Terraphase Engineering Inc. V. Arcadis: A Case Study

605 Words2 Pages

One way of communicating with people and keeping them updated with information is through digital communication. Law firms consider this as a possible way to communicate with clients when handling their cases. However, mistakenly sent information can become an ethical issue. This is called “attorney-client privilege”, meaning the attorney has the duty to keep all confidential information of the client private. Although, attorneys deemed digital communication as a great method this information can be misdirected and shared with the opposing party.
In Terraphase Engineering, Inc. v. Arcadis, U.S., Inc., No. C 10-04647 JSW (N.D. Cal. Dec. 17, 2010). plaintiff’s attorney mistakenly sent a strategy email to his clients containing an attachment that contained plaintiff’s privileged recitation of background and comments to and from the legal counsel. However, the email …show more content…

Yet, Arcadis opposed the motion and argue that the information received was not privileged since it was sent unsolicited to the plaintiff’s email. Arcadis further argue that the plaintiff would suffer no irreparable harm considering that the email would be disclosed during discovery. Arcadis also asserted that the email received was before the parties litigate therefore there was no rule of professional conduct violated. The court denied Arcadis arguments and disqualified the outside counsel and the in-house counsel, who had reviewed the information from the email. The court ordered Arcadis to dismiss its counterclaim and re-filed only without reference to any of the disclose privileged information. Therefore, the court granted the motion for a protective

Open Document