Were The Puritans Carl Degler Analysis

409 Words1 Page

In the provocative article, Were the Puritans Puritanical?, Carl Degler seeks to clarify the many misconceptions surrounding the Puritan lifestyle. He reveals his opinions on this seventeenth century living style, arguing that the Puritans were not dull and ultra-conservative, but rather enjoyed things in moderation. They had pleasures, but not in excess. The Puritans could engage in many pleasurable and leisurely activities so long as they did not lead to sin. According to the article, the Puritans believed that too much of anything is a sin. Degler writes about the misconceptions of Puritan dress, saying that it was the “opposite of severe”, and describing it as rather the English Renaissance style. Not all members of Puritan society …show more content…

Another misconception that Degler sought to clarify was the presence – or lack – of music in daily Puritan life. He argued that it was true that Puritans removed organs from their churches, however, it was not music itself that they were averse to, but more the presence of music in the church. The Puritans believed that the worship of God was to be free of ritualistic practices, so they eliminated music within the church. However, that did not stop them from enjoying music outside the walls of the church. Degler used the same argument for the enjoyment of art in Puritan life. They had no significant objections to art, but that could be due to the fact that there was so little of it present in the seventeenth century. Degler’s last argument was made on sexual activity. While the Puritans did engage in sexual relations, it was not until after marriage that they did so, and even then, Puritan marriages were based much more off of love and companionship than sexual activity. Puritans were not celibate, however they did not stress sexual relations as much as they stressed love and

More about Were The Puritans Carl Degler Analysis

Open Document