The Failure Of The Popham Colony

637 Words2 Pages

The lost colony of Popham was on the brink of being successful, and was nearly one of the most significant places in American History. The purpose of the Popham Colony was to test out colonization in America. However it didn’t end up succeeding due to a singular death, leadership flaws, and little preparation. Even though the colony was unsuccessful, it is still significant due to its failure. This is because it’s failure set up the success of future colonies.
Popham Colony was one of the very first colonies, and ended up serving as a test run. Beckenstein says, “Popham was the cornerstone in the foundation of English America,” says Jeffrey P. Brain, 64, an archaeologist with the Peabody Essex Museum in Salem, Massachusetts, who is excavating …show more content…

Andrews says, “Popham only lasted a year before a breakdown in leadership brought about its collapse” (Andrews, Evan). This is because their first leader died, and their second leader ended up only caring about his own personal gain. This can be seen when Beckenstein says, “The main reason for abandoning the colony, Brain theorizes, was a loss of leadership. Only one member of the group, George Popham, is known to have died at Fort St. George. (Jamestown lost more than half of its 120 settlers the first year.) But he was the colony’s president, and on February 5, 1608, Raleigh Gilbert took command... a resupply ship brought Gilbert news that he had inherited a title and an estate back in England. When Gilbert decided to return to England to collect, the others headed back with him. “They were headless, so to speak,” Brain says. “English society was very stratified; people needed leaders.” Bad relations with the Indians, the fear of another severe winter and the area’s lack of easily exploitable resources, such as gold or other precious metals, also affected the decision to abandon Popham” (Beckenstein, Myron). The people didn’t have good enough leaders, and were not prepared enough to appoint another one, so essentially they just gave up and sailed back to England. Even though the colony failed so close to their goal, the first English colony still holds …show more content…

Beckenstein says, “Popham’s value lies in its failure. Its remains, discovered only nine years ago, have been called one of the most significant archaeological sites in the country. Unlike Jamestown, Popham’s successful sister colony in Virginia, whose footprint changed as it developed, Popham represents a unique, undisturbed time capsule of a very early North American settlement” (Beckenstein, Myron). So, Popham’s failure did have some benefits. It helped the colonies that came after it by paving the way for their survival. It is a fairly important piece of American history because of this, but certainly not one of the most important(although it could have been). Popham may have nearly succeeded, but the fact that it failed is where its importance

Open Document