The Tumultuous Relationship between the East and the West

969 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: A critique of orientalism

During the Age of Exploration, early orientalism started to take shape in fashion. Since, the East has remained an inspiration and influence to Western culture. In spite of this, oriental dress does not symbolise cultural flexibility and acceptance, but rather imperialism. It is a metaphor whereby the West establishes a dominant role over the East by studying and reproducing oriental culture. As Edward W. Said put it, “Imperialism consolidated the mixture of cultures and identities on a global scale. But its worst and most paradoxical gift was to allow people to believe that they were only, mainly exclusively…Oriental” . Moreover, this essay will explore the tumultuous relationship between the East and the West, as well as discuss the impact and progress of Orientalism in fashion. Paul Poiret was the first couturier to embrace draping, thus moving away from the more traditional techniques of tailoring and corsetry. This launched the transformation of couture traditions of the Belle Époque. To many, Poiret had dethroned the paradigm of Western fashion when he employed the art of Orientalism into clothing. Today, Marc Jacobs also illustrates the contribution of Orientalism in contemporary fashion through his cheongsam-infused 2011 Spring collection for Louis Vuitton. A direct and modern take on Orientalism, the collection highlights the feeling of ‘otherness’, in that the Orient represents an exotic fantasy as opposed to being an equal: “Present-day orientalism is a ‘series of imaginary mirrorings’ in which the white Westerner enacts a level of otherness that eclipses the circumstances of the ‘true’ other” . Essentially, Marc Jacobs embodies a colonialist who explores and exploits the Orient, therefore reinforcing the idea that Or... ... middle of paper ... ...countries begin ‘reorienting’ themselves as oriental. More specifically, “it is making peace with an expectation, which, in fashion, was either falsely affirmed or subverted” . Finally, the Oriental look or Orientalism is manipulated and managed as a sub-style, able to create its own identity and aesthetic hegemony, thus enabling it to establish itself and endure. To conclude, today’s Orient in contemporary Western fashion does not refer to the trophy of imperialism. On the contrary, there exists a developed, nomadic Eastern quality that the industry has embraced: its fashion (modernity). Fashion does not belong solely to the West. Hence, there is a greater sense of equality, in that the West exists in the East just as much as the East is present in the West. “They 'live' in one another and their 'own' identity is created by acts of constant slippage and renewal” .

Show More
Related

  • Analysis Of Anne Meneley's Tournament Of Values

    904 Words  | 2 Pages

    In “The Meaning of Adornment,” a sub-chapter within “Distinction and Display in the Visiting Scene,” Meneley explains how important adornment (fashion) is for Zabidi women. The women made sure that they publicly dress too impressed because they know that their families and themselves will be judged (Meneley 1996: 109). Zabidi women become the active participators when they dress appropriately to their culture to ensure their families’

    Read More

  • Cultural Appropriation Essay

    1503 Words  | 4 Pages

    Although concerns about cultural appropriating cultural objects such as bindis, war bonnets, and kimonos have been receiving more attention, the effects of cultural tourism of modern Asian subcultures has been relatively ignored. This lack of attention may be due to the assumption of modernity as Western or a lack of an object that bears significant cultural meaning to the ethnic culture as a whole. However, if the potential effects are left ignored, cultural tourism of modern Asian subcultures may perpetuate harmful constructions of race. The visual analysis of Gwen Stefani and Avril Lavinge’s cultural appropriation of Harajuku culture reveals that it not only reaffirms Asian American female submissiveness and Asian American invisibility, but it also constructs meanings of race and whiteness that excludes American cultural citizenship from Asian Americans.

    Read More

  • Stereotypes Of Orientalism In John Luther Long's Madame Butterfly

    1526 Words  | 4 Pages

    The Western ideology of the Eastern exoticism and docility originates from the long historical context of imperialism and political tensions between the West and the East. Domestic struggles caused by political strife and war in the East, such as the Philippines during the American-Spanish War and China during the Opium Wars, created an opportunity for the West to infiltrate the destabilized Eastern countries. This access allowed the West to exercise a form of supremacy over Asia, as the East was seen as powerless and incapable of self-governance. Thus, considering themselves as racially and politically superior, the West adopted a “White Man’s Burden” mentality described as the duty of the masculine Western men to dominate the East and civilize the “uneducated” and “feminine” Orientals. This racial supremacy mentality characterized the Eastern natives as feminine and the Western imperialists as masculine because the Eastern natives were obedient and docile to those of the West. This historical framework would eventually co...

