Sirius and XM Satellite Radio as a Monopoly

  • Length: 798 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)
  • Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

When the word monopoly is spoken most immediately think of the board game made by Parker Brothers in which each player attempts to purchase all of the property and utilities that are available on the board and drive other players into bankruptcy. Clearly the association between the board game and the definition of the term are literal. The term monopoly is defined as "exclusive control of a commodity or service in a particular market, or a control that makes possible the manipulation of prices" (, 2008). Monopolies were quite common in the early days when businesses had no guidelines whatsoever. When the U.S. Supreme Court stepped into break up the Standard Oil business in the late 1800’s and enacted the Sherman Antitrust Act of 1890 (Wikipedia 2001), it set forth precedent for many cases to be brought up against it for years to come.
Such as the case of two major players in the entertainment community of Sirius and XM who both have a majority of the marketplace in the satellite radio business and their talks of consolidating both businesses into one. This article on Ars Technica (Lasar, 2008) expands on the idea that these corporate entities should not be allowed to merge into one corporation, but above that should also be fined for even considering the idea in back rooms and locked boardrooms. Using the model case of the Sherman Anti-Trust act in Standard Oil, the corporation floated around having anywhere between eighty five percent and ninety five percent. With those numbers, XM and Sirius would fall into the numerical category of filling that condition of a monopoly.
Since this debate still rages on, many people argue both sides of the story of the pros and cons. Many would argue that not breaking up monopolies actually increase the competition of companies that are attempting to break into some of the market share that the monopoly already has, more so than the free market that exists now. Proponents of the Sherman Anti-Trust act argue that “absolute power corrupts absolutely” (Martin, 1996) as originally quoted by Baron Acton. The idea that no competition within the business world establishes no risk and reward that is all part of the entrepreneur spirit of the U.S. spirit.
The U.S. constitution and the Sherman Anti-Trust act has very little to do with laws but more so to eliminate the concept of no competition. If the merger between XM and Sirius was approved, it would be allowing two large corporate entities that have already established a large portion of the customer base within their field of expertise.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Sirius and XM Satellite Radio as a Monopoly." 22 Apr 2018
Title Length Color Rating  
Clear Channel's Grip on College Radio Essay - Clear Channel Communications, owner of 1,200 stations across the United States, has been undermining the values of diversity, localism, and market completion within the music industry since the media policy wars in the early 2000s. Since then, the radio industry arguably has lost a significant amount of the authenticity it once had. The only exception is college radio: the last safe haven for musical integrity. The only facet of radio not owned and controlled by a major monopoly. Recently, however, Clear Channel has gone to bed with college radio stations across the country....   [tags: Media ]
:: 3 Works Cited
1147 words
(3.3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Business Proposal For Sirius Satellite Radio Inc Essay - Business Proposal for Sirius Satellite Radio Inc. The following is a proposal for Sirius Satellite Radio to gain exclusive rights to Division 1 college football. It examines Sirius' current business model and how this new line of programming could be incorporated in to the existing model. Sirius Satellite Radio offers advertisement free, subscription based, satellite radio service in the United States and Canada. Sirius was founded in 1990 as Satellite CD Radio Inc., but, according to Radio Ink, officially changed it's name, to the current designation, in 1999....   [tags: Business Strategy Proposal Satellite Radio] 1749 words
(5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Brand Profile for XM Radio - Brand Profile for XM Radio *Brand Name: XM Radio *Brand Quality: Superior digital sound technology, unparalleled signal coverage, proven chipset technology, and outstanding programming. *Physical Characteristics of the Brand: All hardware is manufactured by third parties, the service is all that is supplied by XM; however all hardwire contains the XM logo. *Brand Strategy: “With XM, listeners will enjoy the clearest the clearest, hottest, hippest, and most provocative radio entertainment, seamlessly across the country.” *Brand Image: Satellite radio inventor, innovator, and market leader....   [tags: Marketing Branding Market] 1589 words
(4.5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay about Sirius Satellite Radio, Inc. - COMPANY BACKGROUND SIRIUS Satellite Radio was incorporated on May 17, 1990 as Satellite CD Radio Inc. On November 18th 1999 the company changed their name to SIRIUS Satellite Radio Inc, which is the name under which the FCC license to distribute satellite radio was given to. SIRIUS Satellite radio currently offers over 100 of music, news, sports, talk, entertainment, traffic, weather, and children’s programming to subscribers throughout the United States. Their primary source of revenue is through subscription fees, with most of their customers subscribing to SIRIUS Satellite Radio on either a monthly or a yearly basis....   [tags: Marketing Business Plan Essays] 2341 words
(6.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Radio Goes Sky-High At Xm Satellite Radio - In 1988, American Mobile Satellite Corporation (AMSC) was formed with the intention of providing a satellite telephone, fax and data network. It was ruled by the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) that sufficient bandwidth existed for only one license to be issued for such broadcasting, which forced the competing firms to form the joint venture. It was the above named American Mobile Satellite Corporation (AMSC) who was granted the license. In 1992, CD Radio, who later changed their name to Sirius Satellite Radio, successfully petitioned the FCC and Congress to examine the creation of a new digital audio radio service in the United States (Uhle, 1998)....   [tags: XM Radio Satellite]
:: 8 Works Cited
2001 words
(5.7 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Value Propositions of Sirius Satellite Radio Essay - I think there are only two value propositions that Sirius gives their consumers. I think the number of radio stations and genres that they have is the most important. The second most important I think is that they have no commercials on most of their stations. I think that these value propositions would sell most of the nation, but that isn't true because there are only around 700,000 subscribers total. I completely agree with these value propositions, these value propositions give satellite radio the edge against FM and AM radio....   [tags: Marketing] 630 words
(1.8 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Xm Radio And Sirius Financial Analysis - Sirius vs. XM: Ratio Analysis and Statement of Cash Flows Paper From the previous company selection paper, we are now familiar with the selected satellite radio broadcasting companies, Sirius and XM Satellite Radio. Our group will now take a further, in-depth look at the ratio analysis and statement of cash flows to get a better understanding of how the companies are doing financially and with in their market. First, we will be reviewing the cash flows for both companies and identifying how much cash was generated or used by each through everyday operations, and financing and investing activities....   [tags: Business Finance] 1774 words
(5.1 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Satellite Radio and Howard Stern Essay examples - Satellite Radio: Will Howard Stern's move make us change the way we think about radio. Howard Stern's plan to move to satellite radio in January 2006 marks a major turning point for the radio industry. Not only has Stern brought the  possibility of subscribing to satellite radio into the minds of the millions in his audience, he has also gotten more people to start thinking and talking about what really distinguishes satellite radio from traditional radio. Satellite radio was first authorized by the Federal Communication Commission (FCC) in 1997, seven years after initial applications....   [tags: essays research papers] 1065 words
(3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
The Emergence of Satellite Radio Essay - The Emergence of Satellite Radio While the transition of television to a digital technology with its improved picture and sound quality has been a much publicized and controversial process, television's venerable ancestor, radio, has stayed in the background. But this year, in the United States, radio broadcasting is making its own digital leap. Two start-ups are introducing a new type of radio broadcast--subscription-based digital audio sent from satellites. With satellite digital audio radio services (SDARS), as they're called, listeners will be able to tune in to the same radio stations anywhere in the United States....   [tags: Papers] 3342 words
(9.5 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Essay about Satellite Radio - Satellite Radio When I drive my car around town running errands and going from place to place, it’s nice to listen to the radio. Now since this distance I am traveling seems to be within a 30-40 mile radius, flipping through the stations is not much of a problem for me. Now on the other hand, I do travel out of town frequently, and I hate it when I want to listen to the radio and there is no signal. The reason why none of us can is because radio signals don’t carry much farther than the town’s radius....   [tags: Technology Essays] 854 words
(2.4 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]

