Xenotransplantation, Transgenics, and the Animal-human Boundary

Xenotransplantation, Transgenics, and the Animal-human Boundary

The progression of modern science and technology has often challenged old, time-worn notions. Nowhere does this seem truer than in biology and medicine, as these fields have changed drastically in recent decades and also relate so closely to the actual substance of how people live. One such development is what is called xenotrans-plantation or the transplantation of organs or cells across species—particularly notable when from a non-human species into a human. The very fact that the procedure is possible is telling as regards the inherently ephemeral nature of the distinction of humans from other animals. It may be useful to first outline how xenotransplantation works, however.

Many ailments can be cured or at least ameliorated by the replacement of an organ and the progression of medical science has increasingly allowed more types of organs to be successfully transplanted. Doctors’ ability to transplant is thwarted, however, by the disproportionate number of patients in need of such life-saving treatment relative to the number of donor organs available. Due to a variety of circumstances there just aren’t enough spare organs to go around. In light of this situation and the ever increasing number of people who die every year while waiting for an organ donor, xenotransplantation has become a very attractive alternative to human transplants, for obvious reasons. While there may be a shortage of human organ donors, we can easily envision animals being bred for their organs and providing an almost unlimited supply.

The major practical issue to be surmounted with any transplant is immunological. For a transplant to be successful the transplanted tissue must not...

... middle of paper ...

...cry. It might be one of my relatives.” That never did prevent him for eating it, however.

Bibliography

Anderson, Walter T. “Science Steps Across the Animal-Human Boundary: Fears of the

Chimera Reemerge.” Pacific News Service. 6 December 1995. Newspaper online. Available at http://www.pacificnews.org/jinn/stories/columns/heresies/950612-animal.html. Internet. Accessed 10 December 2003.

Everett, Margaret. “The Social Life of Genes: Privacy, Property and the New

Genetics.” Social Science and Medicine, 56 (2003): 53-65.

Olson, Eric T. “Was I Ever a Fetus?” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 57(1)

(1997): 95-109.

Rachels, James. Created From Animals: The Moral Implications of Darwinism. Oxford:

Oxford University Press, 1990.

Reiss, Michael J. “The Ethics of Xenotransplantation.” Journal of Applied

Philosophy, 17(3) (2000): 253-262.