Human Beings as the Puppets of Society
Sociologists have long argued about whether or not we are controlled
by the structure of the society in which we live, in other words, are
we or are we not ‘puppets of society’. Social structure theorists
such as Functionalists and conflict theorists like Marxists, believe
that we are ‘puppets’ and that our behaviour is controlled by the
structure of the society in which we live. Both theories suggest that
people are controlled by society but this argument is opposed by
social action theorists such as Symbolic Interactionists who believe
that society is created by the individuals themselves. To show far it
can be argued that human beings are ‘puppets of society’ this essay
will look at functionalism and social control through the family,
Marxism and social control within the education system and then look
at the opposing theory of Symbolic Interactionism. It is also
intended to discuss the recent structuration theory of Giddens who
argues that these theories are no longer valid in determining if we
are ‘puppets’ because both structure and action are necessary for
society to exist and thus in some instances in our lives we are
‘puppets’ and others we are not.
According to Jones, Functionalists like Durkheim consider ‘human
behaviour as learned behaviour’(2004, p.6), in other words everything
we know and do has to be taught to us given that when we are born we
have no knowledge of anything. They argue that all our behaviour is
learnt through the socialisation process. Functionalists consider
that primary socialisation is the basis to learning the norms, values
and roles of society and...
... middle of paper ...
...eeded, so it could be argued, therefore, that even
though at times we are free agents and have an individual choice in
our actions we are also ‘puppets of society’ because of the many of
the structures of society.
References List
Czerniawski, G., 2004. What is the Role of Education? Sociology
Review, 14 (2), 24-25
Giddens, A., 2002. Sociology. 4th ed. Polity Press
Jones, P., 2004. Introducing Social Theory. Cambridge: Polity Press
Wilson, A., 1985. Society Now: Family. London: Tavistock Publications
Bibliography
Moore, S., 2001. Sociology Alive. 3rd ed. Cheltenham: Nelson Thornes
Ltd
Haralambos and Holborn, 2000. Sociology Themes and Perspectives. 5th
ed. London: Collins Educational
Bauman Z & May T., 2003. Thinking Sociologically. 2nd ed. London:
Blackwell Publishing Ltd
It was Emerson who said it best, “For nonconformity, the world whips you with its displeasure” (Porter 1155). With a detailed look of Amy Tan’s “Two Kinds” and John Updike’s “A&P,” you will find that this quote is entirely applicable in the context of oppressiveness and in the likeness of “coming of age.” These two stories document the different perspectives of two characters’ growing up and how the role of the invisible hand of oppression guides developing adolescents into mature adults; without prejudice or even forethought. The characters in question are: Sammy, an A&P store clerk whose time spent at work reveals how oppressed by society he is, and Jing-Mei, whose life and every move is dictated by the iron fist of her high-expectations Asian mother. In comparing these stories, you will find how two characters, with very different lives, are essentially affected by the same forces of humanity.
Stephen King once stated “We never know which lives we influence, or when, or why.” People can be influenced greatly by their society and surrounding environment. Once a common belief is generated, it is usually difficult or others if. In the play, The Crucible, such is shown through the Salem witch trials. In the article, “It’s 2013, and They’re Burning ‘Witches’” the people of Papua New Guinea, also known as PNG, still believe that black magic is used to kill people who have no relation to each other. The general belief that the society influences determine the rash decisions that people take and the fear the unknown results in the blame of the unknown.
In retrospect, I think that we learn all these things for many reasons. One of which being to mourn the lives lost. Another being to learn from previous mistakes. Finally I think we do it to be grateful for the equality and freedom in our lives. That is why I think we learn about the Holocaust.
though, that we don't know as much as we think we do. A person doesn't really
An individual’s role in society can vary with the number themes the characters exhibit. When there are signs of fate, cruelties, weaknesses, and desires for justice and catharsis the role of an individual becomes more complicated. In Antigone, most of those themes are shown thus a single person’s influence or role on society is very small and complicated to attain. However in The Lottery the society has most of the control and there is not many signs of those characteristics so the role of a person is simplified because they are nothing compared to the society combined. Finally, in The Penalty of Death, there are signs of many of the themes but since it is the societies influence against that of an individuals, it is simplified because they have to work together.
and by the teachings of those typically older than themselves. the amount of lessons a person is taught is far beyond count, and unique
James Thurber had many set backs in college. Thurber challenges society and the traditions of modern universities. In the essay "University Days" Thurber mocks the hegemonic structure of schools. He gives examples of the many outdated practices still used today. Thurber disagrees with many of the standard methods of teaching and gives examples of failures in amusing situations to hold the attention of his young audience.