    Read More

  • Racism, Sexism, and Sexuality Shown Through M. Butterfly by David Henry Hwang

    1797 Words  | 4 Pages

    ...d pleasures: orientalism in America, 1870-1930. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press in association with the Sterling and Francine Clark Art Institute, 2000. Print.

    Read More

  • Edward Said's Orientalism

    1010 Words  | 3 Pages

    Orientalism is never far from what Denys Hay ahs called the idea of Europe, a collective notion identifying ‘us’ Europeans as against all ‘those’ non-Europeans, and indeed it precisely what made that culture hegemonic both in and outside Europe: the idea of European identity as superior one in comparison with ass the non-European peoples and cultures (7).

    Read More

  • How The Qing Dynasty Changed China's Fashion

    1288 Words  | 3 Pages

    It is fair to say that China is becoming more and more influential on a global scale. Not only does China influence the economy and foreign policies, but it also establishes much of the world’s aesthetic framework. For instance, many designers have incorporated flamboyant elements of Chinese fashion into their collection and displayed the designs in the Milan Fashion week. Moreover, magazines often invite Chinese celebrities, who are dressed in Chinese inspired gowns, to pose for their front page (an example would be Men’s Uno Magazine). Amongst all the inspiration provided by China’s history and fashion, Qing Dynasty’s imperial fashion

    Read More

  • Embracing Defeat By John Dower

    1276 Words  | 3 Pages

    Western materialism and consumerism, especially products like lipstick and nylon stockings, became a trademark for the pan pan look. It is with these Western goods that the metaphorical transition of the Japanese image from brutish, masculine dominant threat to the vision of a docile female body was formed. Here Dower explicitly depicts the interconnectivity of Japanese and Western cultures through commercialism.

    Read More

  • Israeli Etgar Keret’s The Bus Driver Who Wanted to be God, and Iranian Marjane Satrapi’s Persepolis

    5166 Words  | 11 Pages

    The colonial enterprise, particularly the European imperialist projects in the east, has forever changed concepts of identity, otherness, and power in both the Occident and the Orient. Both sides were indisputably and irrevocably altered; however, the effect upon native cultures (the colonized) was far greater than the effect on the imperial cultures (the colonizers). European colonizers were able to cherry-pick the greatest parts of “new” culture—their art, their music, their architecture, or their cuisine—and adopt or adapt it to modern imperial life. In many ways, the cultural practices and artifacts of a newly colonized civilization were treated like the natural resources (oil, silk, spice) the Europeans were there to gather: they mattered only in their usefulness to the empire. Unlike their imperial counterparts, however, the native peoples had no choice which customs and practices to adopt, and which to discard. The sheer military might and nature of the colonial enterprise demanded that the colonized completely adapt to the social and cultural norms of the empire. In essence, then, the colonized were forced to lead a life of double consciousness, wherein they participated in customs and practices and obeyed laws and regulations in which they did ...

    Read More

  • Chungking Express And The Mood For Love

    486 Words  | 1 Pages

    The opening scene of Chungking Express shows us glimpse of Pan-Asian culture by introducing the concept of Kawaii, meaning cute in Japanese, it is closely linked to aesthetic expressions of kitsch which develop remarkably distinct features in all modernist East Asian countries. Kawaii culture bears traits of a social crisis that is most obvious in Japan, described and characterized as being all style and no substance. “An imminent disillusionment with society as well as a psychological helplessness and scrutinized perceptions of the self.” (Bornstein 2008). A critique of Kawaii culture and its focus on consumers’ values and obsessive fashion consciousness is not unlike Douglas Keller’s critique of consumerism and antique cultural signifiers

    Read More

  • Fashion In France: The History Of Fashion

    1059 Words  | 3 Pages

    A quote by American poet, Allen Ginsberg says, “You can’t escape the past in Paris, and yet what’s so wonderful about it is that the past and present intermingle so intangibly that it doesn’t seem to burden.” In order to truly understand the large role that fashion plays in a culture where the past is such a large part of the present, one must learn about its deep history and evolution.

