Why Is Lizzie Borden Innocent

636 Words2 Pages

Murder, one of the worst crimes that can be committed by man, or woman. One murder that has managed to stay in the lime light through the years do to it’s arguably unproven and uncertain nature is the case of Mr. and Mrs.Borden, who were alleged to have been murdered by their own 33 year old daughter, Lizzie Borden. Much of this case went without clear and trustworthy explanation, sparking curiosity and debate even now. While there are many who believe that Lizzie Borden was guilty despite her acquittal, careful examination of the evidence proves that Lizzie borden is in fact innocent, just as the court had decided. To begin with, supporting evidence to Lizzie’s innocence is found in the testimony of John V. Morse. While Mr. and Mrs.Borden were indeed sick on the day of the murder, when asked if Lizzie was sick aswell Robert recalled that Mrs. Borden had told him that Lizzie was. This evidence is important because it tells us that if Mr. and Mrs.Borden had been sick due to poison, than Lizzie was poisoned as well. Providing also that when Lizzie neglected the fire which Bridget had asked her to tend to may have been due to Lizzie needing to nurse her illness. …show more content…

This reveal absolutely destroyed Lizzie, and threw her into a fit of panic. As stated in a newspaper account of the inquest Lizzie was sent "into a feint that lasted for several minutes, sending a thrill of excitement through awe-struck spectators and causing unfeigned embarrassment and discomfiture to penetrate the ranks of counsel". This is relevant because it shows us that Lizzie felt absolute disgust at the sight and perhaps even despair, I doubt that any murderer would be capable of such feelings towards the remains of their victims. And to claim this was just an act is simply throwing suspicion were it is not

Open Document