Information and Arguments Contained in Images

850 Words2 Pages

Images contain arguments, whether if there are many or just a few. A series of images with no words but contains an argument is a pictorial essay. John Berger's Ways of Seeing (1972) contains both word and pictorial essays. The book is divided into seven sections, three being pictorials. In the very first chapter of the book, Berger made it clear that "the way one image follows another, their succession, constructs an argument which becomes irreversible." Having noted that, it would seem that the sixth essay argues that an observation painting provides more information than that of a directed or arranged portrait. Images that are next to one another in the book such as Sarah Burge, 1883. Dr.Barnardo's Homes and Murillo Bartolomé's Peasant Boy Leaning on Sill shows a comparison between a portrait that seems planned, and one that perhaps was drawn from observation. The information provided from each of them are different because of the way each were portrayed. The images of Sarah Burge1 does tell the viewers her status, but it does not show much of her personality or the time period she may be in. On the other hand the Peasant Boy Leaning on Sill2 provided his social status which is a poor boy due to the clothes he is wearing, a scenario he is perhaps in, possibly a conversation with someone else off to the side since he is not looking directly at the artist and that he is happy that he is being painted for other to see. What we know and what we currently see in these two images do no match with one another. Caroline Jones Senses (2010) discusses how "the senses both constitute our 'sense' of unmediated knowledge and are the first medium with which consciousness must contend." Where our knowledge comes from are based off of ... ... middle of paper ... ...edited by WJT Mitchell and Hansen, 88-99. Chicago, 2010. "Sarah Burge, 1883. Dr Barnardo's Homes." 1883, From: Ways of Seeing. London: British Broadcasting Corporation and Penguin Books Publishing, 1972, 118. Murillo, Bartolomé. "Peasant Boy Leaning on Sill," 1617-82, From: Ways of Seeing, London: British Broadcasting Corporation and Penguin Books Publishing, 1972, 119. "Sale of Pictures and Slaves in the Rotunda, New Orleans," 1842, From: Ways of Seeing, London: British Broadcasting Corporation and Penguin Books Publishing, 1972, 116. Nattier, Jean Marc. "Mademoiselle de Clermont," 1685-1766, From: Ways of Seeing, London: British Broadcasting Corporation and Penguin Books Publishing, 1972, 116. Zoffany, Johann. "Charles, Third Duke of Richmond," 1734/5-1810, From: Ways of Seeing, London: British Broadcasting Corporation and Penguin Books Publishing, 1972, 117.

Open Document