    Read More

  • How the Trickle-Down Theory Works in China

    2827 Words  | 6 Pages

    The Trickle-down theory, a well-known theory in fashion industry, has significant meaning in 19th to 20th century Europe. The American economist and sociologist, Veblen, published The theory of the Leisure Class by 1899, in which he discussed the split between the leisure class and the industrial class in the US critically. He concluded that leisure class treats dress as a sign of their status and possessions, furthermore, ‘Dress must not only be conspicuously expensive and inconvenient; it must at the same time be up to date’(Veblen 1994), by saying that, he refers to upper class was tend to create new fashion trend which was the top of the trickle-down theory. In the 20th century, Simmel, the German sociologist and philosopher, developed this theory further from a more sympathetic perspective. He drew much attention to sameness and difference amongst both classes in his book Fashion (Simmel 1973). The upper class gets self-satisfied and the proof of its priority by distinguishing itself from others, and working class follows the fashion trend which led by upper class in order to feel like he or she is ‘belonging to’ higher class. These opinions which were discussed by Veblen and Simmel were coined by a journalist in the mid-20th century, as ‘Trickle- down Theory’. During mid-18th to early 20th century, the trickle-down theory described the process of how fashion flows, and explains that fashion is a cultural and sociological phenomenon which includes the discourse of identity and uniformity, agency and structuralism. This phenomenon was not limited by geography, at the same period, in the other side of the world, similar situation happened in China which is a typical East Asian country....

    Read More

  • The Fashion Revolution in France

    1465 Words  | 3 Pages

    Fashion plays an important role in the lives of billions all over the world; people, as part of a status craving society, turn to “fashion capitals” of the world for ways in which to dress and carry themselves. New York, Milan, and Paris are leaders among this fierce industry that the world lusts after. Fashion can speak volumes about ones personality, or also about the condition the world is in at the time. In France, fashion changed rapidly and feverously as the times changed.

    Read More

  • Essay On Fashion Stereotypes

    451 Words  | 1 Pages

    His research and publications address environmental thought, cultural inquiry, philosophy of art and culture, holistic well-being, and, applied philosophy and ethics. His book Fashion Myths: A Cultural Critique, discusses advertisements of fashion, and fashion-related goods from a philosophic-anthropological perspective within a contemporary cultural context. In other words, understanding the thoughts of consumers when watching advertisements and making purchases. Understanding the matter from an anthropological perspective, as well as from a design perspective, allows for insight into the matter through an interdisciplinary approach, aiding in understanding the situation from both sides: designer and

    Read More

  • Fashion is an Art

    1515 Words  | 4 Pages

    Fashion takes on many different facets and concerns many subsets— a model sashaying down the runway in a gown encrusted in real gems, Lady Gaga’s infamous dress made of cuts of raw beef, a teenage girl obsessing over the season’s latest styles— it is all an expression of our minds and who we are or want to be, made tangible. It is a medium just like any other, for while artists wield brushes and paints, designers use thread and cloth to illustrate their vision. The artistry is none more so apparent than in the exclusive world of haute couture, a world of extravagance that caters to aesthetics, producing one-of-a-kind wearable masterpieces that are made to be admired rather than worn. It is without doubt, high fashion and its design is an art.

    Read More

  • The Relationship Between Fashion and Lifestyle

    1735 Words  | 4 Pages

    From a historic point of view, Western travelers had remarked on the slow pace of lifestyle and fashion change in Turkey and Persia. On the other hand, many people were of the opinion that the western culture is getting out of hand in terms of dressing fashion (Cumming 234). In most cases, change of fashion and dressing style took place hand in hand with economic and social changes. In the developing world, changes in fashion began with the coming of the whites in Middle East. Changes began in the 11th century when the Turks came to central Asia and Far East. In Europe, continuous change in clothing fashion is believed to have started in middle 14th century. It started by a sudden introduction of shortening and tightening of male garments, it further brought the introduction of trousers and leggings that were worn by men (Cumming 235). After the advent of change in men fashion, it was followed by changes in female c...

    Read More

More about The Tumultuous Relationship between the East and the West

Open Document