The Ghost Road by Par Barker and Paradise by Abdulrazak Gurnah: Viewing the Germans from the British Viewpoint during World War I in Two Novels

3079 Words7 Pages

The criteria that needs to be considered for the winning novel, includes a wide variety of theories, debates and critical writings that together will give an informed and balanced decision. An instinctive judgment would be to view the book cover and the précis of the plot; and then from a personal perspective ask if it would be likely to entice the reader. However, this narrows ones thought process; also an instinctive judgement is based on ones past personal experience, which will ensure that each reader would then have a different view. In order to ensure a balanced and informed view within this essay the impact of the aesthetic theory, which is a view that argues how effective concepts, theories and debates are in explaining and predicting outcomes within literature. Within the aesthetic theory judgements, values and taste are given as views; each individual has the right to have a view that is developed through personal experiences. I will also be discussing the conflict of popular literature, which can be argued is popular due to the amount of novels sold, or due to the readers being able to identify with the novel. Versus the canonical theory which is said to be

Literary works judged to be worthy of academic study (Johnson P.210).

The best novel of the twentieth century is a huge accolade and I have a limited number of words in which I have to debate which chosen novel should win The Pryer Literary Prize. There are centuries of literary history that precede this prize and therefore the literary canon needs to be considered. One needs to consider if either chosen novel fits into the literary canon by asking if future generations will read the it; do they measure up to other canonical works by twentieth century auth...

... middle of paper ...

...had been introduced. There is no political propaganda in the novel that ensured my considered opinion did not differ from my instinctive opinion. I consider that this book could be read by anyone in isolation from the other novels within the trilogy and could still be enjoyed. It was the first novel that I had read about the First World War that was told from the human and personal view, rather than the military view with considered facts and figures. Although Paradise came a close second for me, I felt that this was more of a template novel; although the novel had ticked all the required boxes for a literary prize and perhaps because of this Paradise somehow lacked the sensitivity of The Ghost Road and failed to engage me in the same way. Of course another reader could consider the same criteria chosen by myself and come to a completely different conclusion.

More about The Ghost Road by Par Barker and Paradise by Abdulrazak Gurnah: Viewing the Germans from the British Viewpoint during World War I in Two Novels

Open Document