The Fall Of The House Of Usher Mental Illness

1250 Words3 Pages

“The Fall of the House of Usher,” one of Edgar Allan Poe’s most prevalent works, manifests the descent into madness within an arguably supernatural residence through gothic fiction. A mental illness provokes Roderick Usher, one of the last two direct descendants of the Usher family, to call upon a companion in boyhood, the narrator, to supervise and nurture him and his sister throughout their illness. However, as the house manifests itself as a paranormal being enclosed in its own atmosphere, the descent of the Ushers is questioned by critics due to the marginal reliability of the narrator with possible mental deterioration in his mental being a possibility. Throughout the story, the narrator is himself unstable and, therefore, gives us an …show more content…

”Although the narrator believes he is merely chronicling Roderick’s precipitous descent into madness, he is also documenting his own more subtle mental deterioration,” (Gruesser 80). The narrator, although attempting to remain rational and oppose the supernatural, manifested by his denial of all events deemed unbearably frightening, such as the sounds Roderick’s sister makes along with any of Roderick’s conclusions about the house, is inconsistently skeptical and uncertain towards his beliefs of the house’s ability. Whether the narrator enters the house sane or not is beyond the reader’s comprehension. However, as he familiarizes himself with the mysterious effects of inhabiting the house, his constant denial and pathetic attempts to downplay the events, in which he is consistently incorrect, provoke him to state, “There can be no doubt that the consciousness of the rapid increase of my superstition—for why should I not so term it?—served mainly to accelerate the increase itself. Such, I have long known, is the paradoxical law of all sentiments having terror as a basis,” (Poe 111), thus documenting his descent into madness. The narrator’s inability to deem the sounds of his sister escaping her premature burial something as rational as, “the work of the rushing gust,” (Poe 128), along with the …show more content…

The narrator manifests great uncertainty and is reluctant to convince himself of what he is observing, thus making it impossible for readers to deem the narrator reliable. For a narrator to display distress to where he may be considered, “highly troubled, [and] insecure,” (Howes 72), is confirmation that the he has conveyed these characteristics, along with others, throughout the story. However, the characteristics mentioned are all effects of the narrator’s mental isolation, and to be isolated with dread and uncertainty towards phantasmagoric ongoings is to encase optimal conditions for mental deterioration. Poe utilizes the metaphor of the windows to represent the inextricable nature of mental isolation within the house, “The windows were long, narrow, and pointed, and at so vast a distance from the black oaken floor as to be altogether inaccessible from within,” (Poe 113). The window’s excessive length and pointed attributes project the extents within the mind that are achievable, despite being a narrow path to insanity. Also, Poe is emphasizing how inescapable the mind is, as the windows are positioned a fair distance from the ground, with attempting to escape from the fortress of solitude remaining futile. Essentially, the injection of uncertainty into an inextricable mind, already terrorized and plagued, provided for the ultimate

Open Document