Impermanence in Sonnet 15 Perpetuating the “inconstant stay” by Grafting

1511 Words4 Pages

Shakespeare’s Sonnet 15 explores the possibility of preserving a man through verse, employing a gardening metaphor to explain the process of doing so. Throughout the sonnet, men are likened to plants in their manner of growing, exhibiting beauty, as well as by their impermanence. The comparison between men and plants culminates in the final line of the poem in which the speaker promises to “ingraft [the man] new” (14), presumably through verse. “Ingrafting” in this instance suggests both the act of writing as well as a horticultural process practiced by cultivators of plants. Because writing and the grafting of plants ultimately produce strikingly different results, the poet introduces a dichotomous conception of what exactly he intends for the subject of his sonnet. As a gardener to his plants, the poet may mean to “ingraft” the man with the sonnet such that he is infused with new life and thus “blooms,” or returns to a state of heightened beauty. Alternatively the poet “ingrafts” by writing about or “engraving” the man into verse, thus crafting a permanent and unchanging representation of his much admired graces. The practices of the gardener who causes flowers to bloom and plants to produce fruit may appear to produce an object of greater vitality than those of the poet who “ingrafts” by setting words upon a page. However, if the poet strives for similar results in his craft as the gardener, it is possible that with verse, the subject of poem may be given new energy and life, much like a plant that has been grafted. The final image of Sonnet 15 taken in conjunction with lines from Balthdassar Castiglione’s The Book of the Courtier perhaps suggests that by the writer’s process of creating eternal and apparently lifeless represe...

... middle of paper ...

...the reader. Grafting, as a horticultural process is associated with writing only in word origin and symbolism, but the poet, who has control over his art, affixes new meaning to the term and employs it to participate in his extended plant metaphor.

Works Cited

Castiglione, Balthdassar. The Book of the Courtier. 1528. 58.

“graff” v.

“graff” n.

“graft” n.

“grave” v.

“engrave” v.

“sap” n.

Shakespeare, William. “Sonnet 15.” The Longman Anthology of British Literature. Vol.

1b. Ed. David Damrosch and Kevin J. H. Dettmar. 4th ed. New York: Longman, 2010. 1204.

“stock” n.

More about Impermanence in Sonnet 15 Perpetuating the “inconstant stay” by Grafting

Open Document