The Killing Joke Alan Moore Analysis

1041 Words3 Pages

If you’re reading this, Alan Moore… What exactly is your damage? No matter how you look at it, Barbara Gordon got fucked over. As Batgirl, after Oracle, and just as a character in general, with the final punch being Alan Moore and Brian Bolland’s 1988 Batman: The Killing Joke. The comic itself is revolutionary, and such a staple of the community that it’s even become part of the curriculum for many a “Comics 101” course. Not that there’s a problem with that – because the book itself is full of amazing art, it defines the Joker as the character we know today and shows him in a moment of weakness, and it sparks constant debate about itself, usually regarding the ending. Yet what should be discussed about the book usually never is, and it’s one …show more content…

The writer, Alan Moore seems hung up on this idea, despite the obvious ethical issues with it. Peeking into his history as an author, there’s a theme. The man has penned more smash-hit comic books than you can count on one hand and won countless, well-deserved awards for them, yet every single one (including Watchmen and V for Vendetta) involves some kind of sexual assault, rape, or violence towards women. He insists on bringing questionable morals into his plots, which, quite frankly, is a very, very easy thing to avoid doing. Moore, who is actually not a fan of TKJ, brings to light how DC Comics, the publisher, basically gave him carte blanche with Barbara. According to Moore, Len Wein, the book’s editor, said, “Yeah, okay, cripple the bitch,” when Moore asked if he could cripple Barbara Gordon (Rayner). The, Moore admits that “they should have reigned [him] in, but they didn’t” (Rayner). Moore knew he probably shouldn’t have done it, but he did it …show more content…

Not only do readers gloss over the incident in discussion, but so does the story itself. TKJ never outright denies the sexual assault of Barbara Gordon, but it sure does try hard to avoid it. Nobody in the book ever says anything vaguely along the lines of “Barbara Gordon was sexually assaulted”. Not the doctors, not the police, and certainly not the Joker. Her father, Commissioner Gordon, has to put together the pieces himself while being tortured with the photos of the attack, and even then, it’s still pretty unclear. The assault is never even mentioned explicitly to Batman, who is one of Barbara’s closest friends and her former coworker. Barbara trusted Bruce, yet she can’t even bring herself to tell him about it. The way the aftermath of the attack is handled is just as bad as if the writers had denied the incident entirely. Whether or not the Joker actually raped Barb is still up for debate, but it doesn't actually matter. The entire sexual assault was wildly unnecessary on Moore’s part, because rape should never be used as a plot

Open Document