaining power and social
support systems for men and women” (Coontz, 1997: 21). This was the
situation of having “unequal access to economic resources, political
power, and social status, and these social differences limit how fair
or equal a personal relationship between two individuals from
different groups can really be” (Coontz, 1997: 18). Thus, for unhappy
marriages, divorce was not a practical solution for the woman because
of her few options outside marriage. Women could not apply for loans
or credits or in the own names, for instance, and therefore
prohibiting full financial independence. Coontz sums up this trend in
the following passage:

“A lack of options outside marriage led some women to remain in
desperately unhappy unions that were often not in the best interest of
their children or themselves. Even women in happy marriages often
felt humiliated by the constant messages they received that their
whole lives had to revolve around a man” (Coontz, 1997: 44).

Furthermore, in the case of the more successful marriages, women did
not have to work to support the family, due to the decade’s economic
expansion and the generous and widespread federal assistance
programs. Poverty, though higher than today, was “less concentrated
in pockets of blight existing side-by-side with extremes of wealth,
and unlike today, it was falling rather than rising” (Coontz, 1997:
40). Thus, since only one breadwinner was needed, couples did not
experience the more recent additional stress of raising children while
working fulltime. In effect, the divorce rates fell in the 1950s not
because of a turn in the attitudes of the females, but due to the
overall setup of a booming economy and the lack of approval and
support for women entering the workforce instead of staying home.

Similarly, in the 1990s, the next decade of discussion, the phenomenon
of rising rates of out-of-wedlock births and divorce rates, as well as
decreasing rates of marriage, can be partially attributed to shifts in
economic and employment trends that began in the 1960s and continued
through what was often considered the economic boom of the late
1990s. On the surface, the late 1990s was a “period of strong growth
for families throughout the income scale.” (Mishel, Laurence, Jared
Bernstein, and John Schmitt, 2001: 35) Mishel et al. show that while
median family income for the first half of the decade, 1989-1995,
experienced a drop of $1,572, it grew by $4,555 in the next half of
the decade, or by 2.5% per year. In addition, unemployment fell and
productivity increased (Mishel et al., 2001: 38). It was during this
same period, Coontz states, which divorce rates grew. Divorced men
and women numbered 140 per 1,000 married people; in 1950, that number
was thirty-five individuals per 1,000 married ones (Coontz, 1997:
27). Likewise, the rate of unwed motherhood increased since the end
of 1950 by a factor of 1.73, while that of married women childbearing
fell (Coontz, 1997: 29). Finally, the average of marriage for women
was nearly four years higher than in the 1950s (Coontz, 1997: 31).
Clearly, the marriage institution in the 1990s had changed since the
1950s. To explain these social trends, certain developments in the
economy and in the employment industry in the United States can be

A closer examination into the economic and employment trends of the
later 1990s reveals that behind this impression of prosperity,
inequality of family income, slower growth of wages and income, and
more time at work characterized the lives of the American population
(Mishel et al., 2001: 33). Mishel et al writes, “the upper 20% of
families received 47.2% of all income in 1999. Between 1979 and 1989,
the bottom 80% lost income share and the top 20% gained…The increase
in inequality persisted over the 1989-99 period” (Mishel et al., 2001:
51). Thus, for the general population, instead of experiencing a
growth in income during the supposed prosperity of the later 1990s,
they saw themselves struggling with relatively stagnant wages. Much
of these economic or employment trends of the 1990s, were actually a
continuation of changes that began in the late 1960s or 1970s. For
example, this was the period that saw the beginning of a tighter job
market as the baby boomers grew up, and as it was post-civil rights
and post-feminist movement, a fuller integration of groups such as
women into the labor force. Judith Stacey writes in Brave New
Families: Stories of Domestic Upheaval in Late Twentieth Century

“The emergent postindustrial economy shifted employment from heavy
industries to nonunionized clerical, service, and new industrial
sectors. Employers found themselves irresistibly attracted to the
nonunionized, cheaper labor of women and thus, increasingly to that of
married women and mothers” (Stacey, 1990: 11).

In effect, real wages, which had been rising since the 1950s, started
to fall in the early 1970s, and in the 1990s had yet to recover.

Such economic pressures led to two options for a family: modifying
lifestyle or changing the structure of the family. By the mid 1970s,
family form had changed to maintain the standard of living. Most
families, Coontz quotes economists Gordon Berlin and Andrew Sum,
“‘kept their standard of living up even while real wages were falling
by doing the following four things: they postponed marriage, both
spouses entered the labor market, they had fewer children, and they
went into debt’” (Coontz, 1997: 47). Economic pressures lead to
dual-wage earner households, which soon led to stress on marital
bonds, as couples tried to balance work and family pressures. Women,
especially, had mixed feelings about balancing their traditional
duties at home with the necessity, or desire, to work. In the 1990s,
as little had changed dramatically since, these trends persisted.

This historical background can thus explain the apparent delaying and
even exiting of women from the marriage institution in the 1990s. To
begin with, in contrast to the 1950s, where women had few choices
outside the household and relied on the male’s earnings, women now had
the choice of remaining single or being a single parent and herself
generating the income. Stacey explains, “For modern marriages, unlike
their predecessors, were properly affairs not of the purse but of the
heart” (Stacey, 1990: 9). And for those who were married, the
struggle to raise family income with both people working full time
strained marital bonds, leading to higher divorce rates. The way out
of this trend, Coontz suggests, is not for individuals to adapt, but
for the employment industry to change its hours and its policies to
fit the new family structure.

Thus, while both the 1950s and the 1990s were decades of relative
economic prosperity, conditions among U.S. households and families
contrasted significantly with each other. The 1950s marked a notable
drop in the number of divorces and a rise in marriages; the 1990s, on
the other hand, saw the other polar end of more divorces and
out-of-wedlock births and fewer marriages. Instead of attributing
these trends simply to the changes of values and personal
responsibilities, analyses from sociologists Coontz, Stacey, and
Mishel et al. have shown that the embracing or shunning of the
institution of marriage and other related developments is largely a
response to the economic and employment conditions of the time
period. As Coontz noted, “Men and women have different options in our
society, outside and independent of their personal relationships”
(Coontz, 1997: 19). These options have changed and will continue to
change according to developments in economy and employment, and
ultimately as a result, will affect the features of U.S. households
and families.

Return to 123HelpMe.com