Death does not surrender to science or to rationality; therefore, some people resort to irrational behavior when faced with the fact they may die soon. The fear of death, or, specifically, the anxiety of it, can cause various reactions. A number of people may reach out to love ones for support and comfort while others may run away. These differences in behavior, fight or flight, are a result of a natural human response to fear. Fear affects many people on a daily basis from fear of failure, fear of rejection, or fear of death. This fear may cause certain people to work harder and conquer their fear and overcome it; however, this anxiety that accompanies fear may cause others to surrender to it. Fear is a very powerful emotion that has the ability to make some people prisoners in their own body. Plato’s “Allegory of the Cave” conveys a story of prisoners chained in a cave incapable of moving. The people in society that are chained by fear are very similar to the prisoners in Plato’s cave. Furthermore, the prisoners are forced to view shadows that appear on the cave wall in front of them. Due to the shackles, the prisoners are unable to move their heads to see behind them; therefore, the prisoners believe the shadows of the cave as reality. This story helps to acknowledge that many people may accept these chains by surrendering to fear, hence never reaching true enlightenment. These “prisoners of fear” may not reach their true potential due to fear of failure; consequently, fear will keep a vast majority of people chained to unrewarding, unfulfilling lives. Through the characters Carter Chambers and Edward Cole, Rob Reiner suggests the different ways that fear can act as a chain in his movie The Bucket List,...
Everything worth knowing can be taught by going out into the world and meeting new people and doing things that a person has not experienced for themselves. Oscar Wilde is right in certain circumstances, but he is also wrong. While valuable knowledge is not gotten from a textbook we have to get it somehow. Nobody is born knowing everything they do when they are at the end of their life, so if nothing worth knowing can be taught, how would anybody
In general, when people are learning, they achieve a state of understanding by learning something they consider they do not know. However, this common-sense contains a very irrational factor, that is, if a person have no idea about something exists, then for this person, that kind of things does not exist, hence the person will not emerges a desire to acquire that kind of things, then this person cannot behave like discovering or learning. If a person emerges a desire for something, that person must already know it sometime in the past in some way. Only in this way, it will make sense.
he focus of this paper will be to examine Kate Chopin’s The Awakening chapter ten, specifically paragraphs five to ten. Throughout The Awakening Edna is constantly fighting with the expectations of society and her desire to be a free woman. As a woman, Edna is expected to be the perfect wife and mother, however she longs to embrace and free her creative self. Because of this battle within herself she shows many of the characteristics of depression. The passage mentioned above is very symbolic of Edna’s fight to overcome her mental illness. The thesis of this paper is that Edna’s yearning to swim is a metaphor for her longing to overcome depression, patriarchal expectations and societal constraints. By taking an in-depth look into the author’s word choice, a parallel can be found between learning to swim and the ability to overcome the depression within.
The article examines the need for various social controls in a society, for the society itself not to fall apart. Peter Berger believed that by using Social control it could bring its recalcitrant members back into line. He believed that all groups no matter how small needed social controls to survive. He explores three areas of control political and legal controls, economics pressures, and ostracism. With the Political and legal controls the ultimate and, no doubt, the oldest means of social control is physical violence. In the politely operated societies of modern democracies the ultimate argument is violence. With economic pressure, few means of coercion are as effective as those that threaten one’s livelihood or profit. Both management and labor effectively use this threat as an instrumentality of control in our society. But economic means of control are just as effective outside the institutions properly called the economy. A good example of an economic sanction would be for a minister. It may not be actually illegal for a minister to seduce his
Social control involves rules and behaviors that members of a society are expected to follow.
...t find anything new. This description points out the hindrances on humans’ acquisition of knowledge because of our finite biological capacities.
After a person is aware of their ignorance, they can seek knowledge by learning from others and discovering for themselves. Living a life where someone is constantly examining themselves is important because if they do not examine themselves, then they will not have knowledge about the things they do not know about themselves. Learning from others is a passive way of getting to know something because you are not trying to go out and experience it yourself and learn through experiences. Learning from others is crucial early on in a humans’ life. As humans grow up, they should start seeking more knowledge for themselves as opposed to learning from others because seeking knowledge for ourselves can help to get to the deeper truth about themselves or something else. In school, students often are learning from others instead of gaining knowledge themselves. When students start to discover knowledge themselves, they are trying to get to the truth and are interested in gaining knowledge about the