Jean Rhys' Use of Conflicting Narratives of Antoinette and Rochester in Wide Sargasso Sea

2150 Words5 Pages

Jean Rhys' Use of Conflicting Narratives of Antoinette and Rochester in "Wide Sargasso Sea"

There are many techniques Jean Rhys uses to bring across the point

that the narrators are unreliable and the truth twisted, it is an

interesting and effective idea as it makes the reader feel confused on

who to trust and really involves them in the book, they become party

to the secrets.

Rhys’ book is so complex as it is obviously linked to the Classic

book- ‘Jane Eyre’; this is classic English literature and therefore is

always in our minds during WSS. Those that have read ‘Jane Eyre’

normally like to trust Jane as she is a heroine who we have sympathy

for; we are introduced to her from when she is young so we know and

understand her and how she behaves. Also in ‘Jane Eyre’, Mr.Rochester

comes across very innocent, you believe he is trustworthy and that he

loves Jane, you want them to be happy together- when he reveals his

'mad wife' to Jane you feel sympathy for him as he is in such a bad

situation, you also feel sympathy for Jane; you feel resentful towards

Bertha as she ruined what Jane and Rochester could have had; it is

easy to feel like this as you don’t know her, as you do in WSS.

Bertha, in ‘Jane Eyre’, gets locked up in a luxury place; it seems she

has her own 'quarters' unlike in WSS. When you read WSS I felt less

sympathy for Mr.Rochester because you don’t really get the impression

that he loves Antoinette and that he is only marrying her for money.

Another factor that creates contrast between these novels is it is set

in a midst of strange confusing things (WSS) and a completely

different culture, which is chaotic and primitive, this makes us more

misplaced. Whereas in ‘Jane Eyre’ the culture is...

... middle of paper ...

...ve in

Jane. However I think eh main reason why I find Antoinette more

credible is because we here from her from the start, when she is

young. When we are first introduced to Rochester’s narrative we are

lost in the switch from part to part so we don’t get so in-depth with

him, Antoinette starts the novel so we trust her account; it’s the

first we hear. I generally feel more sympathy for her two as she was

never favoured or appreciated as a young child, rejected by her

mother, father, only friend Tia (who steals her dress), when she is

finally accepted by Richard Mason (stepfather) it is to sell her off

to Mr. Rochester who then accepts her but late rejects her by-

sleeping with her slave whilst she can hear them. She has little power

as a woman and so has to live with these changes made by others. This

is why I feel sympathy for Antoinette over Rochester.

Open Document