False Love in The Lottery and To His Coy Mistress


Length: 1328 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)
Rating: Excellent
Open Document

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Text Preview

More ↓

Continue reading...

Open Document

False Love in The Lottery and To His Coy Mistress


What is love? The age-old question arises once more. In truth, a universal definition has not been agreed upon, but generally one can define love as “an indication of adoration” or an “an ineffable feeling of intense attraction shared in interpersonal and sexual relationships.” Love can be directed towards kin, a lover, oneself, nature, or humanity- but regardless that love in an emotional sense is eternal. Some fall into love, and some claim they fall out. Love should be endless, lasting, and pure, but half of the time that love ends up being a sham. There is solid record of this false love- love that is meant to look pure- in the famous writings The Lottery and To His Coy Mistress.

In the case of To His Coy Mistress by Andrew Marvall, a not-so-gentle gentleman is trying to woo a “coy” young lady with claims of love. This poem is strewn with hyperbole to the point that it becomes exactly the opposite of love. When there is such over exaggerated praise, it starts to lose the real meaning of the message. If you take a look at lines 13-18, you can see the obvious amplification:

“An hundred years should go to praise
Thine Eyes, and on thy forehead gaze;
Two hundred to adore each breast,
But thirty thousand to the rest;
An age at least to every part,
And the last age should show your heart.”

