The Foolish Puritans of The Scarlet Letter

1782 Words4 Pages

The Foolish Puritans of The Scarlet Letter

"What is one man's poison is another's meat or drink," Beaumont and

Fletcher wrote in one of their plays. Almost everything in the world is

interpretable in at least two conflicting ways. In The Scarlet Letter, the

Puritan society shuns a character named Pearl, yet the author, who lived in

the Romantic period, views her with awe and reverence. Nathaniel

Hawthorne's use of nature imagery in The Scarlet Letter reflects Pearl's

wild, capricious character that serves as a constant reminder of Hester's

sin and whose romantically idealistic beauty frightens the Puritan society.

In Hawthorne's descriptions of Pearl as an infant and toddler,

nature imagery emphasizes Pearl's startling beauty and unpredictable, yet

innocent, character. Pearl's beauty and innocence are apparent from the

time of her birth. Hawthorne describes Pearl's "innocent life [as] a lovely

and immortal flower"(Hawthorne 81). Even though Pearl is a product of the

"guilty passion"(81) between Hester and Dimmesdale, both her soul and her

body are untainted and flawless. Hester notices that Pearl has no physical

defects, but Pearl's character has an unexplainable aspect of oddity and

unpredictability. When she plays near Hester's cottage, Pearl "[smites]

down [and] uproot[s] most unmercifully [the] ugliest weeds"(87) which she

pretends are the Puritan children. Hester believes that Pearl is so

emotional and temperamental because the passion which Hester and

Dimmesdale experienced during their sinful act somehow transferred into

Pearl's soul. However, Pearl's antipathy for the Puritans is justified; the

children often torment her for no good reason. When Hester and Pearl go

into town, the Puritan children stop playing and either surround Pearl and

stare at her or prepare to hurl mud at the unfortunate pair. Both actions

by the Puritans result in a fit of outrage by Pearl. One reason that the

Puritans treat Pearl badly is because of her mother's sin. The Puritans

believe that since Pearl is the product of adultery, she is automatically

evil and depraved. The Puritan hatred for Pearl is also due to the fact

that she, like Hester's scarlet letter, is beautiful, and they are in a way

jealous of both. Supposedly, Hester's scarlet 'A' is a punishment, but she

embroiders it richly and wears it with subtle pride. When the Puritans

first see the 'A', they want to replace it with an 'A' made out of

Open Document