Why Is Jay Gatsby Wrong

1566 Words4 Pages

At first glance, the novel, The Great Gatsby, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, seems to be about with a man, Jay Gatsby, with the perfect life. The amazing and glamorous parties he throws have to stem from a place of hospitality right? Wrong. In actuality, he throws these parties in an attempt to lure a married woman, Daisy Buchanan, into his home in order to reunite a love from years ago. This just one of the many cracks in the smooth nature and character of Gatsby. Throughout the novel, Jay Gatsby proves himself to be far from great with episodes of corruption, selfishness, and god-like thoughts. For a while, the readers assume that Gatsby received his prosperity in a legal manner, inheriting it from his parents while also owning a line of pharmacies, …show more content…

For example, after Daisy drives Gatsby’s car and hits Myrtle,Tom’s mistress, he asks if she was killed and showed no signs of emotion, guilt, or concern for getting caught. This reveals that he did not care enough to stop the car and check to see if Myrtle was okay. Even though Daisy was driving, he continued on with her as if nothing was wrong except for Daisy’s emotional status. For example, after being informed that Myrtle was, in fact, dead, Gatsby states in a calm and collected way that, “[he] thought so; [he] told Daisy [he] thought so. It’s better that the shock should come all at once. She stood it pretty well” (143). With this phrasing, Gatsby almost seems like a mentor helping his student, Daisy, past the initiation of committing her first murder After this episode, the readers can conclude that if he was a semi-decent person who cared for human life, he would have done something to either help Myrtle herself or her grieving husband George. Also, due to his behavior, the readers can infer that this was not the first time he has witnessed death. His corruption is further intensified if the readers look back on what occurs before the accident: his argument with Tom Buchanan. As the two quarrel back and forth over who Daisy really loves, a look comes over Gatsby’s face that Nick describes as, “ He looked- and this is said in contempt for the babbled slander of his garden- as if he had killed a man”(134). Not only is this foreshadowing for the death that would occur just hours later, but it proves that not all of the rumors about him are far-fetched and that it is a very real possibility that he has committed murder. A great person would never wrongfully take a life, and even if he did, he would feel much guilt for his

Open Document