Wombs Persuasive Speech

821 Words2 Pages

Thomas Beatie made medical history by being the first transgender man to bear a baby in 2008. It was not physically impossible because as a former female, his reproductive organs were still that of a woman. However, The Telegraph reported that soon, transgender women may be able to bear babies too. This time, it would involve the use of donated wombs. They can start to get pregnant as early as tomorrow, Dr. Richard Paulson, the president of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine, said. Additional challenges Paulson pointed out that if a womb could be successfully transplanted in a woman, there is no reason the procedure can be replicated on men. He admitted that there will be additional challenges, but Paulson could not find any obvious …show more content…

They instead suggested using a surrogate mother. Equalities law may force the NHS to allow the procedure to be extended to transgender women if womb transplantation would become available to natural women with reproductive problems. One of the experts opposed to womb transplant on transgender women is Professor Julia Savulescu, a bioethical specialist at Oxford University. He stressed that a uterine transplantation places a real risk to the fetus and the baby inside. Although it is technically possible to do the procedure, Savulescu added that the surgeon must be confident that the uterus would function normally while the patient is pregnant. He said it is exposing fetuses and future children to unnecessary risks. He cited uterine rupture that could kill or disable permanently the fetus. Savulescu does not favor taxpayer money being used to pay for womb transplantation for transgender women. Not a priority Arthur Caplan, the head of medical ethics at the New York University School of Medicine, agreed with Savulescu that despite the technical capability to transplant womb to transgender women, he does not favor the procedure. Because he views the procedure as not making the best use of American taxpayers’ money, Caplan said it will not get over the …show more content…

In addition, the wombs of other women are removed because of cancer or other medical conditions. Beatie, since 2008, had given birth to three children, while Trysten Reece, another transgender man, had his first biological child with partner Biff Chaplow in summer, The Sacremento Bee repo Uterus transplant Another important female reproductive organ, the uterus, has also been successfully transplanted in Sweden, Science Daily report. After 18 years of research by scientists at the University of Gothenburg, eight babies had been born to women who receive donate uterus in the last three years from September 2014. In the case of one woman, she already had two successful pregnancies with the transplanted uterus. Following the success of the procedure, the doctors at Gothenburg are now focusing on robot-assisted operations. The aim of using robots is to facilitate the challenge of performing surgery inside the pelvis of a woman shaped like a bowl. Mats Brännstrōm, a professor of obstetrics and gynecology at Sahlgrenska Academy and senior physician at the university hospital, said that the hypothesis of their study is to significantly speed up the procedure of uterus transplantation with the use of robots so the patient can return home

Open Document