How can it be remotely possible to spend thirty thousand years on observing a woman’s body? It seems to me as if he is just telling her what she wants to hear as long as he gets what he wants- which is to get into bed with her. The fallacy is even more apparent once line 20 ends because the mood switches immediately from “loving” to a grotesque, dark tone. The speaker goes on about how if she doesn’t lose her “long preserv’d virginity” to him, then the only way she will lose it is in her grave to the worms crawling inside her. How can that be a portrayal of love? The mere thought of that is absolutely grim. What it really does is negate all of the sweet, exaggerated things he mentioned in the first third of the poem.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"False Love in The Lottery and To His Coy Mistress." 123HelpMe.com. 20 Jan 2018
    <http://www.123HelpMe.com/view.asp?id=168380>.
Title Length Color Rating  
Shirley Jackson's The Lottery Essay - “The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson has been criticized, but its longevity and durability prove it stands the test of time. In the article, “Jackson’s The Lottery,” the author A.R. Coulthard finds a deeper meaning in the story which other critics have not. Coulthard believes the story is a “parable of the evil inherent in human nature” rather than “an assault on mindless cultural conformity,” as other critics have suggested (Coulthard 226). Coulthard shows how something that most likely began as a primitive and ignorant way to ensure prosperity, evolved into a complete need for sanctioned violence and murder....   [tags: The Lottery Essays]
:: 5 Works Cited
1443 words
(4.1 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Essay about Comparison of To His Coy Mistress and An Answer to a Love Letter - Comparison of To His Coy Mistress and An Answer to a Love Letter These two poems are meant to be a love letters written by a man to a lady of higher disposition and an answer to that love letter, written by that lady. The first, written by Marvell is written is telling her 'Carpe Dieum' - or 'Seize the Day' this phrase sums up his poem, as that is what he is telling her to do all the time. This is shown by the way he has structured his piece he starts of explaining what they could do if they had all of the time in the world "We would sit and think which way to Pass our long loves day." This means that they would just spend the whole time talking and planning their life because he says o...   [tags: Love Letters Poetry Poems Essays] 1097 words
(3.1 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Family and Tradition in The Lottery - Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery” published in 1948 takes place in a small village in New England. Upon first reading it would seem as though the lottery that took place in the village was a family friendly tradition that had been carried on for many years. However upon a closer look, it seems as if “family friendly” could be the wrong term to use to describe the lottery due to the nature of what takes place during this tradition. So, the question stands, is the lottery really a family friendly tradition in the village....   [tags: The Lottery Essays]
:: 5 Works Cited
1414 words
(4 pages)
Powerful Essays [preview]
Tradition in The Lottery by Shirley Jackson Essays -         Tradition; it is the back bone of every culture and civilization. It is what keeps the beliefs, philosophies, and activities of societies alive, to be passed down from generation to generation. However not all traditions are practiced with pure intentions.  Some activities become so routine, people don’t know a life outside of them. Societies become so accustomed to “tradition” that they will participate in pastimes without  questioning the ethics or morals of the situation. Ultimately when tradition takes the place of a rationalizing mind the outcome can be incredibly dangerous....   [tags: The Lottery Essays] 1232 words
(3.5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on To the Slaughter in The Lottery, by Shirley Jackson - Screaming, yelling, and screeching emerge from Tessi Hutchinson, but the town remains hushed as they continue to cast their stones. Reasonably Tessi appears as the victim, but the definite victim is the town. This town, populated by rational people, stones an innocent woman because of a lottery. To make matters worse, no one in the town fathoms why they exterminate a guiltless citizen every June. The town’s inexplicable behavior derives from following an ancient, ludicrous tradition. With the omission of one man, no one in the community comprehends the tradition....   [tags: The Lottery Essays]
:: 6 Works Cited
1210 words
(3.5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
A False Romance Essay - Generally speaking, romance is something most people consider as crucial element in a relationship. It’s the feeling that comes upon two individuals that can grow into an everlasting relationship. People have dreamed of having an everlasting passionate love at least once in their lifetime. However, if they expect to have it for a long period of time, they are in trouble because such things do not exist as they do in movies. People have dreams of this false perception of love all the time due to Hollywood movies about love, romantic poems, and television shows....   [tags: movies, fantasy, perception, love, Hollywood]
:: 5 Works Cited
1221 words
(3.5 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Analysis of To His Coy Mistress Essay - To his coy mistress is about sexual feelings and infatuation, based on the Italian tradition of courtly love - it is filled with compliments and references to sexual activity and deviancy but is generally a one sided love, the whole poem is about the man wooing the woman and persuading her that she should have sex with him. Throughout the first stanza the poet writes how he would love the woman, had they had all the time in the world. The love is much exaggerated. "I would love you ten years before the flood" This is clearly an exaggerated statement because the flood happened before Christ, before the poet or the woman even existed....   [tags: To His Coy Mistress, Andrew Marvell] 1067 words
(3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
An Analysis of To His Coy Mistress Essay - The poem, To His Coy Mistress, by Andrew Marvell brings out some actions that some of us have experienced or even thought about in this concise poem.  This poem is very appealing to the male senses and what some make are like.  Some women could be thought of when this is read. Andrew Marvell puts it in words that make it seem as if it was very acceptable.  The first twenty lines of the poem start to talk about how much this girl means to this perticular man.  The main character in the poem talks about how he will wait forever to be with her.  He mentions that “We would sit down and think which way To walk and pass our long love’s day.” (st....   [tags: To His Coy Mistress, Andrew Marvell] 677 words
(1.9 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
Essay on Analysis of To His Coy Mistress - "To His Coy Mistress" is a very interesting poem. The main plot of the poem is about this guy that tries to pick up a girl for the night. The poem does not tell about the setting. I assumed that it was in a bar, because of the way he talked to her and that is where most guys go to pick up a girl for the evening. We see this poem through the eyes of the guy, by doing this Marvell gives a look into his mind and what he is thinking. This helps to bring the reader into the poem. It allows the reader to get into his mind as the poem goes along....   [tags: To His Coy Mistress, Andrew Marvell] 798 words
(2.3 pages)
Strong Essays [preview]
The Lottery by Shirley Jackson Essay - The Lottery by Shirley Jackson I was watching an episode of “The Simpsons” on TV the other day, and there was a craze around town because the Springfield Lottery was up to 130 million dollars. Bookstores were selling out of Shirley Jackson’s “The Lottery”. Homer quickly threw the book into the fireplace when he realized that the book could not tell him how to win the lottery, that it was a book about time old traditions, barbaric, but still practiced nonetheless. If Homer had read the book, he would have discovered that Jackson was projecting a subtle message through the minor character of Old Man Warner that the human race can be quite feeble-minded when it comes to following others and...   [tags: The Lottery Essays] 876 words
(2.5 pages)
Good Essays [preview]

Related Searches




He also repeats the overall theme of the poem again-Carpe Diem. “Time’s winged chariot hurrying near,” so she’d better seize this moment or else her “quaint honor [will] turn to dust.” This, to me, is crucial. If you love someone, you shouldn’t think of rushing to make such drastic decisions because you should want to be with them forever anyways. Especially in his case, if he wanted to be with her as long as he claimed he would, there shouldn’t have been anything to worry about; yet he felt the need to mention the fact that “time’s running out” more than once in an attempt to woo her. It’s obvious that in the last third of the poem he reveals his true intentions-sex.

