What Is The Purpose Of Montaigne's Essay Of Cannibals

898 Words2 Pages

In the essay, “Of Cannibals,” Montaigne describes the lives of an indigenous group in Brazil. He compares their beliefs and actions to those of his fellow countrymen during this time, and in many cases prefers the indigenous way of thinking. In this comparison, Montaigne groups all of European Renaissance society to one side because of the similar beliefs concerning imperialism, economics, and societal structure throughout most of the continent. During Montaigne’s time, these beliefs were based in aristocracy and territorial expansion, and will be further discussed later. The purpose of Montaigne’s essay is to criticize and challenge this Renaissance ideology in a time when Europeans were imposing themselves upon peoples in all corners of …show more content…

The Brazilians only fight neighboring tribes to prove their valor and uphold their honor. Montaigne also says, “Their disputes are not for the conquest of new lands, for these they already possess are so fruitful by nature, as to supply them without labour or concern, with all things necessary, in such abundance that they have no need to enlarge their borders.” These two details are in direct opposition to European attitudes of the time. Montaigne lived in an era of European exploration and conquest in continents like Africa and the Americas. The driving forces behind this expansionism were economic opportunities and competition between empires. Additionally, Europe’s prior history was filled with warfare between these same nations over land they all claimed as their own. Therefore, Montaigne uses this comparison to the indigenous group to criticize his own society’s reasons for warfare, and even suggests Europeans are without honor and valor. Montaigne also implies that this lack of honor and valor amongst Europeans stems from their aristocratic governments. These Kings and Queens promote an agenda of economic inequality and nationalism, while they are also unfit to rule. This is exemplified in the essay when one Brazilian describes the Europeans he meets as:
“Full and crammed with all manner of commodities, whilst, in the meantime, their halves were begging …show more content…

This is because it is in disagreement with the group’s belief in togetherness, which is characterized by their reference to one another as each other’s halves. Additionally, the Brazilian comments on the King’s frailty and inappropriate use of his power. Montaigne questions the man about this, and comments that when “asking him what advantage he reaped from the superiority he had amongst his own people (for he was a captain, and our mariners called him king), he told me, to march at the head of them to war.” This means that the indigenous group’s leader is honored to lead his people into their most noble task of warfare, and does not merely hide behind his troops and reap the benefits of their, and not his, bravery. Montaigne uses this encounter between the Brazilian and the King to make further commentary on the faults in his own society. It is obvious that he is dissatisfied with the wealth disparity in his country, and would like to see his people revolt to change this state. He also does not like his King or the idea of aristocracy, and wishes his leaders cared less about conquering lands and obtaining wealth, and more about the people they

Open Document