The Semplica-Girl Diaries By George Saunders

934 Words2 Pages

In his short story, “The Semplica-Girl Diaries”, the author George Saunders crafts an all too human tale as he shows the journal entries of the narrator, a husband and father of three who faces financial insecurity, and displays the effect money, whether in lack or excess, has on our actions and thoughts. The social setting of the story is almost identical to our current society, however there is a distinct divergence in the Semplica Girls, which are girls from impoverished backgrounds that hang by a wire in their heads as an odd, inhumane, and yet expensive, lawn ornament. In the pursuit of the “good life” for both his family and himself, the father places great importance on wealth in order to secure happiness, joy, and status through material …show more content…

The narrative criticizes the narrator’s actions and his views on the importance of money by the presence of Eva, his youngest daughter who detests the concept of the Semplica Girls, and by use of ambiguity and doubt in the journal entries, which casts a spotlight on the flaws of the narrator. Clearly, the work displays that the narrator is a flawed man, and he is not cast as a role-model for one to follow, however, the father is ultimately one I can relate to and understand, as while his actions deserve criticism, his motives do not. The father faces a confrontation with financial issues throughout the story, and in this we get exposure to his consumerist perception of material items, as well as his familial motives for why he pursues them. He wants to buy items of both prestige and comfort, not for the sake of pure ownership, but rather for his family, and specifically their self-perception. In the story, there are several confrontations with this as the father must manage his precarious position with the wishes of his daughters, and though it is near impossible for him to fulfill their wishes he …show more content…

To her, its simply “not nice” and she doesn’t understand why it is accepted. (18) This ultimately leads to her freeing the Semplica Girls, which inadvertently cause her family to be in dire financial straits. This action is in direct contrast to the actions of the dad, and shows a juxtaposition of Eva and the father, as Eva does a morally righteous deed in freeing the Semplica Girls, however causes incidental personal hardship to her family, while the father makes an immoral purchase in the case of the Semplica Girls, but this brings joy to Lilly. However, the harshest critic to the father is himself, specifically in how the journal entries are written. The ambiguity in the text introduces doubt and casts a shadow of uncertainty on what the narrator says. He will explain the financial hardships that his family is facing, and after a long tirade of explaining his debt, he simply says that they are just “stretched a bit thin these days.” (11) The narrator is presented as being in denial, and this causes his actions to be scrutinized by the reader. This style shows both his internal contradictions, but it also reveals some of the dark inner thoughts of the father. Most noticeably, this is on display when after the hardships of the escape of the Semplica Girls reveal themselves, the father wonders “if humans would not be better off living alone, individually in

Open Document