The way the speaker articulates how he wants to have sex with her is just violent. If a man truly respects a woman and loves her, why would her woo her using an analogy to raptors and cannon balls? To me it seems like he wants to sexually be in command of her. He’s well aware of her virgin status, hence the title “Coy” mistress instead of plain mistress, yet his idea of her first experience with sex is rough sex. When he says he wants to “roll [their] sweetness, up into one ball…through the iron gates of life;” The speaker’s basically saying he wants to brutally tear through her hymen while they make love like “birds of prey.” Throughout this entire poem, there is not one mention of what’s to come in their future, further suggesting that his only intention with her is to have sex and get on with his life. Repeating the idea that they need to “seize the day,” manipulates and traps this poor girl into his dark plans of seduction. If one loves someone, he/she should look at the other’s benefits as well, and it’s clear that the speaker truly couldn’t possibly love his “coy mistress.”

Instead of the “love” one has for their significant other as in To His Coy Mistress, in the case of The Lottery by Shirley Jackson we look at the love one has for their kin. In this story, a town holds an annual “lottery” where the townsfolk’s love for tradition outweighs the love for their own family. Every person, whether it be child or elder, draws slips from an old box; whoever picks the marked slip gets brutally stoned to death by their own family and friends, then forgotten about. The whole notion is absolutely peculiar. These people conduct the lottery every year, perform the stoning on their own loved ones, then allow themselves to go home and eat noon dinner. It’s completely emotionless and nonchalant. When Tessie arrived late to the lottery, she simply said, “[Nearly] forgot what day it was” to a friend, and they both “laughed softly.” In a situation where ones husband or child could die within the next hour, it doesn’t seem sane that two women can joke about the situation. To these townspeople, the lottery is just another thing to do, something to get out of the way. Shortly after Tessie’s late arrival, Mr. Summers tranquilly says “guess we better get started, get this over with, so’s we can go back to work.” Again, the tone of everyone is so blasé.

It is instinct that in any species a mother’s main role is to protect her offspring- evidence of nature and love. But when Mr. Hutchinson’s name was called in the lottery, his wife Tessie was willing to sacrifice their daughter’s life for hers. How can she love her daughter yet be able to let her die? The lottery creates a strain between family and tradition, and the love for tradition wins. What’s even sadder is that the children take part in the yearly occasion. Before the actual lottery takes place, “some of the other boys… selected the smoothest and roundest stones…and made a great pile of stones in one corner of the square and guarded it against the raids of the other boys.” The lottery becomes a sort-of game to the children, where they are seeing who gathers the most stones. The parents have passed on to their children the idea that the lottery isn’t that serious. If parents supposedly love their children, they should try to instill positive messages, not destructive things like this. It’s almost like telling your child that it’s okay for you to join in on killing another human being. That is not loving your child; it’s hurting him/her.

In conclusion, even though these stories are of completely different topics, they still had characters that were supposed to be giving love to each other. In “To His Coy Mistress,” the gentlemen to the young lady, and in “The Lottery,” the townsfolk to their own family. This false love is absolutely revolting. I can’t imagine being serenaded and told that I was loved, only to find out that the man only wanted to have sex with me. In the case of “The Lottery” I know that my mother would never imagine letting me die for the sake of her own life, a mothers sole responsibility is to protect her young. But no matter how shocking and sad these observations are, we see them everyday in real life. Whether it’s an abusive father molesting his child, or an unfaithful husband sneaking off to distant hotels with other women, it’s the same concept: the authenticity of love is turning into a sham.


Return to 123HelpMe.com