Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: an essay on propaganda
The 14th of January of 2014 the president and vice-president of Guatemala, Otto Pérez Molina and Roxanna Baldetti, presented the annual report on the advancements made by the government on violence, child malnutrition and other problems that affect Guatemalan society. When the vice-president was leaving the building, a woman throw flour at her as a demonstration of discontent (Associated Press, 2014). Both the president and vice-president of Guatemala have been accused of corruption and having ties with organized crime (Zamora & Arana, 2013). Although they officially report that they made significantly advancements on matters such criminality and health, there are still 15 homicides per day in Guatemala and many children die due to acute malnutrition. After the flour incident, different media outlets did not pay attention on the government report; instead they focused on the story of how the vice-president had been assaulted. The latter story dominated all social media. This is and excellent example on how mass media is capable of shaping what people talk about and how it distract the public of important matters. In the next few lines will use some of the Marxist analytical tools to understand this type of example.
One of the most important aspects of the mass media that we have to consider through the lenses of the Marxist theory is the pattern of ownership. Ott and Mack (2013, 28) distinguish between four types of patterns: concentration, conglomeration, integration and multinationalism. The documentary BEHIND THE BIG NEWS: PROPAGANDA AND THE CFR (2011) shows how in 1917 J.P. Morgan acquired 25 newspapers after a think tank created by him concluded that owning that many media outlets would allow him to control the public opin...
... middle of paper ...
...t/segundo-informe-de-gobierno-una-invitacion-sonar
El Universal. (2007, January 17). ¿Quién es el empresario Ángel González, el fantasma. El Universal. Retrieved January 28, 2014, from http://www.eluniversal.com.mx/notas/400749.html
Gow, T. (Project Manager). (2011). Behind the Big News: Propaganda and CFR. United States: Wisconsin. Available at http://topdocumentaryfilms.com/behind-the-big-news-propaganda-and-the-cfr/
Gutiérrez, A. (2012, April 12). Encabronados. Plaza Pública. Retrieved January 28, 2014, from http://www.plazapublica.com.gt/content/encabronados
Zamora, J. & Arana, A. (2013, April 8). elPeriódico. Retrieved January 28, 2014, from http://elperiodico.com.gt/templates/especiales/investigacion2013/un-cuento-de-hadas-sin-final-feliz.html
Ott, B.L. & Mack, R.L. (2013). Critical Media Studies: An introduction (2nd ed.) Malden, MA: Wiley-Blackwell.
The Central American country of Guatemala fought a bloody civil war for over 36 years. The internal conflict began in November of 1960 and did not end until December of 1996. The key players that fought where the Guatemalan government and the ethnic Mayan indigenous people that where extremely leftist compared to the Guatemalan government. The indigenous persons where joined by other non-government forces known as the Ladino peasantry and other rural poor. This civil conflict would escalate to a bloody series of events that inevitably would see the Guatemalan government regime held responsible for acts of genocide and other human rights violations.
From the time of its colonization at the hands of Spanish Conquistadors in the early 1500’s, Guatemala has suffered under the oppression of dictator after dictator. These dictators, who ruled only with the support of the military and only in their own interests, created a form of serfdom; by 1944, two percent of the people owned 70 percent of the usable land.
Epstein, Edward J. News From Nowhere: Television and the News, Vintage, New York NY. 1973, pp. 16; Pearson, David. “The Media and Government Deception.” Propaganda Review. Spring 1989, pp. 6-11.
MacLaird correctly portrays the film as a paean to a working class that invisibly participates in public works, risking their lives; she also praises the film’s avoidance of the tremendism predominant in fiction film of the period. However, its ideological commitments are hardly visible because of the close focus on the workers. I think that a critical reading of this documentary requires spectators to dislodge the film’s representation of working-class subjects from any connection to formal left-wing politics. When viewed from this perspective, the film is hardly an endorsement of the infrastructure project it depicts. One should remember that the “segundo piso” (upper tier) was not a particularly popular public works project and, in fact, when Rulfo’s film was released, anti-López Obrador commercials airing on television railed against it to criticize his administration’s high levels of public debt. Moreover, the focus on the workers articulates a criticism of the venture at many levels. It is notable that the workers who intervene in the project are precisely the type of social subjects who will not benefit from the construction. In addition, as Madalina Stefan and Lorena Ortiz point out, the documentary presents a stance that subverts what they call “the narration of national progress” embedded in López Obrador’s developmentalist project by presenting that “progress” from the
Skidmore, T. 2013. Modern Latin America. Eighth Edition. Oxford University Press. Pages 268 - 485
Stokoe, Claire. 100 Years Of Propaganda: The Good, The Bad and The Ugly. Smashing Magazine, 13 June 2010. Web. 07 Dec. 2013.
Jowett, Garth and Victoria O’Donnell. “Propaganda and Persuasion”. Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications, (2nd ed.) 1992. Print. 4 Jan., 2011.
To understand media in our society we can examine it through the contemporary theorists point of view. Three major critical theorist are Max Horkheimer, Theodor Adorno, and Herbert Marcuse. Together they agreed with the base/ superstructure theory by Karl Marx. This is the theory where the base consists of the economy and the superstructure consists of anything such as; religion, law, society values and culture. For marks the base determines the superstructure(Appelrouth & Edles, 2008). For Marx the dominant economic class are the ones that own the means of production, He refers to them as the bourgeois and they have the ability to control societies means of material production and the production of idea (Appelrouth $ Edles, 2008).
Guatemala has experienced many significant changes to their government in the past sixty years. The government faced military coups, governmental reforms along with political and social revolutions. Many political forces have influenced Guatemala and transformed it into the country that it is today.
In the New York Times article, A Wrong Turn for Guatemalan Democracy, Guatemala’s political situation is regarded as a declining state where Congress has most control over corruption, leaving little room for their new president, Jimmy Morales, to consolidate the country’s politics. A democracy is a form of government that reflects the wants and needs of the people through political action. The people of Guatemala are viewed by the author of the article, Anita Isaacs, as the only option to reform the country’s corruption since Mr. Morales has only 11 out of the 158 members of Congress in his political party and the United Nations ceases to assist in aiding the corruption. [Isaacs, A Wrong Turn]. Guatemalan Democracy may be unstable due to the
Looking the historical moment we are living at, it is undeniable that the media plays a crucial role on who we are both as individuals and as a society, and how we look at the...
Snowball, David. "Propaganda and its Discontents." Journal of Communication 49.3 (2009): 165-71. ProQuest. Web. 2 Dec. 2013.
Bennett (2011) felt that one of the biggest problems with bias in the American media was its “overwhelming tendency to downplay the big social, economic, or political picture in favor of the human trials, tragedies, and triumphs (177).” Shaiko (2008) alluded to the fact that the American news media is “accountable to the corporate conglomerates” and not “to the readers, listeners, and viewers (205).” Probably the most telling quotation of all can be found in Chapter 10 of The News Media: Communicating Pol...
For Guatemala, Zemurray’s propaganda led to the collapse of the land reforms which would have empowered the peasants by turning them into producers. As Huxley (76) implies, individual stability precedes social stability. Multinational businesses like Zemurray’s United Fruit Company owe their hosting societies the obligation to act in a sustainable and socially responsible manner that would empower the locals. The use of propaganda by Zemurray was not ethically justified as it destabilized the broader society and led to a strained relationship between the majority Latin American nations and their American neighbors which persists the present.
"The Rise of Modern Propaganda." The Rise of Modern Propaganda. N.p., n.d. Web. 12 Jan. 2014. (TROMP p. #)