This merger would be going against the concept of competition and allowing these companies to have free reign of this service. The involved entities would argue that their market share is relative to the size of their market. Satellite Radio although making strides to increase the level of popularity among the average consumer is still relatively a developing medium for entertainment and still fully unproven as a business model. Even with the huge coup of Howard Stern broadcasting exclusively on the Sirius Broadcasting Network, people have been slow to adapt this form of communication.
It is still unclear whether or not the federal government will eventually approve the merger between the two corporations of XM and Sirius is still in appeal after numerous trials and hearings have been held. Constitutionally speaking, the merger is clearly in violation of the Sherman Anti Trust act. Then again, the main argument against this breach is the fact that this act in the Constitution was breaking up a gigantic entity such as oil (or future disputes of this act; transportation, entertainment and gaming) and not concentrating on such a small subset of an industry. For example, if Microsoft and Apple were to announce that they were merging their companies together they clearly would not be allowed to move forward with the transaction as the computing manufacturing industry is booming, extremely lucrative and above all a proven medium. The merger still has a lot of steam left in it’s case so it is by no means dead in the water but it clearly needs to focus on the fact that their industry is unproven and not similar to industries that manufacture or create goods like the oil industry.

Lasar, Matthew (2008, June 8). Coalition demands XM/Sirius pay millions for swindling FCC. Ars Technica, Retrieved June 8 2008, from

Martin, Gary (1996). Power Corrupts. Retrieved June 8, 2008, from Power Corrupts Web site:

monopoly. (n.d.). Unabridged (v 1.1). Retrieved June 09, 2008, from website:

Sherman Anti Trust Act. (2001). In Wikipedia [Web]. San Fransisco: Wikipedia. Retrieved June 8 2008, from

Return to