Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Comparison of two texts
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Chantell Ramirez Ms. Tobias English 3 GT-6th 12 January 2017 The Great Gatsby similarities and differences The Great Gatsby was written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, it was published in 1925. It was taken place in the roaring 20s’ and it was about the American dream, this was taken place before the Great Depression, everybody had no worries about the economy. The film was made in 2013 and it was directed by Baz Luhrmann. Between the film and the novel there was some differences that seemed minor but they affected the relationships between the characters that changed the way you thought of the characters. For example, in the film they didn’t go into detail about Nick and Jordan’s relationship or they made Daisy seem so innocent in the movie but …show more content…
The similarities in the novel say about the strongest points of the film are the scene when he gets the invitation to the “little party” because if Luhrmann didn’t include it, it would’ve seemed fake because Nick’s character isn’t the outgoing type. Comparing the book and the film gave a new perspective because Daisy was portrayed as a innocent girl who didn’t know her husband was cheating on her in the film, but in the novel we realize that she isn’t that thoughtless, she mostly cared about herself. I really enjoyed the little detail that was added at the end of the film when Nick adds “The Great” to the title of the novel he wrote about Gatsby because it tied the whole film together. In the novel Fitzgerald should’ve added “The Great” becuase it would’ve been so unique and interesting because you start thinking about the whole novel. In conclusion the film and the novel are great although the film might not be entirely similar to the novel but they added some stuff to the film that the novel didn’t have, but it worked. I thought the movie was better because I thought the ending of the movie was so much better than the novel ending. When Nick ends the film by adding “The Great” it made me tear up, because he was the only one who actually cared about Gatsby, all those people that would go to his parties never really cared about him, the majority of them didn’t know what Gatsby looked like, but Nick could’ve stopped being his friend after Gatsby took the fall for Daisy but no Nick wanted to know if Daisy called Gatsby because he knew Gatsby was madly in love with her. At the end of the film Gatsby dies a winner well he thinks he does, because when he gets the phone call he goes to get it but he is shot, he thinks he won Daisy but really it was just
F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel, “The Great Gatsby”, and Baz Luhrmann’s film, “The Great Gatsby”, both have similarities and contrasts between the two of them. The Great Gatsby is a novel and film taken place in the 1920s filled with wild parties, mysterious people, The American Dream, and most of all, love. There are several things that can be compared between the novel and film; such as the characters and the setting. There are also contrasts between the two as well; which is mainly involving the character Nick.
Although most of the characters were portrayed the best that they could be, Daisy was not. In the book Daisy is said to have “The voice of money” (Fitzgerald 127). However, in the movie she talks more sweetly and not at all how I expected her to be played. In the novel, Gatsby’s father shows up to the funeral and shows Nick the journal that Gatsby had had when he was younger and talks about how proud he is of Gatsby but unlike the novel, the movie does not have this scene (Fitzgerald 180-182). However, the movie shows that no one came to Gatsby’s funeral except all the paparazzi that showed up to take pictures of him in his casket (The Great Gatsby). I feel this should have really been included because it showed a little more insight into the life of Jay Gatsby. The last and final difference I have about this comparison is about the scene where Daisy is going to visit Nick for tea. The book really did not include many details about how Nick’s house looked after Gatsby had sent everyone over to “get it ready” (Fitzgerald 89-90). When this scene occurred in the movie, I was really thrown off because of how decorated it was. Especially all the flowers that had been brought over to Nick’s house. It was filled to the brim with flowers which made the scene more awkward than it should have
In many stories a reader sides with one or two characters for the whole story. In this book you may have sided with Daisy at the beginning but towards the end you despise her. Even with Nick Carraway the narrator of the story. The reader usually takes sides with the narrator of the story. Yet, at some points during the story I felt that Nick should have stopped Gatsby from using him. It was Nick’s own fault that he got caught up in Gatsby’s drama. Gatsby at first was a character a reader did not know much about. F. Scott Fitzgerald did so to keep Gatsby as a secret prize for later. It kept us readers wanting to keep reading and to learn more about Gatsby. Daisy’s character was very dynamic. At first, we see an innocent girl just exploring her love between two men. By the end of the story she turned into a coward and left the town as soon as she could. “Good writing” does not let a reader know what is to be expected. With the characters of this story a reader at many times struggled with who was right and wrong. The changing of the character’s emotions and personality contribute to the making of a great
Thesis: How does F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel, The Great Gatsby, compares the American Dream in today's generation and back in the 1920's-30's? What did the American Dream really mean and why? So why did this issue happen? Do you think America can change in the future? What is the american dream really about? When did the phrase: ‘american dream’ started? Have you ever wondered what the 20s and 30s were like back then? How can this so called dream ever bring hope to our country? These are all the questions I would like to know myself. I’ve found three online sources & one source from the novel that can help explain about the 20th century, the Gatsby novel, today's generation, and about Mr.Gatsby from the book.
The Great Gatsby is a parody of itself. While Fitzgerald tries hard not to make Gatsby and especially Daisy laughable personalities, this is where he ultimately fails. There's not enough ironic distance to his characters. As Gatsby, at least in the eyes of many critics, should represent the idea of the American Dream, the presentation of his character puts the whole concept in question again, without being intended as criticism. This is mainly the fault of another weak character in the novel, Nick Carraway.
