The Open Window Deception

656 Words2 Pages

Why do people lie? There are many answers to this question. A few include that they are afraid of the consequences if they tell the truth, want to avoid confrontation, or are lying to be nice. However, there are some people who lie just because they can or because they think it is amusing. This is the case of the niece, Vera, in the short story “The Open Window” by H. H. Munro. She doesn’t display any logical reason for her misleading of Mr. Nuttel. Clearly, the author of this short story does an outstanding job of portraying the theme of deception through his characters. First of all, Vera’s traits and the way that she sets up her lie greatly contributes to the theme of deception. In fact, she is the main symbol of dishonesty in …show more content…

Sappleton. The niece uses many details in her story to make it seem more realistic than if she had simply said they went out and never returned. She then adds to the eeriness of the story when she describes how she sometimes gets a feeling that “they will all walk in through that window.” This is her way of making Mr. Nuttel feel slightly unsettled in preparation for him to be completely bewildered. When Mrs. Sappleton enters the conversation, she goes on and on about her husband and brothers and how they will return shortly. Although she is not aware of it, she is doing Vera a great favor by making herself seem crazy and showing that Vera did not lie about the hunting trip. This makes Mr. Nuttel very uncomfortable, just as Vera was hoping for. Because of these details, Mr. Nuttel is extremely freaked out when the aunt’s husband and brothers appear, and dashes off without a word. Lastly, a factor of the short story “The Open Window” that adds to the theme of deception is how the niece continues to lie even after Mr. Nuttel is gone. She tells her aunt and the rest how Mr. Nuttel had a “horror of dogs,” even though he never said anything to her about dogs. Obviously, the fact that Vera continues to lie supports the idea that deception is simply entertainment for her. It also shows that she is very good at coming up with false information on the spot. She also

Open Document