The novel’s main protagonist, Nick Carraway, came from a sophisticated family; however, they didn’t have enough money to be labeled as “Old Money”. Still, in the book, Nick was more stiff-necked and at times, pretentious than his film counterpart. He shows his pretentious ways when he constantly refers to blacks as “Negroes”. He was also very observant, and he wasn’t very playful. His film counterpart, however, is far more playful. He literally jumps on top his cousin, Daisy! “Novel Nick” wouldn’t do such a thing. Also,“Novel Nick” was very judgemental. His film counterpart, however, isn’t as judgemental. In fact, we hear Nick’s inner thoughts more in the novel. The film calls for more spoken interaction between characters, so “Film Nick” doesn’t get the chance to be as judgemental. Lastly, the most striking contrast between the two appeared within the first five minutes of the movie. Nick is obviously adjudicated insane, and he is talking to his psychiatrist. On his psychiatrist’s paper, it says that Nick has a slew of issues, such as being “Morbidly Alcoholic” and having “Random Fits of Anger.” He is telling the story of Gatsby to his psychiatrist. In the novel, there was no reason for Nick telling the sto...
Although there was glamour in the party scene, it was highly impersonal. The characters in the movie seemed as if they were trying to hard to mimic the ones in the book. The characters in the movie didn't really bring their characters personalities to life. Though there is an exception to this, Leonardo DiCaprio did portray Jay Gatsby properly. The only problem with his character in the movie was that when he died no one shows respect come to the funeral, but in the book, his fathers comes and gives Nick some insight to the real James Gatz. The book was thoroughly quoted, but in times the quotes were cut and replaced with other translations of the actual line. That removed a lot of depth from certain quotes and
I have read many books during my life. The Great Gatsby was the only novel that I found to be magnificent. F. Scott Fitzgerald has made me realize that there are many aspects in life that need to be taken seriously. The Great Gatsby has struck me emotionally as well as physically - it contains both physical and emotional pain.
"The Great Gatsby" is a book full of passion. There is Gatsby 's passionate love for Daisy. There is Tom 's passion for money. When reading this book I realized that these people broke the American dream in their time. They couldn 't be happy when all they did was chase money. The Great Gatsby was full of themes, motif 's, and symbolism and the way that fitzgerald used his characters to get his point across of what it was like back them was marvelous. Gatsby just wanted the love of his life back, so he did everything he could so that he could support her. I think that out of every single character, Gatsby 's choices were the most pure. The only reason he wanted all of the money that he got was because he wanted to make the woman he loved happy,
Jay Gatsby’s funeral is a small service, not because that 's what was intended, but because no one bothered to show up. Nick wanted to give Gatsby the popularity he desired, even in death, but only three people were present in the end. Gatsby’s father, Henry C. Gatz, shows up unexpectedly from Minnesota because he heard about the news in the papers. He believes that the man who shot his son must 've been mad, that no one in their right mind could commit such a horrible act. Daisy and Wolfsheim, the people closest to Gatsby in the book, do not attend. This exemplifies that it was always about wealth and social status for them, including Tom, and they never genuinely cared for Gatsby. Nick held up hope,
In conclusion, Baz Luhrmann's version of the film adaptation to The Great Gatsby was in fact very successful and faithful to the novel. The casting was indeed almost perfect because most of the actors such as Toby Maguire (Nick Carraway), Jay Gatsby (Leonardo DiCaprio), Carey Mulligan (Daisy Buchanan), Joel Edgerton (Tom Buchanan) and Jason Clarke (George Willson) all portrait their character wonderfully as described in the novel. The sceneries were great because it was very descriptive compared to the scenes in the novel. The use of Computer Generated Imagery technology was perfect because it highlighted the sceneries making it very vivid, realistic and pleasurable to the eye. The costuming used in the film was very creative, wonderful and perfect because it suited each of the characters class, personality, and it also suited the time period of the 1920s.
In conclusion the Great Gatsby 2013 film adaptation is a piece of work that will be remembered for its stunning visuals not a gripping storyline. However this forgettable story is somewhat salvaged by the characterization of Jay Gatsby who shines through as someone to watch the movie just to see. The movie is quite split when it comes to the historical accuracy. Topics like Fashion and modes of transportation are not accurately represented while topics like race relations and the setting of New York City in the roaring 20s are excellently and accurately portrayed. In my opinion this movie with its masterful visual direction and the deep character Gatsby is a movie worth seeing. Who knows you could have a totally different opinion.
The great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald is a popular book that was published in the early 1900s. An adaptation of the book by the same name was released in 2013 and directed by Baz luhrmann. The book and film are both relatively the same with a few minor differences. The story follows a young wealthy man named Jay Gatsby, who is deeply in love with a woman named Daisy Buchanan. His real name is James Gatsby and initially was a very poor man, he had told Daisy to be patient for him, as he was determined to become rich so that he can provide her with whatever she wanted in life.
Movies can enhance the experience of a story, but they aren’t always completely accurate to the book. The movie, The Great Gatsby, by Baz Luhrmann, is a good representation of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel; however, there are quite a few differences between the two. Some differences include; the portrayal of the characters, the importance of symbolism, and events that were either added or taken out of the movie.
As an American citizen we seem to make presumption that all cultures are different from ours, and some might even call those cultures weird. Americans fail to realize just how similar we are to these “weird” cultures. By reading Things Fall Apart, by Chinua Achebe and The Great Gatsby by F.Scott Fitzgerald , it makes the reader realize how similar the African culture is from the American culture. There 's those obvious differences we already knew about with the two cultures, but readers can learn that not just American culture value men and give them advantages, but many cultures including 1900 's African culture. In both books we come across two main characters that is portrayed as being more superior compared to others. Okonkwo, main